The Voice (Francistown)
Nomsa Ndlovu
13 May 2008
Francistown — They have no nationality. Both the Botswana and the Namibian governments deny them citizenship; and for Maveo Mokove family of Ngarange Village in the Okavango District, that is a matter of life and death.
Mokove, his wife and children have lived a life of wandering between the two countries and this has left them destitute, their children denied education and with no national identity.
They have been deported from this country several times only to return because the Namibian government also repudiates them as its nationals.
But they have no qualms with the Namibian government, insisting they are Batswana; and the villagers agree.
The disputed nationality has not only left psychological trails, hunger and desperation but a bleak future for their children and grand children who are being denied education.
In 2004, Mokove's children - Ben, Patrick, Mary and Kasanga Eshevo - were removed from Ngarange Primary School by law enforcement authorities while doing standard seven, six and four, respectively. Mokove's youngest daughter Naledi, 8, and her seven-year-old cousin, Ida, have also been denied admission to the school.
When The Voice arrived at the Mokove residency in Ngarange last Saturday, we found his wife cracking the nuts of a Mongongo tree for lunch. Besides this, she said, "we survive on wild vegetables, fruits and herbs, at times begging for mealie-meal from neighbours after they have received a ration of their destitute packages from the council."
Mokove, who is a traditional doctor, was away from home but The Voice later managed to speak with him through the mobile phone.
Mokove told how, after being dumped at Omega in Namibia in 2004, they discovered that there was no longer an army barracks but a village. "People in the village did not know us so was the village chief who plainly told us in front of the immigration officers that he had no land to allocate to Batswana. We loitered around without shelter," he said.
Homeless and hungry, the Mokoves found no other way but to barter their clothes and property for food. But they were soon without, and the hunger pangs returned.
"One day we were called at a scene to find Ben being untied from a tree after hanging himself. He was still alive. When we later asked him why he had done that he told us that there was a lot of suffering in Namibia; he wanted to return to Botswana and go back to school. Both my wife and I cried."
Then a few days later, their daughter disappeared.
"We followed her tracks, and she had crossed over to Botswana where she arrived and joined his uncle's family," said Mokove, speaking through an interpreter, as the family knows no other language but the Sesarwa (San) dilect spoken in the area.
Despite the Botswana government's insistence that the Mokoves are not Batswana, village chief Tshosa Tshego, Councillor Mbathira Ngundura and most elderly Hambukushu and Basarwa of Ngarange insist otherwise. They even confirm knowledge of Mokove's birthplace, Tobera, a cattle post in the Okavango district.
His wife, elders insist, is a daughter of a Mosarwa woman who migrated to Namibia during the Boer regime. Then she was married to a man called Okahare, who has since passed on. She had a son with her late husband, whom she relocated to Namibia with and where she was employed as a maid in the apartheid army barracks.
Kgosi Tshego and other elders confirmed Mokove was born to the late Mosarwa man named Mokove Ngavangava. They pointed his ruins at a place called Mahahe, approximately three kilometers between Kauxwi and Ngarange villages.
Tshego said he first met Mokove in their youth in the 1950s.
He revealed that the young Mokove then joined the migration of Basarwa to Namibia.
"We later heard that Mokove had been employed as an army driver and was stationed at Omega barracks where he met his present wife and bore children with her."
In Namibia, he had first met and married a local woman who later died leaving him with some children. "When he met his second and present wife, the woman accepted a parental role to Mokove's children and the family joined as one. That is why when we were repatriated back to Botswana after the independence of Namibia, Mokove came back with all his brood including those from his former wife," said a village elder.
But, according to Botswana laws, if Mokove's marriage was not a civil one, the children inherit their mother's citizenship. The law clashes with the Sesarwa custom. In Sesarwa and Hambukushu cultures, Kgosi Tshosa explained, children belong to their fathers and inherit their names with or without marital bonds.
Tshosa, however, says that when other Batswana returned home in government organized transport, using the Ngoma boarder, ignorant of the law, Mokove and hundreds of other Basarwa in Seshokora settlement and Gudigwa village resorted to their old unlawful entry routes.
"On his arrival, he came to me and announced his return and I accepted him. As I assisted other repatriates to obtain their identity cards, I also made sure that he and his wife got theirs. But in 2004, the police and immigration officers arrived in the village and took them away without consulting us. We also heard that their Omang (Identity Cards) had been repossessed and they had been deported back to Namibia," revealed the chief.
When they returned again, they once again made it known to the chief. "I went to the immigration and told them that the people that they have denounced as Namibians had returned. They promised to return and collect them but they never did up to this date."
The Mokove's plight has been taken up at the highest level.
During the Northwest District full council meeting last week, Councillor Mbathira Ngundura demanded to know why the National Identity Card registration department was keeping mum over the issue despite the fact that it had promised to investigate it.
"We have been kept waiting for too long and now it is time for us to be told the department's resolution to the matter. Those people are suffering destitutes who cannot even be enrolled in any poverty alleviation programs that the government runs," complained the councilor.
In response, the department's assistant director, Hebert Mlandu, said that the matter has long been discussed in Parliament and investigations carried out. He said it was established that Makove and his family are Namibians and the government of Botswana is not mandated to provide for them until they follow the right channels of applying for residence permits and later acquiring their citizenship.
But Councillor Olatotswe Serefo of Gudigwa reminded all of a similar case two years ago, where the Basarwa of Seshokora and Gudigwa had their IDs impounded, only for District Commissioner Bernadette Malala of Maun to discover they were indeed Batswana.
Be the first to Write a Comment!
Copyright © 2008 The Voice. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
