Wilson Johwa and Dumisani Muleya
25 November 2008
Johannesburg — ZIMBABWEAN negotiators are due to meet in SA today in another bid to salvage their power-sharing deal, amid a warning by President Kgalema Motlanthe that the deteriorating humanitarian situation "will get worse and implode or collapse altogether".
Motlanthe warned that a representative government would have to be formed soon, while a delegation of the group of Elders described the situation in Zimbabwe as fast declining.
Motlanthe, speaking after meeting with a delegation of the Elders, said the humanitarian and political crises were two sides of one coin and needed to be addressed simultaneously.
The Elders, comprising former United Nations secretary-general Kofi Annan, former US president Jimmy Carter and human rights campaigner Graca Machel, yesterday urged the ruling Zanu (PF) and two factions of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) to urgently implement the power-sharing deal they signed in September.
The three were denied visas to visit Zimbabwe in a bid to assess the situation. Instead they met with relevant groups and individuals in SA and said the situation was dire.
"We were expecting a gloomy situation, but the situation is far beyond what we could have imagined," Machel said at a press briefing in Johannesburg.
From left, 'Elders' Kofi Annan, Jimmy Carter and Graça Machel say Zimbabwe's humanitarian crisis is worse than they imagined.
Zimbabwe needed $550m in aid next year to help shore up the agricultural industry, said Annan, while another $140m would be needed for farming this year to meet a funding gap.
Carter said the signing of the unity deal had raised hopes, but the "failure to implement it in good faith and create a good workable power-sharing government is leading to despair and accelerating the crisis".
He said that -- regardless of the challenges -- all parties should make the welfare of the people their first priority and "put an end to unnecessary suffering of millions".
Machel said there was no possible solution to the humanitarian crisis before solving the political situation.
Last night the main MDC faction led by Morgan Tsvangirai had resolved it would attend the talks after an emergency meeting.
MDC spokesman Nelson Chamisa said the MDC would attend on condition the talks dealt with all outstanding issues, and not just a constitutional amendment to facilitate the contentious sharing of the home affairs portfolio.
"We are going there to insist that all issues must be dealt with seriously," he said.
The MDC wants the distribution of ministries, sharing of provincial governors, appointment of senior government officials and diplomats, composition of the national security council and correction of alterations in the power-sharing agreement resolved together with the amendment of the constitution to allow for the formation of the unity government.
At an emergency Southern African Development Community (SADC) meeting recently, it was resolved that the home affairs ministry be co-managed between Zanu (PF) and Tsvangirai's MDC, and that the efficacy of this arrangement be reviewed after six months.
The Elders again appealed to SADC to be more assertive and urgently deal with the situation, adding that more could have been done to avert the crisis.
However, Annan described as "delicate" any attempt to have the African Union (AU) take over the mediation since the 15-member SADC would first have to admit failure. "I don't see it happening tomorrow," he said.
But the Elders commended SA's decision last week to withhold R300m worth of agricultural assistance as a step towards more assertiveness by SADC member states.
A "concerted" campaign of this nature could achieve results, Machel said. Services were close to collapse, they said.
School enrolment had fallen from 85% last year to 20% while textbooks were so scarce that one text was shared among 20 learners.
All four of the country's major hospitals were closed, including a facility that treated women with birth-related complaints.
Reported cases of cholera were about 6300 -- yet the disease was killing 10 times more than the average in similar outbreaks.
Zimbabwean authorities had no clue or simply did not care as "anybody sensible" would do everything possible to stop the suffering, Machel said, emphasising that both the humanitarian and political crises needed to be approached with the same urgency.
Earlier, Motlanthe said that in a previous attempt to break the deadlock over the management of the home affairs ministry, facilitators had provided three options to the negotiators.
A proposal to allow the smaller MDC faction oversight over the department was rejected by both Zanu (PF) and Tsvangirai's MDC.
Zanu (PF) and the MDC had disagreed on the options to rotate the home affairs portfolio between them or appoint co-ministers to run it.
Motlanthe said when Zimbabwean authorities refused to grant access to the Elders, SA tried but failed to make contact with the Mugabe government, despite assurances he would be in touch.
"He didn't come back to us," said Motlanthe, who is also chairman of the SADC.
The Elders also met African National Congress (ANC) president Jacob Zuma who condemned Zimbabwe's failure to let them into the country.
"Even in a war, a humanitarian situation is always given an opportunity," he said.
Zuma said that an ANC delegation would seek to meet both Zanu (PF) and the MDC.
With Sapa
Read comments. Write your own.
Copyright © 2008 Business Day. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
I was listening to the BBC Network this morning when I heard some people have started blaming Morgan for his stubborness to cooperate with Mugabe.I want the people of Zimbabwe to realise that Morgan should not be castigated for being too selfish or oblivious to their sufferings.Mugabe and his cohort should not be trusted.You can see from the simple fact that they altered certain sections of the Agreement is a manifestation that they are only signing because they are pushed.Morgan has seen this and he his taking his time not to get into that trap because if he gets it… [Read Full Text]
Morgan is certainly to blame because people voted for him to change things but he is refusing to do so - he withdrew from the runoff and denied people the chance to vote Mugabe out, claiming he was doing this for the people's welfare. Now he has a chance to work for the people's welfare but then he refuses advice from SADC and the Elders to get on with the job of changing things from inside the government. He now wants a fresh election when there is little chance of that being free and fair. So what exactly does this… [Read Full Text]
If Morgan had run the second election or if he signed the agreement without a balanced sharing of power, the MDC would be history by now. Just as Nkomo and Zapu were, back in the day. This previously successful strategy of Cde Mugabe's is not working this time - due only to the will and backbone of the brave men and women of the MDC, who must not cave into the immense pressures on them by short-sighted SADC members for a 'quick fix', regardless of the horrific woes of our country. The only leverage there is for change lies within… [Read Full Text]
Surely you can not be that stupid. Morgan is trying to do the best he can with the limited resources he has with regard to power in ZIM. If Mugabe and regime stepped aside today and let Morgan and party control, Zim, this time next year would be in much better shape. The world would step in and Zim would move forward and i think you would find very few starving because it will be a totally new outlook for the country!
If you have a national football team captian and players that keep loosing because they hate the coach… [Read Full Text]
I am quite sure this time Zanu PF will be serious as current events here in Zimbabwe will not be tenable through arrogance and self serving stunts. I am sure it is the last chance that Mugabe has to ensure a smooth transfer of our liberties to self-determine and rebuild this country. This kind of ill-advised jamboree of blaming everyone who opposes selfish political stunts is pulling this country to uncharted waters ever known to humankind. Time is nigh to stop the rot
This post was deleted because it contravenes AllAfrica's commenting guidelines.
And your evidence for this silly and boneheaded diatribe against the Great Fighter?
Now, if a man with a brain soaking in whatever you called it can send your hero MT, the sprinter, to high fly it to his neo-imperialist masters in Paris, then, even if Mugage is not fit to rule the great people of Zimbabwe, then, HOLY OF HOLIES, it is perspicuous that MT would drag Zimbabwe to the greedy houses of loot of the reaction in Paris and other centers of neo-African infiltration.
Fighters don't run: they hold their ground and nook it out.
Cheers.
See all comments (43).
Active Discussions: Talks Resume as Nation Faces 'Collapse'