Published by the government of Zimbabwe
3 July 2008
Harare — A SENIOR MDC member yesterday said the opposition should unreservedly recognise President Mugabe as the constitutionally-elected Head of State and Commander-in-Chief of the Zimbabwe Defence Forces if meaningful political dialogue is to be initiated.
Mr Gabriel Chaibva's comments came as the MDC-T top leadership - Morgan Tsvangirai and his secretary-general Tendai Biti - have issued contradictory statements regarding their party's position on talks with Zanu-PF.
While Tsvangirai and Biti want the presidential run-off result to be considered null and void, Mr Chaibva said it was time the opposition leadership accepted the reality that President Mugabe is the Head of State.
"Unless Arthur Mutambara and Morgan Tsvangirai are prepared to approach President Mugabe, shake his hand and say 'Mr President', we will not move forward and there can be no talks," said Mr Chaibva.
On his suspension as MDC spokesperson for attending President Mugabe's inauguration on Sunday, Mr Chaibva said he had no regrets over the suspension because in the long term what he did was the right thing.
"In 2002, we said we would not recognise President Mugabe's legitimacy and where did that get us? We cannot keep on engaging in actions that do not take the nation forward. It is time to think of the wishes of the people," he said.
He said there was a serious lack of visionary leadership, strategy, clear ideological orientation regarding the land issue and lack of effective organisational capacity.
"We have to be frank with ourselves and admit our failures. But, more importantly, we have to be honest with ourselves and do what is expected of us as leaders.
"Political confrontation and polarisation has not helped and we need to now sit down and move forward," Mr Chaibva said.
Mr Chaibva said the opposition had under-estimated Zanu-PF and overestimated itself hence the continued friction that could lead to its total collapse.
"We risk a complete and total rejection of the people. Let's be frank, even if the African Union was to come and organise another election you will be surprised to find most people would vote for President Mugabe. So, our politics should be relevant to the people and that is why we have to talk and chart a new way forward," he said.
He urged the opposition leadership not to be foolish because the people would leave them behind as they moved forward saying the people do not vote for change in the context of getting a new president.
"They do it in the context of socio-economic change. And as leaders we must be at the forefront of working for that change. We should forget personal ambitions and put the people first," he said.
Mr Chaibva added that as a senior in the MDC he was aware of foreign influence in opposition politics, which needed to be cast aside to create ground for dialogue.
"Some people will say it is not true but I will tell you it is there and it was quite influential in perpetuating disunity in the opposition.
"When the MDC split, we made it clear that we were for land redistribution. We were nationalist and pan-African.
"But the providers of capital see this as a threat to their permanent economic interests in Zimbabwe. That is why just before the elections the two MDCs failed to unite.
"The Americans and the Germans produced a report telling Tsvangirai that he would win 85 percent of the vote on March 29 and that he didn't need the support of Mutambara. It's ironic really that they thought they would get 85 percent."
Mr Chaibva reiterated that Zimbabweans should not lose this opportunity for dialogue and national reconciliation, pointing out that failure to do so could lead to dire consequences for the opposition.
"In 1992, Angola held elections between President Eduardo dos Santos and Jonas Savimbi and it ended in a run-off.
"Savimbi decided to listen to his foreign backers and boycotted the poll and the country descended into chaos that ended in his own death resulting in a weakened Unita going back to the negotiating table in 2002," he explained.
Mr Chaibva, who urged Zimbabweans to be wary of external influences in local politics, said these were dangerous similarities.
He said these examples were encouraging analogies to draw from African history and Zimbabwe's own history.
"Who would have thought that in 1980 people like Ken Flower (head of CIO under Ian Smith) and General Peter Walls would be incorporated in the administration?"
He said his stance was not meant to have him included in President Mugabe's next Government but that he was merely doing so for the sake of the country.
Mr Chaibva yesterday attended the burial of former Zimbabwean ambassador to Sudan Cde Lloyd Gundu at Heroes' Acre in Harare.
There are serious rifts within MDC-T where Tsvangirai is willing to negotiate on set conditions while his secretary-general Biti has dismissed outright prospects for talks. This emerged yesterday after the two issued separate statements.
Addressing a Press conference in Harare yesterday, Tsvangirai said that his party was committed to a negotiated solution to the crisis the country is facing.
"We are not dismissing the question of talks but we are saying it cannot just be dialogue for the sake of dialogue; it has to be principled dialogue to find a solution to the crisis," he said.
Although he dismissed reports that there were talks currently taking place between Zanu-PF and his party, Tsvangirai said:
"Lessons are that at the end of the day, conflicts are resolved through negotiations."
The opposition leader said there was no substitute for sitting down to map the way forward, taking examples from conflicts that had taken place on the African continent. However, in his statement, Biti said the June 27 presidential run-off that was won by President Mugabe had "totally and completely exterminated any prospects of a negotiated settlement".
"It is now the firm view of the MDC-T that those who claim they have got a mandate to govern should govern. Chitongai tione," he said.
Read comments. Write your own.
Copyright © 2008 The Herald. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
Mugabe and Inzany PF is an Illegitimate government elected through cohersion, thuggery and and state sponsored terror, Mugabe is an Illegitimate President,and hold no Mandate.
Inzany PF lost the elections, including the presidency,in the March elections, It is a shame only few African countries had the spine and guts to speak out against the war criminal Mugabe, And the Shameful act of the AU, Who allowed him in is incredible, Africa,and especially ZIMBABWE has a long way to before they can truly say they entered the 21st century. If ever there will be a chance for peace, and a free democratically elected government, Then I think in the first instance Mbeki has to be removed from the negotiating table, He is PRO Inzany PF and Pro Mugabe, Sees himself as an intellctual, but show very little intellect, Annul the presidential election, Disarm War veterans and IN-Zany PF, Thugs & Militia, Install UN mandated African Peaceforce made up of non aligned Neutral African Countries, Hold new elections and send Mugabe and his henchmen to war crime tribunal in Hague. On charges of Genocide, Infanticide, and Crimes against Humanity.
And Finally Close down the TOILET PAPER Manufacturer called the THE HERALD newspaper. As it is detremental to peoples Intelligence. Its Whole staff should be charged with inciting violence and inciting genocide.
Now I understand why the MDC is performing so badly in elections. Firstly, is this Chaibva a senior MDC official or I picked up the wrong message? If he is then the MDC is a very big joke-and there is no way they could ever upsit ZanuPF. If he was planted by the CIO then my apologies to the opposition party. Mr Tswangirai beat Mr Mugabe in the 29 March poll fact. Why does Mr Chaibva think that if the African Union organises another run off, then Mugabe can probably win? So, this is a senior opposition official disputing the ilegitimacy of a rigged election and its outcome. Why would the AU need to run the poll again anyway if Mugabe is the legitimate president? I strongly suggest that the MDC must negotiate with ZanuPF without any pre-conditions because there are no alternatives. I have been voicing ferrociously for the June 27 election result to be cancelled but my voice is like the forlon cry of a titihoya in the South African jungle. If the MDC supports Mugabe then who should worry a thing? My conclusion is that this opposition party lacks political maturity and needs to be integrated into ZanuPF.
Chaibva is from the Mutambara faction, not Tvangarai. He has been rebuked and faces dismissal from the party (again not MDC-T)
Chaibva's comment are sympathetic to Zanu PF. He is free to join that party. On the call to ' recognise the President' the same can be said about the 'president' recognising that the MDC can win an election and be allowed to rule.
This gentlemen called Chaibva is a power monger and super confused fellow. He just want to be in cabinet at all cost to the extent of lobbying for his collegues to legitimise a flawed election. What a shame! He was basically a weed within a crop of democrats. He can go ahead and dance to the tune of the tyrant maybe he can pick few crumbs from the regime`s terror gains.
WARNING - The Herald is Mugabe's Propaganda Machine. If you believe the lies in the Herald you'll believe anything. How can anyone recognise Mugabe as the legitimate President? He is ILLEGITIMATE or in other words A BASTARD!!! The only way we will see change is to penalise Mugabe's allies, particularly South Africa (blame Mugabe's brother-in-law Thabo Mbeki). The 2010 World Cup should rather be held in England. How can Mbeki remain impartial towards his own brother-in-law? If Africa won't sort out this African problem then I call for sanctions to be imposed by the UN and the West on all countries with close ties with Zimbabwe i.e. South Africa and China (We should boycott the Beijing Olympics). Stop the killing! Stop the maiming and mutilation! No more abuse and human rights violations from this arrogant murderer and dictator and his brothers in arms. If this were Ian Smith, or for that matter any white ruler, would the world allow this behavior to continue? Where are the Anti-Apartheid activists now? Is this behaviour any better than apartheid? He is a racist and a murderer. Let the Hague deal with him. Countries like Zambia, Kenya and Botswana should be rewarded for speaking out against this monster. If Africa and the world at large can "interfere" in South Africa to bring an end to Apartheid then they can do the same to end this racism and bring about peace and stability in Zimbabwe once more.
Say whatever you want about the Herald on this story, but Chaibvu attended president Mugabe's ceremony and issued the statements attributed to him by the Herald. As a result, his part the MDC-M has decided to displine him. So....there is some truth to the story. In addition, other independent Zimbabwe blogs, websites etc also reported on the same story.
The MDC sometimes issues conflicting and undecisive actions.
See all comments (11).
why should the poor people aways suffer in their homeland. africa belongs to the african people so why should the so call african union sat back and watch their people suffer.if Mugabe so love his people,why kill them for the sick of power and greed.we african have had enough of our greedy leaders who only thinks everything is good for them and their families.let Mugabe know that the longest rope ever has an end.may God bless the suffer people of africa.