Daily Maverick (Johannesburg)

Nigeria: Govt Takes the Fight to Boko Haram, but Ignores Underlying Issues

analysis

Johannesburg — Nigerian authorities are bringing the fight to Boko Haram, putting the Islamist militant group on the back foot with "Operation Restore Sanity". What they're not bringing, however, is the economic development or political reform that is essential to solving this problem in the long run.

On Sunday night, the heavy fist of Nigerian law enforcement fell on Boko Haram. In the city of Mubi in Adamawa State, 156 alleged members of the Islamist militant group were arrested in "Operation Restore Sanity", a military raid on what local media described as a "bomb factory"; explosives, chemicals, rocket launchers, machine guns and other weapons were discovered on the scene. Meanwhile, in Damaturu, the capital of Yobe State, the military claimed to have killed 35 people during an overnight gun battle. All the deaths were hostile militants, apparently.

For the Nigerian government, the raids on the two Boko Haram strongholds send a resounding message to the group and to the general public that the authorities are not completely helpless to stem the tide of violence that has been a constant source of irritation and humiliation. Too often, and despite numerous and loud promises to the contrary, the government has failed to protect its citizens.

Since launching its armed insurrection in 2009, attacks attributed to Boko Haram have killed more than 1,000 people in Nigeria. Targets have ranged from the United Nation's office in Abuja to churches, banks and military barracks, and the group has employed almost every tactic from the militant handbook: suicide bombings, grenade attacks, armed robberies, shooting sprees. They've even added a tactic of their own: last month, 30 mobile phone towers in northern Nigeria were targeted in a partially successful attempt to disrupt communications in the region.

All this violence is in support of Boko Haram's main goal: to turn multi-cultural, multi-ethnic, multi-religious Nigeria into an Islamic state governed by strict Sharia law. It is a goal that Boko Haram shares with other Islamist militant organisations across the world, ranging from the Taliban in Afghanistan to Al-Shabaab in Somalia.

It is no coincidence that, like those other examples, Boko Haram operates in one of the poorest parts of the world which has suffered decades of state incompetence and failure. Fundamentalist ideologies seem to thrive in these environments, where people are forced to look for more and more radical solutions to their problems. In northern Nigeria, where Boko Haram is strongest - and where it has concentrated almost all of its violence - this is compounded by a long-standing perception that the largely Muslim north has been discriminated against by the mainly Christian south.

If Nigeria really wants to solve its Boko Haram problem, these are the issues the government should be looking to address. After all, history should have taught them that security crackdowns won't make Boko Haram go away.

In fact, it was the last major offensive against Boko Haram in 2009 which was the genesis of the group's current success. The military had isolated the leadership of the group to a mosque and adjoining compound in the northern city of Maiduguri and was given the go-ahead to attack.

The buildings were shelled and then stormed by troops, indiscriminately firing. By the time they were finished, there were around 100 corpses in the mosque, and Boko Haram's leader Mohamed Yusuf was arrested. He later died, Steve Biko-style, 'while trying to escape'.

When Boko Haram regrouped a year later under current chief Abubakar Shekau, it had even more reason to hate the government, and its attacks increased in frequency and intensity. Security forces' heavy-handed response, meanwhile, seemed to support Boko Haram's arguments about the incompetence and brutality of the government.

This brings us to the present, where Nigeria is again sending in the troops to combat the militant organisation which has its roots in poverty and inequality. The government will bloody a few noses, sure, and score a few points; that's what Sunday's successful raids were. It might even succeed in disrupting Boko Haram and slowing the spate of attacks. This is something it has to do - no government can sit idly by while an armed group wreaks havoc.

However, the chances of a military solution actually working in the long-term are slim to non-existent. Look at Afghanistan, where a decade after being removed from power the Taliban are still in control of wide swaths of the country; or Somalia, where a five-country coalition has yet to push Al-Shabaab out of all its strongholds.

Economic development and political reform is the best way to weaken Boko Haram. Unfortunately, there is no sign as yet that Nigeria's soldiers are bringing any of that with them.

  • Comment (1)

Copyright © 2012 Daily Maverick. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 130 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.

Comments Post a comment

  • REASON
    Sep 27 2012, 03:50

    THE PROBLEM IS NOT WITH THE GOVERNMENT BUT WITH THE PEOPLE THEMSELVES. GOVERNMENT HAS BUILT SCHOOLS, THE REFUSE TO GO. GOVERNMENT HAS YEARLY BUDGETED FOR NOMADIC EDUCATION FOR 30 YEARS BUT THE FAIL TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF IT. THEY REFUSE VACCINATIONS TO KEEP THEIR YOUNG PEOPLE FROM DISABILITY. THEY WOULD RATHER BEG THAN WORK. THEY DENY NON LOCAL INDEGINES OPPORTUNITY TO INVEST IN THEIR AREA. THEY BURN THEIR BUSINESSES KILL THEM AND CHASE THEM OUT. THE PROBLEM IS IN THEIR CULTURE AND ITS MARGINALIZATION OF THEIR WOMEN WHO HAPPEN TO BE THE MAJORITY OF THE POPULATION. AMONG THEM THEIR TEEMING WOMEN CONTRIBUTE NOTHING TO THEIR FAMILIES AND TO THE NATION. ALL THEY DO IS SIT AT HOME AND MAKE BABIES IN THEIR DOZENS WHO THEY ARE UNABLE TO RAISE UP AS RESPONSIBLE MEN. THE PROBLEM IS A NON TOLERANT, DESTRUCTIVE, EXTREME RELIGIOUS MINDSET! THE PROBLEM IS IN THEIR FATALISTIC PREDESTINATION BELIEF SYSTEM THAT THEY DO NOT WANT TO CHALLENGE AND CHANGE. THE PROBLEM IS THEIR FEUDAL SYSTEM THE DIVIDE BETWEEN THE POOR CALLED TALAKAWA AND THE RICH. THE NORTH HAS MORE STATES, MORE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND RECEIVES MORE REVENUE THAN THE SOUTH EAST. THE PROGRESS OF THE SOUTH EAST WAS NOT AS A RESULT OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT PROGRAMS! THE SOUTH EAST AS WE KNOW WAS NEGLECTED AFTER THE CIVIL WAR. BUT THE PEOPLE HAVE PULLED THEMSELVES OUT OF POVERTY THAT THE WAR LEFT THEM THROUGH HARD WORK. THE NORTH SHOULD CHANGE HER WAYS AND STOP WAITING FOR GOVERNMENT.