Business Day (Johannesburg)

South Africa: Top ANC Executive Denounces Mbeki

Johannesburg — AFRICAN National Congress (ANC) national executive committee member Fikile Mbalula has attacked former president Thabo Mbeki, saying he doubted the conspiracy against ANC president Jacob Zuma would have been exposed if Mbeki was still in office.

In an explosive 1800-word open letter to Mbeki, Mbalula said Mbeki's legacy was tainted with "shame" and "disgrace" as he presided over a period of gross abuse of state institutions.

"I doubt if today you were president this conspiracy that has come to light would have been uncovered," Mbalula said.

Mbeki spokesman Mukoni Ratshitanga said Mbeki would not comment on Mbalula's letter.

ANC spokeswoman Jessie Duarte said the ANC wanted everyone to move forward.

"Recrimination is not what we want. The ANC president has said ours is to build our institutions so as to never have this kind of abuse again," Duarte said.

Mbalula's attack, coming just before the general election, could provide impetus to the ANC to break its ties with the former president. Several of Mbeki's former ministers, including former deputy president Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka and former minister of public enterprises Alec Erwin, have endorsed the breakaway Congress of the People (COPE).

There was speculation early last month that Mbeki would come out in support of COPE days before the election.

Centre for the Study of Democracy director Steven Friedman said Mbalula's attack had to be read in the context of the poll.

"It's obviously an attempt to paint COPE with an Mbeki brush," he said. "The ANC wants to make it clear that it is the standard bearer for ANC voters, and that COPE and Mbeki are just sore losers."

Mbalula accused Mbeki of dereliction of duty, referring especially to his conduct when the security agencies became involved in the internal battles of the ANC's succession race.

Mbalula fingered Mbeki for blackening Zuma's name, and accused him of withholding critical information in the Schabir Shaik fraud and corruption trial.

He blasted Mbeki for "betraying the rule of law", which he said was the mantra of Mbeki's presidency. "It is a sad reality that the phenomenon we are dealing with today is a result of your actions of conniving and manipulating people, and advancing politics of patronage ," he said.

Mbalula also accused Mbeki of being the kingpin in the formation of COPE shortly after the ANC recalled him from office.

Mbeki's reaction to the abuse of power by former Scorpions boss Leonard McCarthy was telling.

"The more fundamental issue, which I would have expected would be your primary preoccupation, would be how did you fail the nation so badly such that the chain of events over the last nine years landed us in the position we find ourselves in today?

"How did the state apparatus become so embroiled in partisan politics that sought to rip our movement apart such that not even the highest office in the land had the political will to put brakes on the rot that was settling in?"

Mbalula listed a raft of claimed transgressions, including Mbeki's handling of the Hefer commission and the infamous off-the-record briefing of black editors. He accused Mbeki of inaction when the Scorpions acted illegally, and criticised Mbeki's endorsement of McCarthy, who went to the World Bank on leaving the crime-fighting unit.

Mbalula accused Mbeki of briefing ANC structures, the religious community and opposition parties (particularly the Democratic Alliance) on how corrupt Zuma was in an attempt to garner public support and sympathy.

"You were highly implicated as a central player in the compilation of a dossier which sought to defame Cde Zuma in the run-up to Polokwane, which was distributed among ANC delegates at conference," he said.


Copyright © 2009 Business Day. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 130 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.

Comments 1 to 4 of 4 Post a comment

  • expat dave
    Apr 14 2009, 12:46

    MBeki was not responsible for blackening Zumas' name - he did that all on his own. It is a tragedy that with all that needs to be done in SA all the ANC can come up with is internal mudslinging. Way to go guys.

  • chokora
    Apr 15 2009, 00:56

    Hey "expat dave":

    Vacuous.

    I suppose that you know something. Aren't there problems in your "expat lands" which a know-it-all "expat dave" can work on?

  • ROK-on-chris
    Apr 16 2009, 00:33

    This is just another macheviallian episode in the soap opera of south african politics. Making a martyr out of the former state president is electioneering at its worst. I can't even figure out where lies the truth any longer.

    Where's the consistency, ANC? Yeah, you're consistent with being inconsistent - and this is why you've lost my vote. You have consistently proven to me that you are unable to govern.

    It's so easy for south africans to scorn and ridicule expats that are living and working abroad - but did you ever stop to think that we left the country that we loved because we couldn't even find a job to make ends meet - and that an employer from another country welcomed our skills and expertise with open arms?

    I love my country and would love to come home - but the ANC has been given 15 years - yes 15 YEARS - to turn things around. Clearly our electoral process requires a constitutional change if we want to have an open democracy in South Africa. Proportional representation has failed us dismally because MPs and cabinet members alike can hide behind party lines when they've failed.

    Things have passed the point of ridiculous in sunny SA - citizens, stop thinking about yourselves for a change, stop your constant moaning and exercise your constitutional right and tell this lameduck government that you want results - not EXCUSES!

    Who CARES is Mbeki knew of a conspiracy - who cares is JZ is the next president. Has the ANC done all it could in 15 years to take SA forward? I say, "No." You have been given your 15 years of fame - by 2014 you would have given the nation 20 years of shame.

    Desmond Tutu was right. The Nats couldn't hold power because of their arrogance. No government will ever stay in power if the ruling elite doesn't give a flying f@&k about the people that entrusted them to serve (oh sorry - we have a proportional representation - so we DON'T KNOW whom we've entrusted!).

    Oh, and Trevor - don't think we can't see your scheming ways! Show some self-respect, man!

  • George Warren
    Apr 16 2009, 03:54

    This is all pretty good news for the opposition in SA. What with the ANC and COPE at each others throats will divide the vote more. It might just might happen that SA will have another white president.