Karima Brown
20 May 2008
column
Johannesburg — WHILE it is well and good to blame the government for not having proper policies in place to deal with SA's refugee crisis, the violence against foreign Africans is a reflection of something far uglier.
Granted, the government has consistently displayed a tin ear when it comes to the sheer scale of our refugee crisis, especially since the economic and political meltdown in Zimbabwe in recent years . The lack of leadership from the government in recent weeks is also not helping. This leadership vacuum comes from the top. After a week of violence that left several people dead, all President Thabo Mbeki could mutter at the weekend was that the police must act firmly and arrest the culprits and that a panel would be set up to look at the underlying causes of the violence.
When in doubt, appoint a panel. Mbeki's government has become so adept at obfuscation that setting up commissions, panels and conducting audits in the face of any crisis seems like a national pastime. The police's conduct also leaves much to be desired. Apart from promising to retaliate with live ammunition should they be fired at, the South African Police Service has done very little to get to the bottom of how marauding groups of armed men can go from place to place and attack whoever they deem to be foreigners.
It is also common knowledge that the police are not free of the xenophobia that is so present in communities. Police harassment of foreign Africans in places such as Hillbrow, Yeoville and other inner- city communities is well known.
But what the recent pogroms in Gauteng townships point to is not just state failure. South African society as a whole stands condemned. The violence exposes shortcomings in our society at a moral, social and political level. Considering the solidarity shown during our struggle against apartheid by our neighbours in the frontline states, the killing of foreign Africans in a so-called liberated SA is particularly appalling. Not only did many on the continent endure military attacks, they also provided shelter, food and even employment to thousands of exiles when they needed it most. Now that it is our turn to provide sanctuary and solidarity, we repay our neighbours with murder and rape.
While it is true that there is a scramble for resources in poor communities that is often exploited by local strongmen for political gain, it does not provide all the answers to the senseless violence and the finger-pointing at foreigners. These communities have always been badly off, yet we have not seen the level of violence of recent weeks.
Moreover, the silence from community organisations such as civic structures, local churches and other grassroots bodies in the wake of the attacks is simply deafening. This silence points either to acquiescence on the part of local leaders or a complete demobilisation on the part of community organisations that formed the backbone of resistance during the struggle years. Whatever the reasons, it points to a dangerous vacuum that has already been exploited with deadly consequences.
Apart from the Central Methodist Church in Johannesburg, which plays a vital role in providing sanctuary to vulnerable refugees, why are our spiritual leaders not responding to the cries of the victims of the recent violence with more vigour? As vulnerable women and children flee their homes, where is the moral leadership of the country?
Since the outbreak of attacks in Alexandra, the African National Congress leadership has spoken out, but it is simply not enough, especially if one considers that the violence is spreading and could soon engulf the province. Is it not ironic that most, if not all, of the victims happen to be fellow Africans? This cruel reality blows out of the water any notions of pan-Africanism, never mind the African renaissance so often spoken of by Mbeki and other politicians. Clearly our isolation during apartheid did not only trap whites in an unsustainable bubble, it also insulated the majority from the world including, importantly, our neighbours in the region.
Brown is political editor.
Read comments. Write your own.
Copyright © 2008 Business Day. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
Violence in all its forms must be condemned. This particular kind of violence against foreigners must be condemned even more vehemently. But when the emotions are down, and sobriety and objectivity back, South Africans must take stock about what went wrong.
Progroms, as Karima rightfully used the word, have always been occassioned by perceived or real economic grievances. As South Africans for whatever reasons we do not have the resources to accommodate all the poor people from the rest of Africa.
We have through neglect or ommission pitted our own poor against the poor illegal immigrants for scarce & dwindling resources. Elsewhere refugees stay in camps and receive aid from the UN, Oxfam, and other aid agencies. No country in the world in which you can just come in, and set up shop and sell cocaine the following day unhindered by police. This is the real world, controls are not a luxury but a necessity. The government has resoundingly failed us.
Every African country has illegal and legal immigrants in South Africa. This is too much for any government anywhere in the world. But it does not allow us to kill foreigners.
In France , and Germany and UK there are politicians that run on the anti-immigrant policies. South Africa does not have this, which is a good sign. This week Italy on Euronews blamed Romanians for 35% of all the local crimes in Rome. We are not alone with this kind of problem. The US fights a losing battle against South American illegal immigrants. The Spaniards are losing against the tide of illegal West Africans. The Chinese illegals pitch up suffocated to death in goods containers in the UK.
Ironically, the shanty towns have mushroomed after 1994. South Africa had its own rural-urban migration problems that were triggered by the collapse of the Apartheid state. For the rest of Africa, South Africa is the Eldorado: the land of infinite opportunities. But South Africa is a capitalist state: where very rich people live side by side with abjectly poor people. Who can afford not to be capitalist in a post 9/11 and paranoid global village?
While in the short term the solution is the shooting of rioters and protection of civilians, in the long term we need controls to stem the tide of poor immigrants and put our house in order. If you have prepared diunner for six, you cannot accommodate 600. Zimbabwe is not our problem, all we can do is help where we can.
The false idea that South Africans were hosted by the rest of Africa does not help either. South Africans didnt send its poor en masse to Zambia, Tanzania, Angola and Uganda to compete with the host country poor. We are not dealing here with political exile but with illegal economic migration. And we need to be sober minded and tackle the problem and not compound it with ill-based political correctness.
The African Unity parliament must work out immigration protocols and regulations that will help us to solve this problem. We need scholars and intellectuals to help us with ideas on how to tackle illegal economic migration: a unique 21st century global problem.
And unfortunately we are a nation baptised in violence. Violence has been a way of life in South Africa since Jan van Riebeeck built a garrison to defend the Dutch and Shaka Zulu started his Crushing wars. We have under 400 years of institutionalised violence. Our best exports to the world are army hardware and mercenaries. Whether we strike for better wages or HIV awareness somehow it must end in violent confrontation. Even a harmless child trespassing on a farm is shot to death in South Africa. Some get shot to death for a mere cellphone. This is unapologetically us.
And we have another kind of subtle violence, where we neglect the poor, and barricade ourselves into fotresses and enjoy inordiante fruits of economic success. It is neither wrong nor right, but it is a sure recipe that one day we shall all wake up and find ourselves besieged by the invisible poor people in our midst. We fail to see them, hear them or talk to them.
To the victims, I am humbly ashamed and we apologise unreservedly.