SciDev.Net (London)
Naomi Antony
4 June 2009
The "One Laptop per Child" (OLPC) scheme, which has sent over a million US$100 laptops to children in the developing world, has been criticised by researchers who found that, unless they are introduced with care, they become little more than distracting toys in the classroom.
The study, conducted in Ethiopia, revealed that students wanted more content on the laptops and teachers were not adequately trained on how to make use of them.
The OLPC scheme was launched in 2005 to provide each child in the developing world with a low-cost laptop to encourage "self-empowered" learning. More than one million laptops have been distributed.
David Hollow of the UK-based ICT4D Collective at Royal Holloway, University of London, and his team evaluated the OLPC initiative in Ethiopia by observing classroom sessions and interviewing students and teachers.
They told Africa Gathering - an information and communication technology and social networking conference organised by the London International Development Centre in April - that students tended to play with the machines, largely for taking pictures with the built-in digital camera.
Teachers were left frustrated because the students were better at using the laptops and played on them during lessons instead of listening to the teachers, Hollow told the conference.
"If I had the money, I would not spend it on laptops," Hollow told SciDev.Net. "It will cost about US$3 billion dollars to give every [Ethiopian] child a laptop. And as a proportion of the national budget for education, that's just ridiculous."
The approach "doesn't actually empower people in the way that we'd like. It just undermines the teacher ... It's impossible to integrate it".
The ICT4D team worked with Swiss educational software provider BlankPage to develop Akili, a textbook reader that was used to download books and increase the educational content on the laptops.
"We felt that Akili was something of a bridge because it enabled the children to explore and engage with their own learning but, at the same time, they were still based within the national curriculum and the teacher's authority was not undermined."
Hollow said that in Ethiopia many children only attend school for a year or two so the priority is to give them good basic literacy and numeracy skills.
He suggested that introducing laptops in secondary schools would be more appropriate "because you've got a smaller group of people, which is far cheaper, and you've got a group of people who are actually more likely to be the decision-makers of the future".
But Matt Keller, OLPC's director of Europe, the Middle East and Africa, rejects the criticisms. He says that when children take the laptops home they extend the school day. "When a child uses a laptop, he constructs and engages with it in a way that is far more dynamic and interactive than anything that he does at school."
He disputed Hollow's recommendation to focus on secondary schools: "By the time most kids [are older], they've lost complete interest in school ... And that's partly because school is rote, you sit there and you're taught to memorise what [you ought] to know".
"What technology can do is pique a child's curiosity and engage them at an interest level that's far greater than what a bricks and mortar school can do."
With regards to integration, Keller said that teachers in Ethiopia had been a "little bit slow to come around" in comparison to other countries. "But from what I've seen already, after a few months they've adapted quite nicely."
Hollow told the meeting that, for ICT4D projects to work, it is essential to take a long-term view and assess the impact of the project afterwards. This should involving talking to beneficiaries to discover their perceived needs.
Read comments. Write your own.
Copyright © 2009 SciDev.Net. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
Having spent 25 years training teachers who are already in place in the classroom, this report is of no surprise to me at all. It is an everyday occurance that teachers who are not extensively prepared to integrate new resources (from technology to simply manipulative learning tools) do not properly apply the resources in their instructional program. The process of preparing teachers to successfully use laptops in instruction is complex in any environment: teachers must learn how to use the basic tool, must learn how to load proper applications that are aligned to the curriculum being taught, must learn… [Read Full Text]
“Don’t throw the baby out with the dirty water!” The OLPC program is an excellent concept and is filling a much-needed gap in teaching and learning, globally. It always amazes me how one generation attempts to limit the aspirations of the upcoming generations. Too often, the reason for the gap is due to the limitations of teachers, training, and the need for governments to control what is taught and learned by its constituents. Making available laptops to the young reduces the influence of both generational and political barriers. Bravo!!!
However, I do have one issue with OLPC because last year… [Read Full Text]
“Don’t throw the baby out with the dirty water!” The OLPC program is an excellent concept and is filling a much-needed gap in teaching and learning, globally. It always amazes me how one generation attempts to limit the aspirations of the upcoming generations. Too often, the reason for the gap is due to the limitations of teachers, training, and the need for governments to control what is taught and learned by its constituents. Making available laptops to the young reduces the influence of both generational and political barriers. Bravo!!!
However, I do have one issue with OLPC because last year… [Read Full Text]
I would like to clarify that the quotations attributed to me in the article above were presented out of context and portray only one side of my perspective on the XO 5000 programme in Ethiopia. While I did indeed criticise aspects of the model and implementation of this programme, I also drew attention to positive aspects. In any monitoring and evaluation, it is essential to draw attention to both the positive issues and challenges associated with such an initiative. The research I conducted was just one dimension of ongoing efforts to assess the educational effectiveness of the programme and… [Read Full Text]
Generally the reported study appears to have identified some important challenges and lessons in the implementation of the "One Laptop per Child" (OLPC) scheme in Ethiopia. For instance, it has noted the need to introduce the laptops with care; students' interest in getting more content; the need to provide adequate training for teachers; and, involving beneficiaries to discover their perceived needs. On the other hand, I have found some of the criticisms as stated in this brief news report to be somewhat poorly considered. Just to point out a few: – [The laptops] "... become little more than distracting… [Read Full Text]