15 January 2013

Liberia: PUP Violators Must Be Prosecuted

Photo: Greenpeace International
Logging destruction.

Global Witness has recommended prosecution for those responsible for the widespread illegality and abuses associated with the violation of Liberia's natural resources by failing to follow the legal regulation of acquiring the Private Use Permit (PUP).

Global Witness also urged the Liberian government to implement the report of the Special Independent Investigative Body (SIIB) report in which the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry Development Authorities (FDA), and the Ministry of Lands and Mines were rebuked for their role in the administration of the PUP.

The report said President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf's January 4 Executive Order expanding a moratorium on logging under Private Use Permits is a welcome move towards restoring the rule of law in Liberia's forest sector. The Order also establishes that those found to be responsible for the widespread illegality and abuses associated with these permits will be subject to criminal prosecution.

These moves follow the publication of a report by a Special Independent Investigating Body, established by the President, documenting legal violations and fraud in the issuance of Private Use Permits, which cover a quarter of Liberia's land area.

To prevent such abuses from reoccurring, Global Witness urges the Government of Liberia to fully implement the Body's recommendations, including cancelling all Private Use Permits and prohibiting companies and individuals involved in illegal activities from participating in commercial forestry activities in Liberia.

In an official statement accompanying the Executive Order, President Johnson Sirleaf also announced that logs cut under Private Use Permits may be confiscated and sold, with proceeds used to cover taxes owed by logging companies and to compensate affected communities.

The President announced the establishment of a Special Prosecution Team within the Ministry of Justice to prosecute legal violations related to Private Use Permits and a full assessment by the Land Commission of all land title deeds underlying the permits. The government will need the support of its international partners to ensure that it has the capacity to follow through with these important measures.

Suspending and ultimately cancelling Private Use Permits is not only an important step towards regaining control of Liberia's forest sector, it also makes economic sense. Recent claims that the government will lose revenue as a result of the Executive Order are overstated and fail to acknowledge that Private Use Permits require logging companies to pay little in taxes.

Some of the companies holding permits, including Atlantic Resources and other companies linked to notorious Malaysian logger Samling, already owe the government millions of dollars in taxes under other logging licenses, sources said.

Any costs of the moratorium could be compensated for by collecting taxes owed by logging companies, confiscating and auctioning illegally harvested timber, and seeking compensation for timber illegally exported by Atlantic Resources in 2012 in contravention of an earlier moratorium.

In the wake of the Private Use Permit scandal, the report said it is critical that the Liberian government work with rural communities to find alternate uses for their forests.

In a statement also made on 4 January, Deputy Justice Minister Benedict Sannoh emphasized this point, calling upon donors such as the U.S. and EU to help the country build communities' capacity to manage their forest resources and develop alternative livelihoods that are not based on logging.

If Liberia is to ensure that abuses like those associated with Private Use Permits are not repeated and that the country benefits from its forests, Sannoh said such support will be vital.

Copyright © 2013 New Democrat. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica publishes around 2,000 reports a day from more than 130 news organizations and over 200 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.