Congo-Kinshasa: Election 'Too Flawed to Be Credible' - Civil Society and Diaspora Speak Out

analysis

There is an African proverb which says that if you adopt a name, you must also inherit its affairs. In the Democratic Republic of Congo, recent post-electoral events have led people to question the very essence of democratic culture in the country, and to wonder whether the polity has failed to embrace the virtues of the country's name.

Elections which took place on 28 November 2011 were noted by the EU observer mission as having "serious deficiencies" and warned that the bloc would "re-evaluate its support come the next stages in the Congo's democratic process". The US Carter Centre, which sent observers to the elections, said that the vote was "too flawed to be credible." The Congolese Catholic Church, which had deployed the largest observer mission to the elections (30,000 people) said that the stated results "did not confirm the truth". Meanwhile France's ministry of foreign affairs has "deplored and criticized" the irregularities, as well as the "reported violence". However, instead of calling for an annulment of the results - even though France acknowledged that the irregularities "marred" the vote - it has favoured dialogue and called for lessons to be learned. The same is true of the US. Whilst the Obama administration has been critical of the electoral process, it has not called for an annulment. In a country where civil society (both at home and abroad) is charged and frustrated, these denouncements amount to very little when the status quo is allowed to just continue and smack of self-serving interests.

"Too Flawed to be Credible"

In terms of the management of the elections on 28 November, the Carter Centre detailed impossibly high voter turnouts in some areas, as well as voter intimidation, which was commonplace. A member of the Congolese Diaspora community in the UK spoke of the intimidation and crack-downs on personal freedoms in the post-election period. "Back home, not many people have the internet but many have mobile phones. We send text messages to our friends and families back home about what is happening at home, because they are ill-informed. But now the government has cracked down on this too". This was in relation to the government's closing down of the networks to prevent the dissemination of information and the potential stirring up of Arab Spring-styled anti-government protests. Indeed, the clampdown in the DRC has been harsh, with Human Rights Watch reporting that at least 24 had been killed by the security forces in the aftermath. Many more may actually have been killed as the authorities reportedly launched a rapid clean up operation of the dead bodies.

"Defenders of Democracy, Where are You?"

For the Diaspora community, the festive period did not dampen the resolve to protest on the streets of London. Peaceful protests drew in the crowds in the run up to Christmas in Central London with people bearing placards which read "Defenders of Democracy, Where Are You?", "Merci Tshisekedi Notre Coeur" ("Thank you Tshisekedi, Our Beloved") and "Combatant Jusqu'a la Mort" ("We Will Fight Until We Die"). There was something of a carnival spirit about the demonstrations, with Congolese participants singing in the already lilting local language of Lingala, but the brusque images of death and destruction held up on placards sobered minds, for this was no celebration.

One Congolese activist who spoke with Songhai Advisory admitted that it was time to get more focussed and serious in spreading a strong message about the situation in Congo, and soon enough, the tone of the demonstrations subtly changed. Speeches in English were woven into the campaigns, displaying a resolve to reach out to sympathisers beyond the Congolese community. At the protest on Christmas Eve, organisers had managed to canvass support from Islington MP Jeremy Corbyn. To an expectant crowd he criticised the BBC for its scant coverage of the situation in DRCongo, which he claimed preferred to focus on Russia -which held an election at a similar time. He was also critical of Western countries, saying "if governments are serious about democracy, where are they in the DRC? There's a wider agenda - Congo has been disgracefully treated".

This "wider agenda" is something which is spoken about often by the Diaspora community in relation to the West's attitude to the DRC. Indeed, as far as natural resources are concerned, the DRC is one of the richest countries in the world. It boasts a host of minerals including diamonds, copper, uranium and coltan (used in the production of mobile phones). The Congo River is also the second longest in Africa and has significant hydro-electric potential. The feeling that the West has been largely indifferent to the situation in the DRC is juxtaposed with the groundswell of support for Ivorian former opposition leader now president, Alassane Ouattara, when, following the announcement of results by the Constitutional Council over a year ago, he also maintained that he was the rightful winner. With the support of the international community, Ouattara's opponent and former Ivorian president Laurent Gbagbo was toppled and subsequently extradited to The Hague to face war crimes charges. But such a scenario in the DRC is not on the cards. According to Jean-Marie Guehenno ," (the U.N.'s former head of peacekeeping, and now a professor at Columbia University) there has been "a gradual political disengagement in Congo." He continued: "There is definitely Congo fatigue after 11 years and billions of dollars. There is no appetite for repeating the Ivory Coast experience". There is also the perception that the West is not particularly fond of outspoken, veteran opposition figure Tshisekedi, who may be more challenging to work with than Kabila. But as one Congolese blogger Mvemba Phezo Dizolele put it: "Whether or not diplomats like Tshisekedi, he is an icon to the Congolese ... For a segment of the population, he is the man who best articulates their aspirations and dreams".

The Diaspora movement has been generally peaceful, but, as alluded to by a Congolese demonstrator, this could be changing. On 1st January 2012 it was reported that the government of the DRC denounced an attack on the nation's Senate chief in Paris as the Diaspora community there who oppose Kabila fought back. A 76 year old senator, Leon Kengo, was attacked at the Gare du Nord station on Saturday 31st December - some reports speak of his teeth being knocked out and he was reportedly hospitalised in Paris. Congo's Communications Minister Lambert Mende believes Kengo was targeted because he stood in the elections, (polling a mere 4%), yet to Tschisekedi's supporters, these were votes which could have been directed towards their leader. Kengo also attended the inauguration of Kabila.

Conclusion

Kabila's legitimacy is strongly challenged. However, the security force crackdowns and the heavy police presence - which halted Tshisekedi's planned swearing in ceremony at the Martyrs' Stadium in Kinshasa - will frustrate the plans of the opposition to pressurise Kabila out. But the Diaspora community, a step removed from Kabila's force of arms, appears resolved to keep up the fight in applying pressure on Western capitals and also on their friends and families back home to persist. A proverb from the Congo says that "if you have spoiled your name at home, go and live elsewhere" and that is precisely what civil society movements in the Diaspora, vehemently opposed to Kabila, are hoping for.

View from the Ground:

"The movement is quite homogenous, even we are surprised by the level of unity because beforehand, we were really divided. We want to reach out to all the Congolese youth organisations, hand out leaflets to all but above all, the Congolese. We will never negotiate with Kabila and a power sharing situation is not even imaginable. Without Congo, there are no mobile phones, there are no computers. It's for this reason that the West is sowing hatred in Congo. If [the West] doesn't listen, our mode of pacifist resistance will change." - Congolese demonstrator

View From the Ground:

"We provide the remittances, so they must listen to us. My father, who is a civil servant, has not been paid for five years under Kabila. So yes, if we tell our families to continue to protest, they have to, because we [the Diaspora] are the ones sweating for them. We want to go on holidays, we want to go out to places, but we can't. We must work for our immediate families here and also for our families back home, because the system does not provide for them. That is why Kabila must go." - A Congolese father of one living and working in London who is also looking after his sister’s four children and his father back home.

Kissy Agyeman-Togobo writes for Songhai Advisory LLP, a bespoke business intelligence consultancy providing critical insight on market opportunities in Sub-Saharan Africa.

  • Comment (2)

Copyright © 2012 African Arguments. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 130 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.

Comments Post a comment

  • ras sideeq
    Jan 5 2012, 08:35

    STATED FROM THE VERYBEGINNING THAT THIS ELECTION WAS FLAWED MISRABLY. WHAT THE WEST IS PROVIDING IS THE START OF A NEW KIND OF PROCES THEYALLOW FLAWED ELCTIONS TO PROGRFESS THEN THEY ALLOW FOR THEIR CHIMPNZEES TO ASSUME POST. IT IS MY FEELING THAT TIS HOW WE WILL SEE AFRICAN GOVERNMENTS ELECTED FOR THE NEAR FUTURE. THERE IS NO WANT TO RECIND THE ELECTION AS THEY SAID THEY DONT WANT TO INTIATE ANOTHER IVORIAN CRISIS. THIS WAS THE ELECTION WHERE LAURENT GBAGBO ASKE FOR THE VOTES TO BE RECOUNTED AND THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF THE LAND DISMISSED THE ELCTION AS FRUADULENT.THEIR IS CONSIDERABLE DIFFERNCES TO IVORY COAST; MR. GBAGBO ASKED FOR ANOTHER COUNT FROM INTERNATIONAL OBSERVERS WHICH HE SAID WOULD SERVE THE COUNTRY BETTER. THE WEST REFUSED EVEN THOUGH THEIR WAS CONSIDERABLE DEMOSTRATION AGINST THIS. INSTAED THE PEOPLE WERE FORCED IN TO A SECOND CONFLICT WHERE THEY WERE THEN TERRORISED INTO ACCEPTING QUATTAR AS ELECTED HEAD OF STATE. TODAT THE IVORY COOAST IS A FRENCH COLONY WITH PUPPET HEADS OF STATE. WE ALSO MUST SEE THAT OBAM IS NOT INETERSTYED IN DEMOCRACY HE PREFERS DICTATORS AS WE SEE IN BAHRAIN YEMEN AND THE MILITARY IN EGYPT. OBAMA IS NOW OFFICIALLY THE HEAD OF UNITED STAES WITH MARTIAL LAW ITS LEGAL TENDER. THESE ARE THE THINGS THAT THEY ALLEGEDLY FIGHT AGAINTS WORLD WIDE BU THIS IS NOT THE TRUTH THIS WHAT THEY PROPOGATE. THERE WILL BE NO CALL FOR KABILA TO RE;ENTY AND EXCUSE HIMSELF FROM GOVERNMENT. HE IS THEIR MAN HE WILL BE BRIBED HE WILL SELL OUT THE CONGO TO THE INTERNATIONALS HE WILL NOT REALISE THE BENIFT OF HIS PEOPLE . HE WILL NOT SEE THAT WE NEED TO L;EARN TO BUILD COMPUTERS AS WE HAVE TJHE MATYERIALS NECESSARY. HE DOESNOT SEE THE LITTLE CHILDREN IN DYRE POVERTY WORKING IN THESE MINES THAT COULD BE ANTIONALISE BUILT PROPERLY WHERE THE HIRIRNG OF THE MANY WITH GOOD SALARIES WHICH WOULD ENABLE THE CONGOLESE GOVERNMENT TO BUILD THIS HYDRO ELCTRIC A DAM SO ELECTRITIYY COULD BE SOLD TO NEIGHBORING COUNTRIES WHERE INDUSTRY FACTURIES WOULD POP US SO THE AMNY WOULD HAVE EMPLOYMENT. HE DOES NOT SEE THE FERTILE REGIONS OF THE EAST WHERE MANY COULD EMVBRACE AGRICULTURE ON AVERY HIGH LEVL WHERE MOST OF WEST CEANTRL AND SOUTH AFRICA COULD BE FED. AFRICA NEEDS TO HAVE PEOPLE STUDY AGRICULTURE ON COLEGIATE LEVL TO IMPROVE THE NATIONS AVAILABILITY OF FOOD PRODUCTS. A PLACE LIKE CONGO CAN FARM FRUITS VEGETABLES ETC THIS COULD BE BIG BUSINESS ON THE CONTIENENT. WE NEED MORE TECHNICAL HELP WE WANT TO START PRODUCING COMPUTERS OR EVEN IF WE START SMALL BE MANUFACTURING MOBILE PHONES WHY NOT ?ALL THE MATERIALS ARE THEY.MORE AFRICAN GOVERNMENST MUST PAY ATTENTION TO ALLL AFRICA THIS MEANS NORTH SOUTH EAST AND WEST HAS AN OBLIGATION TO REJECT RESULTS THAT ARE NOT COMPRHENSIVE AND OVERWHELMING. ITS AFRICAS DUTY TO SUBMIT INSTRUMENST AND WAYS TO DEFEAT FRAUD IN ANY AFRICAN GOVERMENTS VOTING SYTEM. AFRICAN LEADERS SHOULD WANT TO STAND SHOULDER TO SHOULDER WITH THEIR BROTHERS WHOM ARE ELECTED DEMOCARTICALY BECAUSE THEY SHOULD ALL HAVE THE SAME HONOURABLE IDEALS. WHERE IS THE AU STANDING UP TO REJCT THIS IF YOU WANT TO REJECT AN ARMED AL SHABAB WHICH WILL BE DIFFICULT TO DO AS WE SEE IN AFGHNISTAN THESE PEOPLE MUST BE INCORPORATED INTO THE PROCESS OF GOVERNMENT. THE US PUSHES THESE CONFLICTS WORLD WIDE AS WE KNOW THE DEVIL FINDS WORK FOPR IDLE HANDS THEY DESTROY DESTRUCT AND THEN RUN AWAY. THERE IS NO PRIZE FOR THESE PEOPLE. THERY ARE RELGATED TO THE DREGS OF VOTE FOR THE WORST MOST IGNOBLE OF ALL BARBARIANS THEY RATE ZERO AS DOES THEIR COMANDER IN CHIEF. AFRICA MUST STOP KILLING ITS PEOPLE ON BEHALF OF SLAVE HOLDERS THIS A TRAVESTY . YOU MUST BELIVE THEY WOULD NEVER VER DREAM OF KILLING THEIR OWN ON YOUR BEHEST O WHY COMPROMISE YOURSELVES? IT IS TIEM TO STAND UP FOR TRUE DEMOCARTCY ON ETHAT IS FULLY INDEPENDNT OF TIES TO OUTSIDERS INSIDERS BUT ONES THAT ARE TRUETOONLY THE PEOPLE WHO ELECTED THEMTO SERVE AND REPRESENT THEM ./ WHO WANTS TO LIVE INA COUNTRY THAT IS EBING GOVERNED FROM WITHOUT ? THIS IS WHY WE SOUGHT INDEPENDECE FROM THE IMPERIALIST COLONISERS. WHY SHOUL WE AFTER SO MANY CEBTURIES OF ABUSE BE STILL BEHOLDEN TO THOSE WHO DID NOUGHT FOR AFRICA ABSOLOUTELY NTHING BUT ABUSE ABUSE ABUSE WHAT HAS CHANGED NOTHING AT ALL. THESE ARE THE SONS OF THE SLAVERES WHO HAVE BEEN TAUGHT IN THEIR SCHOOLS THAT WE ARE THEIR INFERIORS SO THEY ACT ON THIS AND WE WHO IS BLIND REFUSE TO OPEN OUR EYES WE ARE STILL WAITING FO RTHIS WHITE JESUSU TO COME SWOOPING OUT THE SKY TO RESCUE US. I SAY TO MY PEOPLE THIS A FANATSY WQE MUST RESCUE OURSELVES AND THEN WE MUST APLY OUR MENTAL RESOURCES TO UPLIFTMENT AN DSERVE ONE THAT IS NOT PICTURES OR VISIBLE ONE THAT SHINES BRIGHTER THAN THE SUN MUCH MORE RADIANT ON ETHAT SPOKE TO MKOSES AND TOLD HIM TO BOW DOWN BEFORE HIM FOR WHERE HE WALKS IS HALLOW GROUNG OR VERY VERY HOLY GRTOUND AND NOMAN CAN LOOK IN HIS FACE OF HE DIDI HE WOULD SURELY DIE. SO MY BROTHERS NO WHITE GUY CAN SAVE YOU FROM THESE THIEVES WHOM ARE PRETENDING TO BE GODS. IN FACT THEY ARE NOTHING MORE THAN LITTLE DEVILS SENT TO CONFUSE LIE TRICK THEIR WAY THROUGH WHAT THEY KNOW THEY CAN NEVER INHERIT.WE MUST AS A STRONG PEOPLE REJCT ALL THAT IS NOT STRONG BUT WEAK AND FLAWED WE MUST REJECT KABILA BY VOTING IN REPRESENTATIVES THAT WILL NOT ACCOMODATE THE CORRUPT GOVERNMENT THT HE PROPSES AFRICA WILL REJECT ALL PUPPTES AND THEIR ILLEGAL AND MISREPRESENTED GOVENRMENTS. ALL THOSE WHO ARE WORKERS AGAINST THEIR PEOPLE SHALL NOT PRVAIL IN AFRIC WEMUSTMAKE THIS KNOWN AND WHEN THEY ARE CAUGHT WITH THEIR HANDS IN THE TILL THEY WILL LOSE THEIRMHANDS AND WHEN THEY GETT GREEDY AND LUST FUL ILKE THEIR TEACHERS THEY WILL LOSE THEIR EYES. THERE IS NO ROOM FOR CORRUPTION ON THIS GLORIOUS CONTIENENT WE MUST SEEK TO PRESERVE ITS GREATNESS THERE IS NO OTHER CONTIENET LIKE THIS SO WE MUST NOT SUBMIT TO ANY WEAK GOVERNMNEST THT DOES NOT SUPPORT THE PEOPLE ONE HUNDRED PER CENT. WE WANT FREE HEALHT CARE HEALTH CARE THAT IS PROFESSIONAL AND EDUCATED WE HAVE MANY CHILDREN WOMEN MAN WHO NEEEDS THESE SKILLS CONGO HAS THE WEALTH TO SUPPORT AL ITS MAJOUR DEVELOPMENTAL INTIATIVES WHY AREN'T THY BEING PURSUED BECAUSE THE WEST IS BUSY KEEPING THE PEOPLE IN UNDERDEVELOPMENT UNDEREDUCATION THEY FOSTER CONFLICTIN CONGO.THEYAS THE REBELS DO RAPE AND PLUNDER THIS IS SOME THING THESE REBELS LEARNED FROMTHEIR FORMER RULERS. THEY RAPED AFRICAN WOMEN WITH IMPUNITY THEY MURDERED AFRICAN CHILDREN WITH IMPUNITY THEY STARVED UNDR FED SOLD ALL THEIR PRODUCTS ABROAD SO THE AFRICAN NEVER GREW HOW ABSOLOUTELY WHITE IS THIS?

  • Prezedu
    Jan 5 2012, 11:08

    Thanks for the above extended comments from Ras Sideeq. Most readers are acting just like the West, by not commenting at all on recent articles. As a regular commentor, we encourage others to speak-up and express their opinions or react to most DRC's aritcles. This current article resonates well with what I have been advocating recently during these elections. My point is very clear and consistant that DRC name does not match with her democratic behavoir. I am not trying to deviate from the article which focuses on ongoing electorale events. But, I am trying to question the essence of the name DRC. It is here where we need to start. Why are we calling ourselves a Democratic country???. Is it because we partcipate in democratic elections???. If so, most countries around the world do vote, and just not us in DRC. We in Diaspora, must incorporate the fight to CHANGE THE NAME DRC in our strategy. We cannot adopt a name that has brought shame to us. We must remove the word Democratic from DRC, and that will be our first victory against the West. All Congolese Intellectuals are asked to join-in in this new debate.