Harare — The former chairman of Mazoe Mansions Owners Association, who was demanding US$20 000 compensation for defamation by a fellow member of the group, has been granted US$500 by the High Court.

Shadreck Murehwa wanted US$20 000 from Stephen Nyambuya, but High Court Judge Justice Samuel Kudya found it appropriate to award him US$500 compensation for his tarnished reputation. Nyambuya defamed Murehwa during two private meetings held by owners of Mazowe Mansions, a block of flats in Harare, on June 18 and 22 last year, insinuating he was a thief, dishonest and a liar.

Murehwa, who was chairman at that time, had called the meeting to seek money to fund a Harare City Council utility bill shortfall. Nyambuya interjected saying: "We are not here to hear that. We are here because funds are missing. "We are here because our funds are being misappropriated. Mari dzedu dziri kudyiwa. "Our funds are not getting to the City of Harare. That is why we are having problems.

"There is no transparency and accountability in this chap. At the next meeting we must choose people who are honest to represent us." In his recent ruling, Justice Kudya agreed that defamation had occurred, but US$20 000 was too much. In arriving at his decision, the High Court Judge alluded to several cases. "After assessing the factors outlined . . . I estimate that the plaintiff is entitled to damages in the sum of US$500," he said.

The judge also noted that Murehwa testified in a quiet and dignified manner and described Nyambuya as a poor witness. "He (defendant) was not able to give a straight forward story. He was argumentative and evasive during cross examination," he said.

Lawyer Jonasi Dondo of Mudimu and Dondo represented Murehwa while Mr Simplisius Chihambakwe of Chihamba-kwe, Mutizwa and Partners acted on Nyambuya's behalf.