SW Radio Africa (London)

Zimbabwe: Rights Groups Slam Arrest of Hundreds of Exiles in SA

Zimbabwean refugees sheltering in the Central Methodist Church, Johannesburg. (Photo Courtesy Sokwanele)

Human rights groups in South Africa have slammed this weekend's arrest of more than 300 people, mainly Zimbabwean exiles, taking shelter at Johannesburg's Central Methodist Church.

Police swarmed the church premises in the early hours of Saturday morning following numerous complaints from businesses in the area about 'vagrants'. The majority of those who were arrested were Zimbabwean refugees, and included a number of women, children and people who were seriously ill.

Amongst them were a 58-year-old South African women who is blind and deaf, a South African man suffering from acute psychosis, a pregnant woman and over 10 children. 344 people in total were hauled away during the raid that reportedly saw police officials launch an unmotivated attack on the exiles camped outside the church premises.

According to bystanders from the medical charity Doctors Without Borders, who work at the Church, police forcibly pushed many people to the ground while some were even threatened with electric stun guns.

Police officials said that the women and children would be released with warnings, while all the men would be detained, unless they could fork out a R300 admittance of guilt fine. But no one was released and the whole group was forced to appear on vagrancy and loitering charges in court on Monday. Lawyers for Human Rights and the Legal Resources Centre have both slammed the arrests and detention of the exiles, with lawyers expressing outrage that they were denied access to the arrested group.

"The only crime they committed is to be destitute without shelter," said Lawyers for Human Rights spokesman Jacob Van Garderen. "In addition several people were arrested who just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time, which again shows the arbitrariness of the arrests and the police operation."

The charges against the exiles were dropped in the Johannesburg Magistrates Court on Monday, which van Garderen said, "strengthens our conviction that homeless people are being targeted just because they are homeless and vulnerable."

The Church is a safe haven for an estimated 4000 exiles, mainly from Zimbabwe, who have fled their homes seeking safety and job opportunities in South Africa. Most Zimbabweans seeking refuge at the Church fled the country during last year's violent post election upheaval, while many have fled the economic collapse of the country. But with few job opportunities and a lingering xenophobic attitude prevailing in South Africa, most Zimbabwean exiles have remained at the Church, where they receive food and medical attention.

The Church therefore has been hosting numbers well beyond its capacity, with thousands of exiles sleeping on the surrounding streets. Local businesses have reacted with outrage, even going as far as to take the church's Bishop, Paul Verryn, to court over what they said was a 'safety' threat. The exiles have been accused of thefts and muggings, while the unsanitary conditions outside the church are being blamed for a drop in business trade in the area.

Earlier this year Gauteng local government MEC, Qedani Mahlangu, lashed out at Bishop Verryn, for 'exposing' the exiles to more danger by allowing them to stay at the church. She pledged to seek out alternative accommodation for the thousands of exiles, with the help of NGOs. But to date, little has been done to change the situation and with up to 200 new exiles arriving per day, the church has remained overcrowded and a target for South Africa's police force.


Copyright © 2009 SW Radio Africa. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 130 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.

Comments 1 to 5 of 11 Post a comment

  • gammacarra
    Jul 6 2009, 20:04

    Sometimes l feel that God have no faith to poor Zimbabweans.But has great faith to that Devil of Robert Mugabe Those racist white police in South Africa should have mercy in human. If someone is homeless and sick how do they expect someone to have 300rands.90% of Police in south Africa are white and should have mercy to those poor people of Zimbabwe. And l don' t trust God it is time up to take away Mugabe to hell and people of Zimbabwe have suffered enough. when Mr Smith was in power and lots of white farmers Zimbabwe was such a great country.I hope Mr Tsvagirai will workout the best for farmers to well come them back. Mugabe needs a big coffin soon to be prepared.

  • akapfunde1
    Jul 7 2009, 03:24

    Hey hey hey Glamacara so you tell us that when Hitler was in Germany was doing extremely well. Mr Hitler invested in jobs, motorways, scientific research and patriotism. Smith was worse than Mr Adolf Hitler.

  • emily_sorensen
    Jul 7 2009, 04:22

    Smith was worse than Mr Adolf Hitler???

    I guess the small matter of 6 million jewish murders isnt important then eh?

  • richerson88
    Jul 10 2009, 00:20

    This post was deleted because it contravenes AllAfrica's commenting guidelines.

  • Pianki
    Aug 19 2011, 17:13

    Yes, Smnith stood for white supremacy. The same as Obama and Hilliary Clinton and Susan Rice. Look how Nato Nations in particular France, U.S and Britain is doing Libya. Look at what France done to Cote D Voire. Look at what the US done to Somali back in the 1970's which stand for the reasons Somali is in the condition she is in now. Britain and the U.S renig on the Lancaster Agreement and now due to sanctions and boycotts they demonize Mugabe. I want to work to make Zimbabwe independent of the west for subsidence of any klind.

See All Comments