Kaisernetwork.org (Washington, DC)
2 May 2008
Politics and Policy
Canadian Government Committed 'Breach' of Scientific Standards by Interfering in Vancouver's Supervised Drug-Injection Site, Researchers Say
Across The Nation
Magic Johnson Calls for More HIV Testing Among Blacks in D.C.
Global Challenges
Rapid Population Growth in Uganda Affecting Efforts To Fight HIV/AIDS
Shanghai, China, To Establish Four New Methadone Clinics To Curb Spread of HIV, Health Officials Say
Times of Central Asia Examines HIV/AIDS Epidemic, Related Stigma, Discrimination in Tajikistan
Politics and Policy
Canadian Government Committed 'Breach' of Scientific Standards by Interfering in Vancouver's Supervised Drug-Injection Site, Researchers Say
[May 02, 2008]
Canadian government officials committed a "serious breach of international scientific standards" by intervening in an independent scientific review of the supervised drug-injection facility Insite in Vancouver, British Columbia, according to an article recently published in the International Journal of Drug Policy, Toronto's Globe and Mail reports (Picard, Toronto's Globe and Mail, 5/2).
Insite, which is funded by the British Columbia provincial government and has received research funding from the Canadian government, includes 12 booths for injection drug users to inject drugs as well as a "chill-out" room, in which users can be monitored for overdoses. At the site, drug users receive clean needles, tourniquets, water and cotton balls, and a nurse supervises their activities and provides them with referrals to detox centers and homeless shelters. Vancouver has one of the highest illegal drug use rates in North America, with as many as 12,000 IDUs in the Vancouver metropolitan area, 30% of whom are HIV-positive and 90% of whom have hepatitis C.
When the facility opened in September 2003, it received a three-year exemption from the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, which bans heroin use, to conduct a pilot study on the site's role in reducing drug use and crime in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside. Health Canada, the country's health ministry, in October of last year announced it would extend the exemption until June 2008 (Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report, 10/4/07). According to the Globe and Mail, Insite operators are currently appealing to the British Columbia Supreme Court to extend the exemption for the facility.
Health Ministry Involvement
An independent scientific body advised Health Canada in 2006 to recommend that funding for the project be extended and that similar programs be established in other cities, the Globe and Mail reports. However, Health Minister Tony Clement said he could not approve the recommendations, citing inadequate research and unsound public health policy. The government later offered grants to further research the effectiveness of drug-injection sites in preventing HIV, under the condition that investigators not release their findings until after the exemption expires. Evan Wood -- a research scientist at the B.C. Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS and lead author of the journal article -- said the offer amounted to "muzzling researchers." The University of British Columbia considered that condition ethically unacceptable, and its researchers did not apply for the grants.
The journal article states that Clement's actions were taken on the advice of police organizations and based on political concerns over sound health policy, according to the Globe and Mail. Wood noted that there have been 22 peer-reviewed studies published on the Insite program that found it reduces rates of HIV/AIDS and increases opportunities for IDUs to seek rehabilitation. "From a scientific perspective, it's descipable," Wood said, adding, "Governments should not handpick grants based on ideology."
Rita Smith, a spokesperson for Clement, said on Thursday that the researchers' comments were "completely inaccurate." She added that Clement "commissioned more research" about safe drug-injection facilities and had Health Canada form an independent committee to compile a report on domestic and international research on the subject.
Reaction
Perry Kendall, British Columbia's provincial health officer, said he agreed with the journal article. "I'm a realist enough to know that public policy is not based solely on science, but you would hope that policy would be strongly swayed by science, particularly in health care," he said. Kendall said that injection drug use has caused government to intervene as it would never do in other areas. "If there was a validated intervention for hernia repair, would we accept that the government steps in and says, 'We don't like hernia repair'? I don't think so," he said.
In a related IJDP commentary, Robert MacCoun of the Goldman School of Public Policy at the University of California-Berkeley, called the Insite issue a "policy horror story." He wrote that the evidence demonstrates that a "well-executed piece of policy research on a promising innovation was discontinued for unstated but blatant political reasons." MacCoun also wrote that Clement's questioning of whether Insite lowers drug use and addiction misses the point that such programs are designed to reduce harm that IDUs do to themselves and others, which a law cannot achieve (Globe and Mail, 5/2).
Link to this story.
Across The Nation
Magic Johnson Calls for More HIV Testing Among Blacks in D.C.
[May 02, 2008]
As part of his "I Stand With Magic" campaign, former National Basketball Association player Earvin "Magic" Johnson on Wednesday during a roundtable discussion at Howard University encouraged blacks residing in Washington, D.C., to be tested for HIV, WTOPnews.com reports.
The "I Stand With Magic" campaign, a partnership between the Magic Johnson Foundation and Abbott Laboratories, aims to reduce the number of new HIV cases among minority communities by increasing awareness and knowledge about the disease. In 2006, the district had the highest rate of new AIDS cases among blacks in the country, WTOPnews.com reports.
Johnson said it is a challenge within the black community for people to get tested for HIV. He added, "We finally get over the fear of getting tested, and then we finally go get tested, and then people say, 'Uh-oh, I don't want to know the results.'" Johnson noted that if the black community "did know, in terms of educating ourselves about HIV, then we would know we can still high-five [an HIV-positive] person, we can still play basketball against them."
According to WTOPnews.com, no-cost, rapid HIV tests were provided at the Howard forum. Shannon Hader, head of the city's HIV/AIDS Administration, said there are a lot of HIV/AIDS services available for people in the district, adding, "But that doesn't mean people know about them or believe in them" (Basch, WTOPnews.com, 5/1).
Essence Profiles Health Workers' Efforts To Fight HIV/AIDS in the District
In related news, Essence magazine on Thursday examined the HIV/AIDS epidemic in the district and the efforts by some community health workers to reduce the spread of the disease. According to Essence, community health workers from the Family and Medical Counseling Service and other groups have set up mobile HIV testing centers and travel throughout the city providing information on the epidemic (Owens, Essence, 5/1).
Link to this story.
Global Challenges
Rapid Population Growth in Uganda Affecting Efforts To Fight HIV/AIDS
[May 02, 2008]
Rapid population growth in Uganda is undermining efforts to fight the spread of HIV/AIDS, Uganda AIDS Commission Director General Kihumuro Apuuli said Wednesday at a press briefing in the capital of Kampala, New Vision/Allafrica.com reports. Apuuli spoke with journalists ahead of the four-day HIV/AIDS global implementers meeting scheduled to start June 3 in Kampala.
Be the first to Write a Comment!
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
