Fahamu (Oxford)

Nigeria: Environmentalists Call for End to GM Cassava Trials

opinion

The Nigerian government's alleged approval for field testing of genetically modified cassava plants by a US-based plant science centre puts Nigeria in danger of trading away its food future to colonialists under the guise of agricultural biotechnology, Friends of the Earth Nigeria/Environmental Rights Action (FoEN) have warned. They and over 30 local civil society groups have called for an immediate end to the trials, to be conducted by the National Root Crops Research Institute with the reported approval of the National Biosafety Committee - a body that currently has no legal power to grant such an approval. In addition to its concerns about the effects on biodiversity and human health of GM crops, FoEN says that Nigerian food security lies in building the capacity of its farmers, not in GM foods.

The alleged approval by the Nigerian Federal Government for the US-based Donald Danforth Plant Science Centre to conduct field-testing of a genetically modified cassava - 'Super Cassava' - in Nigeria can be likened to trading away our food future to modern colonialists that hide under the cover of agricultural biotechnology. The tests must be halted immediately, Friends of the Earth Nigeria/Environmental Rights Action, Nigeria and over 30 other civil society groups in Nigeria have said.

ERA/FoEN's position is premised on the recently reported approval of the National Biosafety Committee (NBC) for the National Root Crops Research Institute (NRCRI) Umudike to go ahead with plans to conduct "contained" field trials of genetically modified (GM) cassava on the banks of the Qua Iboe River, Abia State. The NBC has no power to grant this kind of approval.

Details of the approval were revealed at the annual meeting of the American Society for the Advancement of Science, held in Chicago, USA on 13 February 2009, where it was announced that Nigeria's NBC had given the Danforth Centre approval to carry out field trials for GM cassava in collaboration with NRCRI.

In its response to the development, ERA/FoEN warned that the back door approach of the biotech industry and its Nigerian allies to introduce GM crops in the country will not only endanger Nigerians, but is also a "breach" of the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety which Nigeria is signatory to, and which seeks among others to protect biological diversity from the potential risks posed by living modified organisms resulting from modern biotechnology.

"Nigeria does not need any 'Super Cassava'. The genetic modification of cassava to produce Vitamin A is fraught with many dangers to the health of Nigerians who depend on cassava as a staple. Some years back, the biotech industry engineered the so-called golden rice to be rich in Vitamin A, but one would need to eat 9 kilograms of that rice to have as much Vitamin A as one would have from eating just two small carrots. The golden rice was a golden hoax and the super cassava will turn out to be super fraud", said ERA/FoEN

Executive Director, Nnimmo Bassey in a statement issued in Lagos.

"Nigerians have used different fora to voice outright rejection of GM crops and public opinion is massively against the commercialisation of our stomachs. This cannot be done through the backdoor and we have made it clear that the solution to our food needs is with our local farmers and not with Danforth Centre, Monsanto and their local allies".

"It is very clear now that like the International Institute for Tropical Agriculture (IITA), the NRCRI is unfortunately becoming another front for the same companies in their push for introduction of GM into Nigeria. Why cassava? What happened to the over 40 so-called hybrids of cassava that the IITA allegedly developed, which it said have the capacity to resist diseases and solve our cassava needs?" Bassey queried.

He pointed out that the planned field testing is a well-scripted and systematic attempt by the biotech industry at breaking down Africa's regulatory resistance to GM crops, even as he added that the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation early this year awarded Danforth Centre a US$5.4 million grant to secure approval of African governments to allow field testing of GM crops.

Accordingly, he maintained that the application letter from NRCRI to the ministry of environment, housing and urban development, dated 14 November 2008, saying it would work closely with an unknown Nigerian Biosafety Office is enough evidence that the research institute is not fully informed about the structure of Nigeria's biosafety regime hence, the need to halt the testing exercise.

Time and again we have said that the solution to Nigeria's food crisis is in consistency in government policies with regards to involving local farmers in planning and strengthening their skills - not GM crops. It is also pertinent to remind the promoters of this misadventure that Nigeria's biosafety law is still in draft form and is yet to be deliberated by the National Assembly. Any field-testing of GM crops is nothing short of an illegality, which must not be allowed, Bassey insisted.

Mrs. Juliana Odey, national coordinator of Nigeria Cassava Growers Association, Cross River State, said: "Cassava is our gold. We don 't want these GM crops because we have enough cassava cuttings to feed this nation. The food problem in Africa is waste, due to lack of storage facilities. Governments should not implement policies that affect farmers without consulting with farmers."

* Friends of the Earth Nigeria/ Environmental Rights Action is an advocacy non-governmental organisation that deals with environmental human rights issues in Nigeria.

* Please send comments to editor@pambazuka.org or comment online at http://www.pambazuka.org/.

  • Comment (3)

Copyright © 2009 Fahamu. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 130 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.

Comments Post a comment

  • Elijah E.
    Mar 15 2009, 03:09

    We are in an era of global crisis marked by economic meltdown, famine, droughts, war, hurricane etc. This is not the time to give approval to any firm, company or institute to test their technological projects on our soil after the possibility of being rejected in their own country. Nigerian government are gullible when it comes to foreign bodies or associates they remove their thinking caps. This is why we need experts or professionals to handle certain position in Nigeria not just opportunist. As an environmentalist I believe we are already witnessing the negative impact of environmental change, as such what are government should do is to bring in the experts in such field for them to carry out an Environment Impact Assessment of such project before it is approve/recommended. The inter-relativity of the ecosystem can not be denied, therefore care should be taken know what the yield and quality of such produce and the effect it will have on man as the negative will be left for the poor masses to carry.

  • sejeh1
    Mar 16 2009, 02:43

    Elijah E and other environmentalist,

    I thought that this was a good idea (and I still believe it is until you convince me otherwise). The argument that GM rice was unsuccessful in the past means that GM cassava wouldn't be is false. We don't know that.

    What is wrong with having better variety of cassava that would provide food for our suffering masses? Frankly, I would have thought that this is the ideal time to try out something like this given the current global downturn and our numerous attempts to self sufficient.

    Please convince us that your point of view is to the benefit of the poor and then we would change our mind.

  • upliftdarace_144
    Mar 16 2009, 13:22

    Nigeria : Environmentalists Call For An End To GM Cassava Trials

    I agree.

    There are some wicked sinister forces attacking Black Africans from all angles.

    Read the following book on the GMO game they are playing on us. If we eat GMO , we might as well eat plastic fruit; RIDICULOUS !!!!

    SEEDS OF DECEPTION BY JEFFREY SMITH

    “ A must read for truthseekers. “ [www.seedsofdeception.com]

    PARABLE OF THE GMO GAME AND ITS ORIGINATOR (Satan aka D-Evil )

    And Jesus said another parable to them, saying, “ The kingdom of heaven is like a man which planted good seed in his field: But while men slept, his enemy came and sowed tares (GMO / FAKE) among the wheat (NATURAL), and went his way. But when the blade was sprung up, and brought forth fruit, then appeared the tares also. So the servants of the householder came and said to him, Sir, didn’t you plant good seed in thy field ? Where did these weeds (GMO/ FAKE) come from ? The Householder said to them, An enemy (D-Evil) has done this. The servants said to him, Do you want us to pull up the weeds ? The Householder said, No ; we don’t want to hurt the NATURAL plants by accident. Let the GMO /FAKE & NATURAL grow together until the harvest. And in the time of harvest I will say to the reapers,

    Gather together first the tares (GMO/ FAKE) , and bind them in bundles to burn them (In The Lake Of Fire & Brimstone).

    Then gather the wheat into my barn. (PARADISE) “ [Matthew 13:24 -30 - Paraphrased]

    ROACH GENES IN CORN

    [http://ixquick.com/do/metasearch.pl?query=Roach+genes+in+corn&cat=web&pl=f f&language=english]