Business Daily (Nairobi)
Mammo Muchie
13 November 2007
opinion
Ethiopia as a nation of nearly 80 million people makes it amongst the three most populous countries in Africa. Peace and political and ideological stability is not only critical for Ethiopia, it is also even more critical to all the peoples, states and regions of the wider Horn of Africa and indeed Africa in general.
Any project to break this country is fraught with the danger that 80 million people will be dispersed throughout the world. That is not acceptable to any one. Look at what is happening in Somalia. The citizens have been dispersed and they are suffering everywhere away from home .
Breaking and blackmailing the national framework and creating ethnically and vernacularly organised states will be difficult to sustain in Ethiopia in the long run.
Imagine how difficult it has been and indeed a nightmare it still is to construct a security community after Eritrea broke away. We had war five years after Eritrea's referendum in 1993. There is now a talk that another war is brewing.
Although the Ethiopian Government swears it has no intention to go to war, the Eritrean Government has produced statements after statements accusing Ethiopia and foreign powers of being behind Ethiopia and are plotting to start another conflagration.
Given Ethiopia's involvement in Somalia, it would be truly foolhardy to open another war front. Why the drums of war threats are hovering over the region is beyond anything one can comprehend.
The problem is that often we do not know who is lying and who is telling the truth. All we can say is that there is remotely no good reason for one to attack the other .
However exasperating and confounding, what happens between the elites in Eritrea and Ethiopia, the fact remains that the separation they promoted without clear appreciation of the consequences did not resolve the problem by silencing the guns or stop war and violence from recurring.
What this means is that any effort to break Ethiopia by following the Eritrean example is likely to create more problems than bring solutions for stabilising the region .
Any war that the elite in Eritrea has been warning will break out will be indeed a monumental crime if it breaks out, as the alternative to negotiate and solve amicably any problem is open except for the intransigence and bellicosity of the elite that rule Ethiopia and Eritrea by splitting the country into two.
Prof Muchie is the Director of Development, Innovation and International Political economy, Aalborg University, Denmark.
Read comments. Write your own.
Copyright © 2007 Business Daily. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
Sir, Every body know the Italian came from their country to invade Abyssinia not to Invade Eritrea or creat Eritrea. the Italian simply capture piece of land from Abyssia and used it for lauching to invede Abyssina and they call it what ever they want. By the way are n't we Eritrean the main Abyssinian? Sure We are check the history. The Italian finaly caputer the whole Abyssinia,and after 5 years they defeated WW2.
Thank you.
Dear Sir,
I appreciate your comments about the problems that seccession can cause. However, I strongly object to your sentence. Quote - ‘The problem is that often we do not know who is lying and who is telling the truth. All we can say is that there is remotely no good reason for one to attack the other.’ And I would not compare Eritrea to the Regions in Ethiopia. Eritrea has a legal right to be independent – as all post colonial states in the world do.
The conflict between the two countries has primarily got to do with their… [Read Full Text]