Wilson Johwa and Dumisani Muleya
26 November 2008
Johannesburg — TALKS to end the deadlock in Zimbabwe's power-sharing agreement got off to slow start yesterday amid reports that the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) had taken offence at the tone of a letter written to Morgan Tsvangirai by the mediator, former president Thabo Mbeki.
Party insiders said the letter, dated November 22, had so upset the MDC that officials had sought an audience with President Kgalema Motlanthe, who is also current chairman of the Southern African Development Community (SADC).
In the 10-page letter, which is a response to a letter sent by MDC secretary-general Tendai Biti, Mbeki made comments that did not go down well with the MDC, sensitive to the common Zanu (PF) accusation that it took its cue from the west.
Biti had described the decision on Zimbabwe taken by the extraordinary SADC summit earlier this week as "a nullity", a rejection that appeared to have irked Mbeki.
"It may be that, for whatever reason, you consider our region and continent as being of little consequence to the future of Zimbabwe, believing that others further away, in western Europe and North America, are of greater importance," Mbeki wrote.
The SADC meeting compelled Zanu (PF) and the MDC to seek ways of jointly running the much-contested home affairs ministry, a position rejected by the MDC. Mbeki, whom the MDC has long accused of bias, said the MDC did not respect decisions made by African leaders.
"Realistically, Zimbabwe will never share the same neighbourhood with the countries of western Europe and North America, and therefore secure its success on the basis of friendship with these, and contempt for the decisions of its immediate African neighbours," Mbeki went on.
He also accused the MDC of publicly denouncing SADC leaders as "cowards".
"Such manner of proceeding might earn you prominent media headlines. However, I assure you that it will do nothing to solve the problems of Zimbabwe," Mbeki said.
He also told Tsvangirai that in accepting large numbers of Zimbabwean exiles, "in a spirit of solidarity", neighbouring countries had displayed no characteristics of cowardice.
The parties were also at odds about the scope of yesterday's negotiations.
Sources said Mugabe's negotiators from Zanu (PF) insisted they were in SA only to discuss an amendment of the constitution to facilitate implementation of the power-sharing pact as recommended by SADC.
But Tsvangirai's MDC faction wanted to include a far wider number of issues, including the distribution of ministries, the appointment of provincial governors, top government officials and diplomats, the composition and function of the National Security Council and the correction of "fraudulent changes" to the original power-sharing agreement.
Read comments. Write your own.
Copyright © 2008 Business Day. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
Please keep "God" out of this purely secular problematic.
Cheers.
When all avenues are exausted in tring to resolve this crisis the people of Zimbabwe can only turn to god to be their saviour. Respect that! Heaven knows Mbeki has no desire to turn his back on Mugabe, his corrupt secrets might come out in the wash. Cheers
When all avenues are exausted in tring to resolve this crisis the people of Zimbabwe can only turn to god to be their saviour. Respect that! Heaven knows Mbeki has no desire to turn his back on Mugabe, his corrupt secrets might come out in the wash. Cheers
Certainly, given the fickle nature of human existence---death, sorrow, tsunamis---it is true that when "all avenues are exhausted" Some human beings "turn to god [sic]".
Certain too is that "all avenues" have not been exhausted in Zimbabwe.
A wide open avenue is evident to the highest degree: LIFT THE ILLEGALLY IMPOSED SANCTIONS!
"God" certainly has better things to do than worry about the pranks of western neo-imperialists and their African fifth columnists. Annan, for one.
Regards.
"LIFT THE ILLEGALLY IMPOSED SANCTIONS!"
Please tell me how allowing Mugabes theives to travel and allowing arms into Zimbabwe will help the country?
You are fool to believe that sanctions are the cause of the trouble in Zimbabwe.
There is a reason why Zimbabwe is rated 14th most corrupt country in the world. Ever stop to think that this greed and corruption that resides in the government of Zimbabwe could be the problem? Aid organisations give money and it goes missing. Point the finger of blame where it deserves to lie, at Mugabe.
Pray tell what are the sanctions you are talking about? More so please enlighten us as to the sanctions the UN has imposed under the watch of Annan?
Surely, these politicians are wasting time at the expense of peoples lives. First things first, people lives shold be saved first, then the political bickering about power afterwards. There is nothing stopping anyone from appealing for humanitarian aid, and we would like to see MT appeals for aid brougt to fruition. I can see Mbeki is hitting back, which is unfortunate for a mediator, but i guess he is giving them a taste of their medicine, he is losing patience, and all along the MDC have denounced Mbeki publicly about how biassed he is, i am sure he has taken enough of those patience and losing patience with the process. MT should also restrain his official spokesperson from denouncing Mbeki in public and then continue to participate in a process where Mbeki is a negotiator. Perhaps, they need some lessons in diplomacy. You can not continue to condemn SADC and still hope to go back to them for favourable solutions.
See all comments (11).
Mbeki was denied by his own people so what good do you expect from a person of that nature. I urge MDC-T to soldier on. If they don't get what they deserve they should not go ahead with the GNU. Let Mugabe do it as he is said to be able. Let him show his ability. Gone are the days Bob. God is God of time. Accept defeat, pave way for others.