9 July 2009
Monrovia — As an angry debate rages over the 200-plus people recommended for prosecution by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), an independent body set up under the 2003 peace agreement, civil society groups warn its many other recommendations risk being overlooked.
The final TRC report also recommended President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf be barred from public office for 30 years once her presidential term runs out in 2011 because she failed to express remorse for her support for Charles Taylor -now on trial for war crimes- in the late 1980s.
Several TRC commissioners have received death threats following the report's release, one commissioner confirmed to IRIN.
"The biggest tragedy is the attention this [fracas] is giving to the perpetrators of war crimes, but the benefit of the TRC is to give victims a voice and to give society a chance to respond to their needs," said Lizzie Goodfriend, programme associate at International Center for Transitional Justice (the ICTJ), a non-profit with an office in the capital, Monrovia, which helps countries pursue accountability for past mass atrocities.
"Our biggest concern is that the entire report be subject to the scrutiny the prosecutions' controversy is getting."
TRC spokesperson James Keargoi told IRIN: "Anyone who reads the whole report will see a very comprehensive list of recommendations that are essential to building peace - a review of government structures, a conflict-resolution forum in towns and villages, and reparations to victims of crime. The focus on all of these has been lost."
The government must set up a human rights commission immediately, he added, to start implementing all of the report's recommendations - not just prosecutions.
Deputy Information Minister Gabriel Williams told IRIN the government welcomes the TRC report and will do everything it can to bring forward its peace building proposals.
At a 6 July press conference, seven former warlords, most of them signatories to the 2003 Liberia Comprehensive Peace Agreement, declared the TRC's report as "anti-peace", claiming it sought to undermine democratic government and stability in Liberia.
Former warlord Sando Johnson, cousin to Charles Taylor, who was accused by the TRC of serving as a recruiting officer for Taylor's forces, told reporters the report was biased: "We will not let this go down...it is the TRC that has invited confusion and if the government does not get involved, I can promise you one thing: this Sando Johnson and all other persons will not succumb."
Several of the former warlords said they had not had an opportunity to come face-to-face with their victims to apologize and move towards reconciliation.
But the TRC's Keargoi said though former warlords may not have had one-on-one opportunities: "The TRC had public hearings at which every leader of a warring faction was asked about their role in the conflict. They also had media outlets and other forums in which to take responsibility for their actions. It is incorrect that they did not get a chance to apologize."
Showing remorse and accepting responsibility for war crimes allowed some prominent rebel fighters to evade a recommendation for prosecution by the TRC.
Deputy minister Williams told IRIN the government is trying to institute the rule of law. "Liberians know the consequences of lawlessness. We want to make it clear this will not be tolerated in Liberia."
Threats made by the former commander of rebel group Independent National Patriotic Front of Liberia, and now Nimba County senator, Prince Johnson that he would destabilize the country if his name was mentioned in the report, led to a meeting between him and US ambassador Linda Thomas Greenfield at which he clarified he did not intend to promote instability.
Backlash
Following strong language from former warlords, civil society groups, human rights activists and religious leaders have called on Liberians to stop instilling fear and to avoid making threats that counter the 2003 peace agreement.
This is a good sign, said Goodfriend "The most significant thing that this indicates is that Liberians are secure enough in their current peace to take public stances against people who might want to detract from the peace agenda."
Liberians have no appetite for further instability, said TRC's Keargoi. "There is always a backlash after a truth and reconciliation report," he told IRIN. "But Liberians are resolved to move forward with their lives - they won't let anyone take this country back to the path of war."
[ This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations ]
Read comments. Write your own.
Copyright © 2009 UN Integrated Regional Information Networks. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
What is this cry about TRC report undermining the peace of Liberia? Or is that another political scare-tactic to undermine justice and promote impunity? we will not be deterred nor perturbed by those crying wolf, wolf, to stall the course of justice. We invaded the establishment of a war-crimes court for the TRC amid public outcry for one. We shouted aloud that the TRC with all of its mandate, which should include what we now received of them, that it was the best way forward. What is the problem now? We are not afraid for another war, what we are… [Read Full Text]
The TRC reported what they think was right for the country, and it was an act of bravery to be so honest. Why can we except their report and ask those that are listed to apologize to the Liberian people. Although some of the names listed make no sense, we still have to compliment the TRC for job well done. Over two hundren thousand lost their lives in our senseless war according to CNN. It's not the time to let those killer walk our street free without apologizing to the Liberian People.
The whole world is watching what we do in Liberia & what our "leaders" do with the TRC's recommendations will set a standard by which we will be judged as a people by the rest of the world.
I am hearing people saying that the TRC missed an opportunity to advance peace in Liberia an assertion I refuse to accept.The recommendations of the TRC is an opportunity to heal the sore in the side of Liberia for good even though implementing them may be a little painful,but it is better to follow the right path to true and lasting peace… [Read Full Text]
Liberia does not have the capacity to prosecute those people. Why are we not being real? Bar hundreds of people from holding public office which is their profession. How do they survive? Will TRC not be killing also.
Where did TRC leave ECOMOG? Why did Nyepan Verdier not invite ECOMOG? They also committed a lot of atrocities, killing, raping our mothers, sisters and sons, uprooting our infrastructure and abandoning thousands of offsprings. Will the TRC find and prosecute them. It is not just real. Let have an open discussion about these self destruction in its many forms. All Liberians… [Read Full Text]
It is just scare tactic. No war will come to Liberia because of the TRC list. The people on the list carried out killing sprees dring the war. They need not contest these recommendations because they know that number of lives the have erased. They murdered Liberians at will senselessly and it is ridiculous that they want to hold their jobs and preach "bygone to be bygone." No, not this time. That will path a way for the to do it again because we are "quick to forgive." All of them belong on the list and the lawmakers need to… [Read Full Text]