The Analyst (Monrovia) AllAfrica aggregates reports from Africa's news media.
This is an article from the Liberian press.

Liberia: Prosecutors in Taylor's Trial Ordered


AllAfrica aggregates reports from Africa's news media. This is an article from the Liberian press. It is not a report by AllAfrica.

Special Court for Sierra Leone judges has ordered prosecutors to disclose to the defense all new documents that they intend to use in the cross-examination of former Liberian president Charles Taylor who is responding to charges that he was involved in a joint criminal enterprise with rebel forces who waged an 11-years rebel war in Sierra Leone.

In delivering the Chamber's ruling, presiding judge Justice Richard Lussick pointed that the prosecution's "piece mill disclosure of individual documents" was unacceptable.

"This cannot be allowed to continue and the Chamber needs to set out a disclosure regime," Justice Lussick said. The order came in the wake of Monday's decision by the judges in response to prosecution's request to use "new evidence" in the form of documents to impeach Mr. Taylor's credibility as a witness in his own defense.

In the said decision, the judges ordered that documents which are meant to impeach the credibility of Mr. Taylor can be used by the prosecution without the need to disclose said documents to the defense. These documents will be dealt with on a case by case basis, the judges ordered.

The judges further ordered that all documents which have probative value to the guilt of the accused must be disclosed to the defense before they could be used by the prosecution in cross-examining Mr. Taylor.

When cross-examination resumed this morning, Mr. Taylor's defense counsel objected to the use of a bundle of bank documents which prosecutors sought to cross-examine Mr. Taylor on in order to establish that Mr. Taylor was not truthful in his direct-examination about various bank accounts which he is alleged to have had before his detention by the Special Court for Sierra Leone.

Mr. Taylor's defense counsel said the team had not been given sufficient time to study the said bank documents. Mr. Taylor's defense asked to be given up to Monday to study the said documents. The judges granted the defense application.

Lead prosecutor Ms. Brenda Hollis, addressing the judges, agreed that to avoid further misunderstanding of the judges' order, all documents, whether intended for use to impeach Mr. Taylor's credibility or to point at Mr. Taylor's guilt will be disclosed to the defense.

Addressing all the parties, Justice Lussick made the following orders:

All such documents should be disclosed to the defense by close of business day on Tuesday, and

Prosecution should give 24hrs notice to the defense of documents it intends to use for cross-examination on a particular day."

Mr. Taylor is on trial for his alleged role in supporting RUF rebels who waged an 11-years rebel war in Sierra Leone. Crimes committed by the rebels ranged from amputation of civilian limbs, to rape, recruitment of child soldiers and murder. Mr. Taylor is accused of involvement in a joint criminal enterprise with the RUF rebels. He has denied all the allegations against him. Mr. Taylor's cross-examination continues on Monday.

At the same time, Prosecutors Wednesday questioned former Liberian president Charles Taylor on his decision to grant Liberian citizenship to Sierra Leonean rebel forces who relocated to Liberia in December 1999 after falling out with the Sierra Leonean rebel group's hierarchy.

Mr. Taylor has stated in his direct-examination that when Sierra Leone's notorious rebel commander Sam Bockarie became a hindrance to the peace process in the country and eventually fell out with Revolutionary United Front (RUF) leader Foday Sankoh, West African leaders took a decision to get Mr. Bockarie out of Sierra Leone and have him relocated to Liberia.

As Mr. Bockarie departed Sierra Leone for Liberia, hundreds of his loyal rebel fighters followed him to Liberia. Prosecution witnesses have testified that Mr. Bockarie relocated to Liberia on the invitation of Mr. Taylor. The former Liberian leader has denied these assertions.

Mr. Taylor has stated that upon arrival in Liberia, Mr. Bockarie and his rebel followers were all granted Liberian citizenship before Mr. Bockarie's followers were recruited into Liberia's Anti-Terrorist Unit (ATU).

During his cross-examination today, prosecution counsel Mr. Nicholas Koumjian asked Mr. Taylor under what authority he had granted Liberian citizenship to Mr. Bockarie.

"Under the constitution of Liberia and long standing practice," Mr. Taylor responded.

When the Liberian constitution was presented to Mr. Taylor, the former president referred the court to Chapter 4, Article 27, sub-sections (b) and (c) and explained that"the constitution does not spell out exactly but statutes are enacted." The former president read sub-sections (b) and (c) of the above Article of the Constitution which provide that:

In order to preserve, foster and maintain the positive Liberian culture, values and character, only persons who are Negroes or of Negro descent shall qualify by birth or by naturalization to be citizens of Liberia.

The Legislature shall, adhering to the above standard, prescribe such other qualification criteria for and the procedures by which naturalization may be obtained.

Mr. Taylor told the court that "based on those provisions and the legal advice that I received and based on long standing practice from President Tubman, I had the right to grant citizenship." Mr. Koumjian referred Mr. Taylor to a document titled An Act to Establish Citizenship and Naturalization Law of 1973 and amended in 1974.

Mr. Taylor immediately raised concerns about the document, saying "I don't know when this document was published. Laws are amended but at the time I was president and the legal advice that was given to me was this particular practice and so I'll want to look at the Title 3 of the Liberian Code of Laws of 1956.

Justice Julia Sebutinde intervened to say that the 1973 Act (as amended in 1974) makes clear that Title 3 had been repealed and was replaced by Title 4. Reading from Article 21 of the 1973 Act (as amended in 1974), Mr. Koumjian explained that sub-sections (a) and (b) make clear that a person becomes qualified for naturalization as a Liberian citizen if he has maintained continued lawful residence in the country for at least two years, and that the person has resided in the country from the day of filing the petition to the day the citizenship is granted.

"I am not a lawyer. I was president. I was given legal advice by my lawyers. So it's unfair for me to answer questions on these legal documents when i am not a lawyer," Mr. Taylor responded.

Mr. Taylor further explained that exceptional circumstances gave the president the power to grant citizenship to certain persons and that "it was within the context of peace in Sierra Leone that these exceptional circumstances arose." Mr. Koumjian also read provisions of Liberian laws that for a person to be lawfully admitted into the country, he must have "been and still is of good moral character in accordance with the constitution of Liberia."

"Do you consider Mr. Bockarie to be of good moral character?" Mr. Koumjian asked Mr. Taylor. "I cannot pass that judgment. Under normal circumstances, I'll say no but under exceptional circumstances, I am not in a position to make that judgment," Mr. Taylor responded.

When asked by the presiding judge Justice Richard Lussick to give a more direct answer to the question, Mr. Taylor said "I'll say he was a person of good moral background." The former president, however, added that "I did not look at that. I did not evaluate him on that background but the circumstances on which he entered Liberia."

Mr. Koumjian further read that the president can waive the two years residency requirement for naturalization but the person for whom the provision is waived will still be required to "make and file a petition with his own handwriting" and sign a declaration that he does not favor anarchy and wishes to become a citizen of Liberia.

"Did Mr. Bockarie sign a declaration?" Mr. Koumjian asked Mr. Taylor. "I don't know. I had an advice from the Ministry of Justice that I had the authority to do this. I had to assume that they filed a declaration of intention," the former president responded.

Asked further whether Mr. Bockarie took an "oath of allegiance" as required by law, Mr. Taylor said that "I'll assume that he did so with the appropriate agencies of government." In proving their case that Mr. Taylor occupied a position of superior authority over RUF rebels, prosecutors have led evidence on the relationship that existed between the former Liberian president and RUF commander Mr. Bockarie.

Prosecution witnesses have testified that Mr. Bockarie consulted Mr. Taylor before undertaking any major operation in Sierra Leone and that based on the former president's advice, Mr. Bockarie sent rebel forces to attack the diamond mines in Sierra Leone as well as the country's capital Freetown in 1998 and 1999 respectively.

Witnesses have further testified that when Mr. Bockarie fell out with the RUF leadership in December 1999, Mr. Taylor invited him to Liberia because he had better use for him. According to witness' testimonies, Mr. Taylor sent Mr. Bockarie to attack Ivory Coast and when the rebel commander attempted to return to Liberia after his assignment in Ivory Coast, he was executed by Liberian forces on Mr. Taylor's orders. Mr. Taylor has dismissed these claims as "lies."

Also in cross-examination, prosecutors sought to present several documents to impeach Mr. Taylor's credibility as a witness. This action was taken pursuant to the Trial Chamber's decision issued yesterday which granted the prosecution's request to submit "new documents" but only to impeach Mr. Taylor's credibility.


Copyright © 2009 The Analyst. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 130 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.

Comments Post a comment