IN THE recently published Dead Aid, author Dambisa Moyo, a Harvard- and Oxford-educated Zambian economist and former World Bank employee, controversially called for an end to development aid in Africa in five years.
Moyo has produced one of the most dangerously influential books in recent times, offering simplistic, sweeping recipes for resolving Africa's economic crisis. The book is lacking in substance and subtlety, and often borders on sophistry.
Without providing much convincing evidence, Moyo blames aid for corruption and conflict in Africa, as well as for preventing the building of social capital and attracting foreign investment. She grandly promises a new "model" for financing development: private capital markets, remittances from African diasporas, microfinance, government bonds, and Chinese investment.
Aside from the exaggerated faith in these funding solutions, the global financial crisis has clearly rendered many of them impractical.
It is not that Moyo does not say things that many sensible people would agree with: she correctly criticises widespread corruption and misrule in Africa; acknowledges the pernicious impact of western agricultural subsidies on Africa; and identifies the potential of Chinese trade and investment for Africa.
But her ahistorical approach and lack of understanding of contemporary African international relations are clear. She fails to grasp the fundamental point that aid in Africa has often been misused for self-interested strategic pursuits rather than for poverty alleviation. She talks of Soviet "aid" to African countries during the Cold War without seeming to realise that many African countries were disillusioned by Moscow's support which came largely in the form of military and not economic assistance. She puts insufficient effort into explaining how corrupt autocrats such as Mobutu Sese Seko were backed by western powers.
Moyo explains Africa's push for democracy in the 1990s as having been initiated by external donors, blissfully unaware that national actors in SA, Mali, and Zambia led the struggle for more democratic governance. The fact that Washington gives Egypt's 28-year- old regime of Hosni Mubarak 2bn annually (often double the amount to all 48 sub-Saharan African countries combined) escapes her attention.
Moyo does not explain clearly what she means by "aid" - sometimes including loans that have to be repaid - and often fails to separate national oil revenues from foreign aid. Cases where aid has promoted development in Rwanda, Ghana, Uganda, and Ethiopia - despite some cases of poor governance -- or supported worthy education and health programmes, are given short shrift. The fact that West Germany transferred over 1-trillion of "aid" (the amount Moyo claims went to 53 African countries in 60 years) to revive the relatively developed East Germany after 1989 would also appear to weaken her argument.
If aid is really the main problem, surely corruption would not be so rife in countries such as Nigeria, and to a lesser extent, SA, which do not rely on aid? Moyo argues that millions of Africans are poorer because of aid but does not provide much evidence to prove her point. She fails to make the link between cause and effect.
Her mono-causal explanation of aid as the root of all evil can also be easily debunked: structural issues from colonialism, external debt, and the global distribution of resources, as well as conflicts, poor governance, lack of a productive base, and failures of economic integration, have all contributed much more to poverty than aid.
This is a work of self-flagellating simplicity, totally devoid of any thinking by leading African research centres or scholars, making the book often read like a Harvard Masters syllabus or a World Bank report. Moyo reveals her ignorance by incredibly charging that "scarcely does one see Africa's ... officials ... offer an opinion on what should be done".
Adebajo Adedeji, the Nigerian Executive Secretary of the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa between 1975 and 1991, for example, provided several African-led alternatives based on African selfreliance and regional integration. Others such as Samir Amin, Thandika Mkandawire, and Bade Onimode have also offered African-led solutions.
Moyo employs crude stereotypes of "tribal conflict" to depict African wars, and recklessly suggests that aid is "an underlying cause of social unrest, and possibly civil war". Such an absurd link would, of course, involve a huge leap of logic, and the author's ignorant blaming of Somalia's civil war on competition for food aid completely ignores the decade-long homicidal campaign of US-backed autocrat, Siad Barre, which eventually led to rebellion in 1991.
Without providing any evidence, Moyo blames aid for stifling entrepreneurship, making African policymakers lazy, and politicising African countries. It is as if there are no genuine group grievances in places such as Nigeria's oil-rich Niger Delta or pre-civil war Liberia. The author draws fatuous comparisons with China and India: countries with enormous markets that dwarf those of all sub-Saharan African countries combined.
This book also has glaring factual errors: the target of 0,7% of gross national product to be provided as aid is said to have been set in 2002 instead of 1970; Harry Dexter White is listed as US secretary of state instead of assistant secretary at the Treasury; a third Sino-African summit in 2006 is described as the first meeting.
Moyo's book is also riddled with contradictions. She notes that 85% of aid is diverted to other purposes, which suggests that it is the abuses of aid - rather than aid itself - that is the main problem. She notes the decline of aid levels from 0,38% in 1982 to 0,22% in 1997, but continues to argue the deleterious effects of aid. Surely, if her arguments were correct, things would start to improve with this decrease in aid, which continues today.
She argues that Africa loses 500bn each year due to restrictive trade embargoes on its exports, but is unwilling to use aid more effectively to plug this hole. She calls for a huge improvement of Africa's infrastructure, but will not support the aid that would be needed to build these roads, railways, and bridges. Moyo also notes that the US poured more aid into South Korea than it did into all 53 African countries, seemingly showing the efficacy of aid, if used properly.
Moyo will give succour to conservative thinkers who already see nothing good coming out of Africa. They can now hide under the skirt of an educated African woman to peddle their prejudices. This book surely represents more a case of "brain dead" than "dead aid".
Adebajo is the executive director of the Centre for Conflict Resolution, Cape Town.
Comments 1 to 3 of 3 Post a comment
HeyNow Afrikan Family !
On Afrikans Investing In Technology , Afrikans abroad & In Afrika
Should Invest In The Technologies around the world And Have It
Shipped To Afrika With The Know-How To Do It Ourselves.. We
SHOULD NOT just allow countries to come into our countries and build
and settle on our lands. If you will allow a stranger to run your country,
Then you will allow then to run your state. If you will allow a stranger to run your state,
then you will allow them to run your city, your neighborhood, your home, your family,
yourself.. We Black Afrikans will be free , when we stop selling ourselves !!!!!!!
America (The Whore Of Babylon) Is Trying To Re-vive it'as dying
soul via other ASIANS & CAUC - ASIANS , But Prophecy Is
Pronounced :
And in those times there shall many stand up against the king of
the south(AMERICA / BABYLON ): ALSO the ROBBERS OF OUR
PEOPLE shall exalt themselves to establish the vision; BUT
THEY SHALL FALL ! [Daniel 11:14 ]
ATTENTION AFRIKA , you have 300 million citizens spread
abroad that need your help getting back to our roots. While you
are looking to countries like America & China to uplift Afrika, Many
of us Black Afrikans spread abroad are proficient in a lot of useful
technologies. Here is a brief synopsis of some of the inventions
that Black Americans have produced. So please help us to get
home.
BLACK AFRICAN INVENTORS AND THEIR INVENTIONS
* Sarah Boone - IRONING BOARD - April 26, 1892
* John A. Burr - LAWN MOWER
* Marie V. Brittan Brown - HOME SECURITY SYSTEM - Dec 2, 1969
* Buridge & Marshman - TYPEWRITER
* George Carruthers - X-RAY MACHINE
* George Washington Carver - PEANUT BUTTER - PAINTS PAINT STAINS ETC
* W.A. Dietz - SHOE
* P.B. Downing - POSTAL LETTER BOX
* Charles R. Drew - BLOOD PLASMA STORAGE SYSTEM
* T. Elkins - TOILET (COMMODE)
* Robert Flemming Jr. - GUITAR
* George F. Grant - GOLF TEE
* J. Gregory - MOTOR
* Michael Harney - LANTERN
* Augustus Jackson - ICE CREAM
* B.F. Jackson - GAS BURNER
* H.A. Jackson - KITCHEN TABLE
* Ruane Jeter - DIGITAL TOASTER - April 14, 1987
* Isaac R. Johnson - BICYCLE FRAME
* John A. Johnson - WRENCH
* P. Johnson - EYE PROTECTOR (GOGGLES)
* W. Johnson - EGG BEATER
* Frederick M. Jones - DEFROSTER - REFRIGERATION CONTROLS AIR CONDITIONER
* Jones & Long - BOTTLE CAPS
* John H. Jordan - CLOTHES DRESSER
* Mary B. Kenner - SANITARY BELT (TAMPONS) - May 15, 1956
* Mary B. Kenner - BATHROOM TISSUE HOLDER - Nov 19, 1982
* Mary B. Kenner - BACKWASHER ( BATHTUB OR SHOWER MOUNTED) - July 29,1987
* Lewis Latimer & Nichols - ELECTIC LAMP
* W.A. Lavalette - PRINTING PRESS
* Maurice W. Lee PRESSURE COOKER
* A.L. Lewis - WINDOW CLEANER
* John L. Love - PENCIL SHARPENER
* Tony J. Marshall - FIRE EXTINGUISHER
* Alexander Miles - ELEVATOR
* Jan E. Matzeliger - SHOE LASTING MACHINE
* W.A. Martin - LOCK
* Garrett A. Morgan - GAS MASK - Traffic Signal
* Lydia Newman - HAIR BRUSH - Nov 15, 1898
* Alice H. Parker - HEATING FURNACE - Dec 23, 1919
* J.F. Pickering - AIR SHIP (BLIMP)
* Purdy & Sadgwar - FOLDING CHAIR
* W.B. Purvis - FOUNTAIN PEN
* L.P. Ray - DUST PAN
* W.H. Richardson - BABY BUGGY
* G.T. Sampson - CLOTHES DRYER
* .W. Smith - LAWN SPRINKLER
* J. Standard - REFRIGERATOR
* T.W. Stewart - MOP
* Paul E. Williams - HELICOPTER
* Granville T. Woods - Roller Coaster
* Thanks to The Black Inventors Museum *
* Address : P.O. Box 76128 - Los Angeles , Calif. (90076)
* Phone (310) 859-4602)
* Director : Ghanaian Mr. Hamza Salifa
AND
ONE AFRICA TOURS & SPECIALTY SERVICES LTD.
* Major Contributor of Information : SEESTAH Imahkus Nzinga Ababio Okofo
[ http://www.oneafricaghana.com/ ]
P. O. Box CC 1251 - Cape Coast
Ghana - West Africa
What can you do to help us ?
Start with contacting Pan-Afrikanist organizations like BLACK
STAR MEDIA (Modelled after Marcus Garveys Vision For Afrika) : They are at
[ www.libradio.net ]. The CEO of BLACK STAR MEDIA is Keidi-Obi
Awadu. He has been on the frontline fighting for our freedom for
over 30 years.
It's Not A Question Of Other Learned Societies.
It's The INFERIORITY COMPLEX WE HAVE TO SHED
St. Paul In A Letter To The Christians In Rome Said :
" For I say, through the grace given to me, to every man that is
among you, NOT TO THINK OF HIMSELF MORE HIGHLY Than
He Ought To Think; but to think soberly, according AS GOD HAS
D EALT TO EVERY MAN THE MEASURE OF FAITH .
We All Should Think Highly Of Ourselves, Keeping In Our Mind
That God Gave Us Dominion Over The Earth
, NOT EACH OTHER. !!!!!!!!
So let's please help us to return to our Mama Afrika as Israel
under Moses escaped their exile !!!!!!!
MAMA AFRIKA YOUR CHILDREN WANT TO COME HOME !!!!!!!
[Check Out :
WHO BROUGHT THE SLAVES TO AMERICA ?
[ http://isohunt.com/torrent_details/42787621/Who+brought+the+slaves+to+ameri ca?tab=summary]
for full length video
FRITZ SPRINGMEIER A Bold Christian Truthseeker The Top 13 Illuminati Bloodlines
[ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k73Q2_f4vKU ]
WAKE UP ! STAY UP MY BROTHERS & SISTERS !
[ www.libradio.net ]
[ www.gcnlive.com]
- Life Is a Game. Have Fun. [ Luke 18:17 / Isaiah 11:6 ] :
The problem with most of these economists who critisize aid is that they never explain how the aid was spent. They have no crasp and are incapable of detail analysis. They are economists who deal will huge figures without delving into the datails of the issues. Usually the devils are in the details. Most economists) will allude to lump amounts of money the west or the soviet spent on Africa over the years but they don't explain how the money was raised, how it was spent, by who, for what reasons. Just blaming it on corruption is simplistic too. Who is corrupt here ? Both the donors and the recepients are corrupt. This is a complex issue that requires more rigorous analysis than warmed over opinions. The suggestions she makes or raising money are basically pea nuts untargeted and haphazardly, uncoordinated efforts that have failed to make an impact. What need is a concerted, planned, and commited effort on both sides -- the donors and the recipicients. These mealy mouthed halfhearted offers are the problem as they achieve nothing.
I have always read with interest most of the critiques on Moyo's book and would say for the most part, the criticisms have been very lame. This is understandable when it comes from people in Africa who heavily depend on the aid industry and have enriched themselves from it. After all, you don't bite the hands that feed you. I think equating Moyo's book to a "Harvard Masters Syllabus" is an insult to Harvard University. However, coming from Harvard and knowing fully well that the author comes from Fletcher, which is a third tier school in the US and a thousand miles behind Harvard, I understand why the piece is bitter. May be the author was never admitted into Harvard and is making it a point to criticise the institution whenever and wherever. It is a shame that some people think they have a monopoly of knowledge on Africa and as such, are very unhappy why someone like Moyo should delve into an area where they consider theirs. As the saying goes, it is very easy to criticise negatively, than to contribute positively. It would be interesting how Moyo reacts to the learned Mr. Executive Director or should I say Dr. knowledge of Africa?