Sudan: Genocide Scholars Letters to the U.S. Special Envoy to Sudan and the U.S. Government's Atrocities Prevention Board Go Unanswered

opinion

On November 27, 2012, over 50 scholars of genocide studies from around the world wrote a letter to U.S. Special Envoy Sudan Princeton Lyman regarding their concern about the crisis in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile in Sudan. Mr. Lyman, for some reason, chose not to respond to the letter. Shortly after the genocide scholars sent the letter to Lyman, he, for whatever reason, tendered his resignation. (The copy of the letter Lyman did not respond to is included below.)

Then, on December 12, 2012, over 60 scholars of genocide studies and anti-genocide activists sent a letter to the U.S. Atrocities Prevention Board (APB), a board that President Barack Obama personally established and has touted as being part of a sea change in regard to how past administration had dealt with issues of crimes against humanity and genocide. The letter was sent in care of Ms. Samantha Power, a member of the National Security Council and Chair of the Atrocities Documentation Board. That letter also went unanswered. Subsequently, in January 2013, Power, for some reason, submitted her resignation and left government service. (The copy of the letter sent to the Atrocities Prevention Board is included below, following the letter that was sent to U.S. Special Envoy Lyman.)

The aforementioned genocide scholars are preparing to resend the letter to the Atrocities Prevention Board in the hope of getting a response to their concerns. The lack of response, thus far, seems to speak volumes to the APB's lack of interest in and concern about the opinions of scholars and activists. That, though, is in direct contradiction of Obama's words that "citizens and activists, who have been carrying the torch,...are partners in this work."

November 27, 2012

Special Envoy Princeton Lyman

United States Department of State

Bureau of African Affairs

Washington, D.C. 20520-6258

Dear Envoy Lyman:

First, thank you for your recent letter of November 1, 2012, in response to our (scholars of genocide studies') missive regarding the ongoing crises in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile in Sudan. Second, thank you, too, for inviting us to take part in your conference call on November 14, 2012, during which you provided an update vis-à-vis the various situations in Sudan (Darfur, South Kordofan, and Blue Nile), and the U.S. efforts regarding these ongoing situations.

Prior to positing numerous concerns and questions we have in regard to issues you raised in your letter and conference call, we wish to convey our appreciation of the tough situation you face: dealing with a regime in Khartoum that is better at making promises than keeping them; making food available along the border of The Republic of South Sudan and Sudan only to realize that many (especially infants, the elderly and the ill) are continuing to starve to death in the Nuba Mountains; witnessing the UN Security Council repeatedly issue Chapter VII Resolutions vis-à-vis the humanitarian crises in Sudan but never following through by getting truly tough; and having to swallow Khartoum's cavalier dismissal of U.S. entreaties and UN resolutions.

At the outset, we feel compelled to duly note that the debilitating and deadly malnutrition and desperate conditions currently faced by the Nuba Mountains people are not caused by crop failures or flooding. Indeed, we have solid information from local sources that the bombing of civilians by GoS aircraft, which began in June 2011 and have continued unabated throughout the rainy season (even if less regularly), is responsible for the decimation of people's villages, homes and farms. Tellingly, when various organizations and individuals have suggested the critical need to transport humanitarian aid to the region, the response (from both the U.S. Government and the UN) is that the GoS has threatened to halt all such efforts by any means necessary.

Statements by President Bashir, backed up by videos recording the words of his subordinates on the ground, make it very clear that Khartoum's intent, from which it will not be deterred by outside diplomatic pressure, is to physically eliminate the peoples of the Nuba mountains. By destroying the people's farms and preventing humanitarian aid from reaching the Nuba Mountains, the GoS' actions indicate an attempt to perpetrate "genocide by attrition." The armed attacks by troops and planes, carried out without meeting any effective opposition, only accelerates the attrition. The Obama Administration, which claims to be in favor of early prevention vis-à-vis crimes against humanity and genocide, has much to answer for.

As for your comments, first, we wish to draw attention to the contradictory information we've garnered from various sources regarding the actual amount of food that has reached those remaining in the Nuba Mountains. In your letter of November 1, 2012, you stated that as a result of the United States' effort "we have reached 470,000 people in South Kordofan with food and 88,000 with non-food items, such as medicines, seeds, tools, and other material. The food represented roughly half-rations that could sustain the recipients through the rainy season." Conversely, another authoritative source has informed us that no more than 5.5 thousand tons of food were delivered into the Nuba Mountains during this year's dry season - and absolutely nothing into Blue Nile. That is extremely disconcerting in light of the fact that humanitarian logisticians estimate that roughly 1,700 metric tons of food per month are required per 100,000 of population in need. Using the current UN figure for South Kordofan and Blue Nile, and not including Upper Nile and Unity, this means roughly 3,000 tons per week are required. A dramatic shortfall by any calculation.

Do you, in fact, know how much food has reached the people still stuck in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile? Do you have any sense - even a rough estimate - how many individuals are suffering from severe malnutrition? Starvation? Or, even a crude estimate as to how many individuals have perished by now due to severe malnutrition (or the effects thereof) and starvation?

Second, in your letter of November 1st and during your conference call on November 14th, you suggested that the seeds and tools that were donated to the Nuba Mountains, along with the fact that this is harvest season, could bode well for the people. However, based on sources in the Nuba Mountains, we fear the situation is not that sanguine. More specifically, it is our understanding that while the situation may look "bright" for some since they will be able to harvest and eat their produce, "it is also a fact that due to the lack of adequate amounts of food in August and September people began eating their produce even before it was ripe. Furthermore, under normal conditions a family would not even start eating the fruits of the new crop until January or February" (Nuba Reports, November 1, 2012). Essentially, this means that an untold number of families have already tapped into next year's food supply. Furthermore, the same source reported that "some areas of the Nuba Mountains got very little rain and thus some crops were poor this year." The point is, the efforts of the U.S. have been far from enough to ameliorate ongoing hunger or worse.

A classic example of "worse" was documented in a recent statement issued by "Nuba Reports": Dr. Raphael Veicht, a physician with Cap Anamur Emergency Doctors, who is heading up a tiny hospital in the Nuba Mountains, has reported witnessing "a sharp increase in malnourished children over the past five months." Many of the young children "were suffering from severe malnutrition." He also reported "it was likely that there were people who were so weak they could not make the long trek to the hospital and were starving to death."

Concomitantly, reports coming from highly reliable sources in the Nuba Mountains assert that "most villages in Abassyia County in north eastern South Kordofan have been burned down recently and these villagers' food stocks were destroyed and they were not able to farm. They are currently displaced in the mountains. Not only will these people not have food but they are in a region that is extremely difficult to reach."

Additional information we've received indicates that the food being provided by the U.S. along the South Sudan/Sudan border was being given to the refugees; and in turn, the refugees purposely limited their consumption of the rations so that they could carry what they had left to those remaining in the mountains. The point is, it seems that much less food is getting up to the Nuba Mountains than some seem to think. Is this your understanding of the matter as well? If so, is there a reason why the U.S. has not at least doubled the amount of food donated?

The upshot is that while food donated by the United States may have warded off mass starvation in the Nuba Mountains, there are still plenty of people suffering and dying there due to the GoS' obstructionary actions. And many of those perishing are the youngest of the young, the oldest of the old, and the sickest of the sick. Does this not resonate with the highest levels of power within the White House? From our perspective, it seems as if it doesn't.

Indeed, in a very real sense, it seems that the international community is fine with this latest crisis in Sudan as long as the numbers of dead do not creep too high and no concentration-camp-like skeletal bodies appear on television news channels and in local, state, regional and national newspapers across the globe. Half-hearted efforts to stave off starvation are akin to attempting to stave off a tsunami by erecting paper fences along a beachfront.

Third, during your conference call, when asked by Samuel Totten, University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, whether the US government had any statistics in regard to the extent of severe malnutrition and starvation in the Nuba Mountains and/or the mortality rates of the people in the Nuba Mountains, you replied that since no outside organizations or agencies are allowed into South Kordofan or Blue Nile, there was no way to conduct a formal assessment along those lines. Our question is this: If the U.S. government is truly interested in conducting such assessments, why couldn't they be carried out in the various refugee camps in The Republic of South Sudan, where literally hundreds of individuals are flowing over the border every single week seeking sanctuary? Not only would the researchers have tens of thousands of individuals to choose from but the latter would likely be from various areas within South Kordofan and have been in the camp for various amounts of time, all of which would be ideal for such a study.

Fourth, during the conference call you mentioned that numerous sanctions have been applied against Sudan. In doing so, you seemed to suggest that sooner or later Sudan will feel their effect and thus begin to cooperate with the international community. Perhaps. But how can the U.S. and the international community allow month after month after month (and in many cases, year after year after year) to go by while Sudan continues to kill its own people in Darfur, carry out murderous attacks against its own people in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile, starve to death its own people in the Nuba Mountains, and engages in one ethnic cleansing spree after another in various regions of its nation? It makes absolutely no sense. Essentially, it is giving credence to vacuous promises and abject lies by a government, Sudan, that has absolutely no compunction about engaging in bald-faced lies. Our question for you and President Obama is this: Why in the world has the Obama Administration not applied and/or pushed for sanctions against Sudan as tough as those that have been applied to Iran?

If the point of sanctions is to push and prod a nation into better behavior and the sanctions applied thus far are ineffective then it is obvious that the sanction regime must be ratcheted up. It is high time for the Obama Administration (and the international community) to recognize and admit that the sanctions imposed on Sudan have not had the desired effect.

In your letter you stated that the U.S. continues to "strongly condemn" the actions of al Bashir and the GoS, but that means little to nothing to the culprits. Indeed, their translation of such condemnation, sans tough action, seems to be: "Who cares? In the end, we have no punitive actions of consequence to deal with."

Fifth, as you well know, the Government of Sudan and its leaders, particularly President Omar al Bashir, are untrustworthy, unreliable, and experts at dissimulation. Time and again, both during the crisis in Darfur and now during the crises in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile, the GoS and al Bashir have made promises one day only to break them the next. Currently, the GoS is playing games with the international community -- and, literally, with peoples' lives - in regard to the "tripartite initiatives," which would have allowed for the creation of a humanitarian corridor to provide humanitarian assistance to people affected by the crises in South Kordofan and Blue Nile areas. Sudan waffled over whether it would even sign onto the initiative (February-July 2012), and then when it signed a memorandum of understanding to implement the initiative within 90 days (August 5, 2012), it allowed the period to elapse without any movement at all. Then, on November 3, 2012, Ahmed Haroun, the governor of South Kordofan, vowed "that no talks will be held with the Sudan People's Liberation Movement-North (SPLM-N) until the defeat of the rebel group" (Sudan Tribune). Days later, on November 6, 2012, Agence France-Presse reported that the GoS asserted that "There is no humanitarian crisis in the war-torn South Kordofan and Blue Nile States." And then, a day later, the GoS blatantly lied that it had "fulfilled all its commitments toward the implementation of the [tripartite] initiative" (November 7, 2012).

That is not the entire story. What has not been mentioned is that the GoS and al Bashir got away with exactly the same murderous plan in the 1990s in the Nuba Mountains. And the impunity for the latter crimes swiftly dovetailed into the genocidal crisis in Darfur. As a result of the killings in Darfur, the International Criminal Court (ICC) issued a warrant for al Bashir's arrest on charges of crimes against humanity, war crimes and genocide and an arrest warrant for Haroun on charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity. What leads the U.S. government to continue to believe that the GoS and al Bashir will eventually, one of these years (not days or months, but years), honor an agreement, especially when it is aimed at helping their putative enemies (meaning, the civilians of the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile, including women, children and infants and the elderly)?

Year after year after year, diplomacy has been tried and yet the GoS continues to kill at will and thumb its nose at international law and the will of the international community. Talk has lorded it over action. It is time to act, and to act boldly. People are dying and it is untoward to be silent and passive in the face of such atrocities. Likewise, it is unconscionable to accept the status quo; more of the same by the U.S. and international community (i.e., talk, talk and more talk) is bound to result in more of the same by the GoS (i.e., broken promises, more destruction, more deaths, more heartbreak).

With all due respect, Envoy Lyman, for the last dozen years the GoS and al Bashir have been treating both the United States and the international community as fools: "a person [or entity] who has been tricked or deceived into appearing or acting stupid." By all accounts, the GoS and al Bashir have hoodwinked and duped the U.S. and the international community time and again by issuing fatuous promises that the latter never intended to honor. One can almost hear the laughter of derision in the corridors of power in Khartoum as they celebrate yet another successful act of bamboozlement.

Sixth, word has it that a key, if not the main, reason why the United States has taken a kids-glove-like approach to the genocidal actions and serial ethnic cleansing by the GoS in such places as Darfur, the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile is because Sudan is playing ball with the U.S. vis-à-vis America's "war on terrorism." Seemingly, the U.S. Government's war on terrorism supercedes all other policies and promises, including the Obama Administration's purported dedication to preventing crimes against humanity and genocide.

Rumors are also rife that an adjunct reason for the U.S. going easy on Sudan is that it (the U.S.) has drone bases dotting Sudan and wishes to retain them - if not at all costs then certainly at the cost of the lives of those residing in Sudan's peripheries. Is that, in fact, the case?

In light of the above and the ongoing death and destruction in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile, we call on you -- and we do so in full appreciation of the gravity of our request -- to resign in protest over both Sudan's habitual tendency to act in bad faith while murdering its own people and the totally inadequate response of the United States and the United Nations to the crises facing the people of the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile.

We believe it would be the honorable and heroic thing for you to do, and that such an action by an individual of your stature might finally prod the United States, if not the international community, to begin to deal with al Bashir and the GoS with the firm resolve that has been missing over the past dozen years. In the end, you, Envoy Lyman, could be instrumental in saving the lives of countless numbers of people in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile, all of whom undoubtedly cherish life as much as we (you, President Obama, Secretary of State Clinton, and the signatories to this letter) do.

We must all ask ourselves: "When all of the bodies in the Nuba Mountains and the Blue Nile are buried, how will history judge us?"

We thank you in advance for your serious consideration of our concerns, questions and request. We look forward to receiving a written response from you.

Sincerely,

Dr. Samuel Totten

Professor Emeritus

University of Arkansas, Fayetteville

Author of Genocide by Attrition: Nuba Mountains, Sudan (Transaction Publishers, 2012) and An Oral and Documentary History of the Darfur Genocide (Praeger Security International, 2010)

Dr. John Hubbel Weiss

Associate Professor of History

Cornell University

Ithaca, New York

Dr. Israel W. Charny

Professor Emeritus of Psychology

Hebrew University

Jerusalem, Israel

Chief Editor of Encyclopedia of Genocide, and Founder and Director, Genocide Prevention Network

Hon. David Kilgour, J.D. and D.D. (Hon)

Canadian Minister of State for Africa and Latin America (1997-2002)

and for Asia-Pacific (2002-2003)

Dr. John Hagan

John D. MacArthur Professor

Northwestern University

Evanston, IL

Author of Darfur and the Crime of Genocide (Cambridge University Press, 2009)

Dr. Hannibal Travis

Hannibal Travis

Associate Professor of Law

Florida International University - College of Law

Miami, Florida

Author of Genocide, Ethnonationalism and the United Nations: Exploring the Causes of Mass Killing Since 1945 (Routledge, 2012)

Dr. Eric Reeves

Professor of English

Smith College

Northampton, MA

Author of Compromising With Evil: An Archival History of Greater Sudan, 2007 - 2012 (2012), and A Long Day's Dying: Critical Moment in the Darfur Genocide (Key Publishing House, 2007)

Dr. Eric D. Weitz

Dean of Humanities and Arts and Professor of History

City College, City University of New York

New York, NY

Author of A Century of Genocide: Utopias of Race and Nation (Princeton University Press, 2003)

Helen Fein,

Chair of the Board

Institute for the Study of Genocide

New York, NY

Author of Human Rights and Human Wrongs (Paradigm Press, 2007)

Dr. Craig Etcheson

Visiting Scholar

Northern Illinois University

DeKalb, Illinois

Author of After the Killing Fields: Lessons from the Cambodian Genocide (Texas Tech University Press, 2006)

Dr. Ervin Staub

Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Founding Director,

Ph.D. program in the Psychology of Peace and Violence

University of Massachusetts at Amherst

Author of The Roots of Evil: The Origins of Genocide and Other Group Violence

(Cambridge University Press, 1989) and Overcoming Evil: Genocide, Violent Conflict and Terrorism (Oxford University Press, 2011)

Dr. Gerry Caplan

Independent Scholar

Richmond Hill, Ontario, Canada

Author of Rwanda: The Preventable Genocide (Organization of African's Unity's International Panel of Eminent Personalities to Investigate the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda, 2000)

Dr. Douglas H. Johnson

Fellow, Rift Valley Institute

African Researcher in Residence, Center for Peace and Global Citizenship

Haverford College

Haverford, Pennsylvania

Author of The Root Causes of Sudan's Civil Wars and When Boundaries Become Borders

Roger W. Smith

Professor Emeritus of Government

College of William and Mary

Williamsburg, Virginia

Author of "Scarcity and Genocide" (in Michael N. Dobkowski and Isidor Wallimann, Eds. On the Edge of Scarcity: Environment, Resources, Population, Sustainability, and Conflict (Syracuse University Press, 2002)

Prof. Wendy James, FBA, CBE

Professor Emeritus of Social Anthropology

University of Oxford, UK.

Author of War and Survival in Sudan's Frontierlands: Voices from the Blue Nile (Oxford University Press, 2007, 2009)

Professor Linda Melvern

Department of International Politics

University of Aberystwyth

Wales, UK

Author of A People Betrayed: The Role of the West in Rwanda's Genocide (Zed Books, 2009)

Dr. Victoria Sanford

Director

Center for Human Rights & Peace Studies

Professor of Anthropology

Lehman College & the Graduate Center City University of New York

New York, NY

Author of Buried Secrets: Truth and Human Rights in Guatemala (2003)

Dr. Dominik J. Schaller

Research Fellow

Karman Centre for Advanced Studies in the Humanities, and University of Bern

Lecturer, Ruprecht-Karls-University Heidelberg

Heidelberg, Germany

Author of Late Ottoman Genocides: The Dissolution of the Ottoman Empire and Young Turkish Population and Extermination Policies (Routledge, 2010).

Dr. Herb Hirsch

Professor of Political Science

L. Douglas Wilder School of Government and Public Affairs

Virginia Commonwealth University

Richmond, Virginia

Author of Genocide and the Politics of Memory (University of North Carolina Press, 1995)

Dr. Colin Tatz

School of Politics and International Relations

Australian National University

Canberra, ACT, Australia

Author of With Intent to Destroy: Reflecting on Genocide (Verso, 2003)

Dr. Henry Theriault

Professor and Chair of Philosophy

Worcester State College

Worcester, MA

Author of "Denial of Ongoing Atrocities as a Rationale for Not Attempting to Prevent or Intervene" (Transaction Publishers, 2012)

Dr. Maureen S. Hiebert

Assistant Professor of Political Science/Law and Society Program and Senior Fellow, Centre for Military and Strategic Program

University of Calgary

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Author of "Do Criminal Trials Prevent Genocide? A Critical Analysis" (Transaction, 2012)

Dr. Elisa von Joeden-Forgey

Visiting Scholar

Department of History

University of Pennsylvania

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Author of "The Devil in the Details: 'Life Force Atrocities' and the Assault on the Family in Times of Conflict" (Journal of Genocide Studies: An International Journal, 2010)

Dr. Nicholas A. Robins

North Carolina State University

Raleigh, North Carolina

Co-editor of Genocides By the Oppressed: Subaltern Genocide in Theory and Practice (Indiana University Press, 2009)

Dr. Alex Alvarez

Professor of Criminology & Criminal Justice

Northern Arizona University

Flagstaff, Arizona

Author of Governments, Citizens, and Genocide (Indiana University Press, 2001), and Genocidal Crimes (Taylor and Francis, 2009)

Dr. James E. Waller

Cohen Professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies

Keene State College

Keene, New Hampshire

Author of Becoming Evil: How Ordinary People Commit Genocide and Mass Killing (Oxford University Press, 2007)

Dr. Adam Jones

Associate Professor of Political Science

University of British Columbia

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

Author of Genocide: A Comprehensive Introduction (Routledge, 2010)

Dr. Robert K. Hitchcock

Professor of Geography, Michigan State University, and Adjunct Professor of Anthropology, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque

Co-editor of Genocide of Indigenous Peoples (Transaction Publishers, 2011)

Dr. Rouben Adalian

Director

Armenian National Institute

Washington, D.C.

Author of Guide to the Armenian Genocide in the U.S. Archives, 1915-1918 (Chadwyck-Healey, Inc., 1994)

Dr. Philip Spencer

Professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies

Kingston University

London, UK

Author of Genocide since 1945 (London: Routledge, 2012)

Dr. Paul Slovic

Professor of Psychology

University of Oregon

Eugene, Oregon

Co-author of "Can International Law Stop Genocide When Our Moral Intuitions Fail Us?" (Oxford University Press, 2012)

Dr. Amanda Grzyb

Assistant Professor of Information and Media Studies

University of Western Ontario

London, Ontario, Canada

Editor of The World and Darfur: International Response to Crimes Against Humanity in Western Sudan (McGill-Queen's University Press, 2009)

Dr. Donald W. Beachler

Associate Professor of Politics

Ithaca College

Ithaca, New York

Author of The Genocide Debate: Politicians, Academics and Victims (Palgrave, 2011)

Dr. Edward Kissi

Associate Professor of Africana Studies

University of South Florida,

Tampa, Florida

Author of Revolution and Genocide in Ethiopia and Cambodia (Lexington Books, 2006)

Dr. Peg LeVine

Senior Research Fellow/Clinical Psychologist and Medical Anthropologist

Monash University

Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Author of "The Plight and Fate of Children During and Following Genocide" (Transaction Publishers, 2012)

George Shirinian

Executive Director

International Institute for Genocide and Human Rights

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Co-editor, Studies in Comparative Genocide (Macmillan, 1999)

Dr. Rubina Peroomian

Research Associate

University of California, Los Angeles,

Author of The Armenian Genocide in Literature, Perceptions of Those Who Lived Through the Years of Calamity (2012)

Dr. Gregory H. Stanton

Professor of Genocide Studies and President of Genocide Watch

School for Conflict Analysis and Resolution

George Mason University

Arlington, Virginia

Author of "The Eight Stages of Genocide" (Routledge, 2009)

Dr. Robert Skloot

Professor Emeritus

Department of Drama

University of Wisconsin, Madison

Author of If The Whole Body Dies: Raphael Lemkin and the Treat Against Genocide (Parallel Press, 2006)

Dr. Peter Balakian

Donald M. and Constance H. Rebar Professor of the Humanities Colgate University Hamilton, New York Author of The Burning Tigris: The Armenian Genocide and America's Response (HarperCollins, 2003)

Tanya L. Domi

Adjunct Professor of International and Public Affairs

Columbia University

New York, NY

Author of "Why Giving the European Union the Nobel Prize Was Wrong," The Atlantic Magazine, October 2012

Dr. Elihu D Richter, MD MPH

Hebrew University-Hadassah Genocide Prevention Program

Jerusalem, Israel

Dr. Yael Stein MD

Hebrew University - Hadassah Medical Center

Jerusalem, Israel

Co-founder, the Jerusalem Center for Genocide Prevention

Dr. Michiel Leezenberg

Associate Professor of Philosophy

University of Amsterdam

Amsterdam, The Netherlands

Author, "The Anfal Operations in Iraqi Kurdistan" (Routledge, 2012)

Dr. Rick Halperin

Director, Embrey Human Rights Program

Southern Methodist University

Dallas, Texas

Dr. Kjell Anderson

Project Leader/Senior Researcher

The Hague Institute for Global Justice

The Hague, The Netherlands

Dr. Linda M. Woolf

Professor, Psychology and International Human Rights

Fellow

Webster University

St. Louis, Missouri

Marc I. Sherman, MLS

Chief Librarian

Harry S. Truman Institute for the Advancement of Peace

Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Jerusalem, Israel

Editor of GPN - Genocide Prevention Now

Uriel Levy

Director

Combat Genocide Association

Tel Aviv, Israel

Amy Fagin

International Association of Genocide Scholars

New Salem, Massachusetts

December 5, 2012

Members of the Atrocities Prevention Board

c/o Ms. Samantha Power

Senior Director for Multilateral Affairs and Human Rights

National Security Council Staff and

Chair, Atrocities Prevention Board

1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

Washington, D.C. 20500

Dear Members of the Atrocities Prevention Board:

We (scholars of genocide studies and human rights activists) are vitally concerned about the ongoing crisis in the Nuba Mountains, Sudan. Since July 2011, the Government of Sudan (GoS) has carried out a scorched earth policy against the Nuba Mountains people. Using both aerial and ground attacks the GoS has, as it did in Darfur, not only attempted to quell the actions of the rebels active in the area but murdered innocent civilians (including children and infants), displaced between 200,000 and 300,000 people from their villages and homes, purposely destroyed the peoples' farms thus leaving them bereft of food on which to exist, and prevented humanitarian aid from reaching those now seeking sanctuary in the mountains looming over their destroyed farms. As the rainy season has come to an end, the GoS is ramping up for a more concerted aerial and ground campaign against the Nuba Mountains people and those of the Blue Nile. Both the U.S. Government and the international community have largely stood by and watched this tragedy unfold.

We are well aware of U.S. Envoy Princeton Lyman's varied diplomatic efforts and his attempts to reason with Khartoum. Unfortunately, though, his efforts have not sufficed and clear evidence of that is the fact that the attacks by the GoS have been relentless and more murderous as time has gone by. We are also cognizant of the fact that small quantities of surreptitious aid provided by the U.S. have been welcomed by people of the Nuba (although none reached the people of Blue Nile); but it provided only a very small fraction of what is needed. The dry season has begun and it is once again possible to move food, medicine and other supplies on the ground, but without secure access, this improvement in transport conditions counts for little.

There is a point, we believe, when it should become self evident that the continuation of endless dialogue with a state that has engaged in serial crimes against humanity, genocidal-like actions, and ethnic cleansing and engaged in habitual denial of its responsibility and been a purveyor of deceit and broken promises, is total waste of time. As hundreds of thousands of innocents needlessly suffer, there is a moral imperative that the continual "diplomatic" talking, negotiating, pleading, and ultimately begging with leaders of such openly deceptive and destructive strategies must be replaced by concrete and effective action -- action that stanches the killing and death due to mass starvation as a direct result of the destruction of farms and foodstuffs and the obstruction of humanitarian aid to those in need. That time, we believe, is now.

As you undoubtedly know, the time to address a crisis heading towards mass violence is early on; only in that way is it likely the crisis will be nipped in the bud. Unfortunately, that has not happened in the case of the Nuba Mountains. Some three months after the establishment of the Atrocities Prevention Board (APB), the GoS began bombing the Nuba Mountains and carrying out ground attacks, and those attacks quickly morphed into an even greater disaster: the dislocation of hundreds of thousands, a massive food crisis, and the ongoing destruction of farms, villages and the murder of even more people, which continues to this very day.

Presidential Study Directive 10 (August 4, 2011) states that "America's reputation suffers, and our ability to bring about change is constrained, when we are perceived as idle in the face of mass atrocities and genocide." From our perspective that is exactly the situation we are now seeing vis-à-vis the Administration's stance in regard to the atrocities, mass displacement, and mass hunger that the GoS has unleashed in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile.

In light of that, we wish to inquire as to whether the APB has addressed the dual crises in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile; and if so, how?

President Obama has stated that one of the results of the creation of the APB was that "Our diplomats will encourage more robust multilateral efforts to prevent and respond to atrocities." Quite frankly, we are still waiting to see this happen in the case of the Nuba Mountains. To date, ineffective diplomacy has substituted for action and as a result the crisis in the Nuba Mountains and Blue Nile has not only gone on for 17 long months but is now on the verge of spiraling totally out of control. The GoS is not only bombing village after village but destroying farm after farm by burning them to the ground.

We understand that along with the APB the President has promised to establish "alert channels" that avail lower-level officials of the right to draw attention (or raise red flags) about potential or actual atrocities in areas of conflict. Have, in fact, the crises in South Kordofan and Blue Nile been the subject of such alerts?

In recent correspondence with U.S. Envoy to Sudan Princeton Lyman we were informed that since it was impossible for anyone to reach the Nuba Mountains due to the prohibitions of the GoS it was impossible to conduct a study into the percentage of people in the Nuba Mountains who are suffering from severe malnutrition and starvation or how many people have perished from starvation. Since a specific component of the APB is to "increase the collection and analysis of information relating to atrocity threats and situations," would it not make sense to conduct an investigation in the refugee camps inside South Sudan? After all, thousands of people have been crossing the border from Sudan to South Sudan for months on end in flight from the terror inflicted on them by the GoS in both South Kordofan and Blue Nile. The point is, there is a solid sample of those who have been in the camps for a relatively long while versus those who have just arrived.

We also must ask: has the APB considered recommending that the U.S. Government prod the UN Security Council to issue a Chapter VII mandate in order to install a peace enforcement contingent in the South Kordofan and Blue Nile to attempt to halt the violence?

Also, has the APB suggested that the U.S. government, either alone or in conjunction with the international community, design and apply tougher sanctions on the GoS for the ongoing and serial murder of its own people, destruction of their villages and farms, and mass displacement of hundreds of thousands of innocent people?

If little to nothing concrete has been attempted or accomplished by the APB along the aforementioned lines, then we strongly urge that the APB immediately call an emergency session to examine how the U.S. Government could use the full range of instruments at hand -- diplomatic, economic, humanitarian, and military - that can be brought to bear on this, the latest, crisis in Sudan.

It is our ardent hope that the new approaches, "tools and expanded capabilities" developed by the U.S. Government for the express purpose of the prevention of atrocities will be implemented in order to prevent the current tragedies in South Kordofan and Blue Nile from expanding into the years-long and deadly affair that Darfur has become. Here, we are referring to, for example, the following, all of which were touted by the White House as approaches that the APB would implement: new kinds of targeted sanctions, financial levers, and getting truly tough on impunity. The latter is especially relevant in light of the fact that President Omar al Bashir is wanted by the International Criminal Court on charges of crimes against humanity, war crimes, and genocide for the atrocities perpetrated in Darfur, and that the Governor of South Kordofan, Ahmed Haroun, is also wanted by the ICC on charges of crimes against humanity and war crimes for atrocities committed in Darfur by the GoS.

As you might recall, when the Genocide Prevention Task Force report, in 2008, called for creation of the Atrocities Prevention Board, it alluded to situations exactly along the lines of the current situation in the Nuba Mountain and Blue Nile regions of Sudan. Indeed, it was clearly stated that the express purpose of an agency such as the APB was to deal, in a decisive fashion, with such humanitarian emergencies in the face of the deep failures of US policy in recent years, especially the case of Rwanda.

We are counting on the APB to honor its charge to "ensure that key decision-makers receive early warning and hear dissenting views" in regard to potential or actual crimes against humanity, ethnic cleansing, war crimes, and genocide. For well over a year now, we have written and submitted letters to Congress, the White House, State, and individual U.S. officials, and to date we've only received replies from Special Envoy Princeton Lyman. While we certainly appreciate his engaging with us, we believe he needs the full-fledge support of top decision makers with the Administration.

We believe it is absolutely critical for the APB and the Administration to address, openly with the rest of the U.S. Government and U.S. citizens, the fate of the people in Nuba Mountains (South Kordofan) and the Blue Nile. Indeed, we believe that silence is acquiescence and goes totally against the grain of President Obama's declaration in April of this year that atrocity prevention is "a core national security interest and core moral responsibility," and "a high priority for his Administration." A lack of attention and action by the APB to these matters would go counter to its stated mission.

We thank you in advance for your serious consideration of our concerns expressed herein, and we await both your written response and your determined action.

Sincerely,

Dr. Samuel Totten

Professor Emeritus

University of Arkansas, Fayetteville

Author of Genocide by Attrition: Nuba Mountains, Sudan (Transaction Publishers, 2012) of An Oral and Documentary History of the Darfur Genocide (Praeger Security International, 2010)

John Marshall Evans

U.S. Foreign Service, Retired

Washington, D.C.

Dr. John Hubbel Weiss

Associate Professor of History

Cornell University

Ithaca, New York

Dr. Frank Chalk

Professor of History and Director, Montreal Institute for Genocide and Human Rights Studies

Concordia University

Montreal, Quebec, Canada

Co-author of Mobilizing the Will to Intervene: Leadership to Prevent Mass Atrocities (McGill-Queen's University Press, 2010)

Hon. David Kilgour, J.D. and D.D. (Hon)

Canadian Minister of State for Africa and Latin America (1997-2002) and for Asia-Pacific (2002-2003)

Dr. Norman M. Naimark

McDonnell Professor

Department of History

Stanford University

Palo Alto, California

Author of Fires of Hatred: Ethnic Cleansing in Twentieth Century Europe (Harvard University Press, 2002)

Rabbi Abraham Cooper

Associate Dean

The Simon Wiesenthal Center

Los Angeles, California

Faith J. H. McDonnell

Director, Religious Liberty Program and Church Alliance for a New Sudan

The Institute on Religion and Democracy

Washington, D.C.

Dr. John Hagan

John D. MacArthur Professor

Northwestern University

Evanston, IL

Author of Darfur and the Crime of Genocide

Dr. Douglas H. Johnson

Author of The Root Causes of Sudan's Civil Wars (James Currey 2003 and 2011), and When Boundaries Become Borders (Rift Valley Institute, 2010)

Fellow, Rift Valley Institute

African Researcher in Residence, Center for Peace and Global Citizenship

Haverford College

Harverford, Pennsylvania

Dr. Benjamin Madley

Assistant Professor

Department of History

University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA)

Author of American Genocide: The California Indian Catastrophe, 1846-1873 (Yale University Press)

Rebecca Tinsley

Freelance Journalist/Author Genocide and Human Rights

London, England

Clair Duffy

Khmer Rouge Tribunal Monitor

Open Society Justice Initiative

Phnom Penh, Cambodia

Dr. Eric Reeves

Professor of English

Smith College

Northampton, MA

Author of Compromising With Evil: An Archival History of Greater Sudan, 2007 - 2012 (2012), and A Long Day's Dying: Critical Moment in the Darfur Genocide (Key Publishing House, 2007)

Dr. Caesar Ricci, MD

Nuba Mountains Advocacy Group

General Surgery Resident

Lincoln Medical Center

Bronx, NY

Damien Lewis

Author (authority on Sudan)

Cork City

Cork County, Ireland

Dr. Ervin Staub

Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Founding Director,

Ph.D. program in the Psychology of Peace and Violence

University of Massachusetts at Amherst

Author of The Roots of Evil: The Origins of Genocide and Other Group Violence (Cambridge University Press, 1989) and Overcoming Evil: Genocide, Violent Conflict and Terrorism (Oxford University Press, 2011)

Dr. Gerry Caplan

Independent Scholar

Richmond Hill, Ontario, Canada

Author of Rwanda: The Preventable Genocide (Organization of African's Unity's International Panel of Eminent Personalities to Investigate the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda, 2000)

Linda Melvern

London, England

Author of A People Betrayed. The Role of the West in Rwanda's Genocide(2009).

Jack Slater Armstrong

Founder/Director

Joining Our Voices

Baton Rouge, LA 70806

Dr. Henry Theriault

Professor and Chair of Philosophy

Worcester State College

Worcester, MA

Author of "Denial of Ongoing Atrocities as a Rationale for Not Attempting to Prevent or Intervene" (Transaction Publishers, 2012)

The Reverend Lowell Grisham

Rector

St. Paul's Episcopal Church

Fayetteville, Arkansas

Dr. Israel W. Charny

Founder and Director, Genocide Prevention Network

Jerusalem, Israel

Chief Editor of Encyclopedia of Genocide

Dr. Dominik J. Schaller

Research Fellow

Karman Centre for Advanced Studies in the Humanities, and University of Bern

Lecturer, Ruprecht-Karls-University Heidelberg

Heidelberg, Germany

Author of Late Ottoman Genocides: The Dissolution of the Ottoman Empire and Young Turkish

Dr. Benjamin Madley

Assistant Professor

Department of History

University of California at Los Angeles

5371 Bunche Hall

Los Angeles, California

Dr. Herb Hirsch

Professor of Political Science

L. Douglas Wilder School of Government and Public Affairs

Virginia Commonwealth University

Richmond, Virginia

Author of Genocide and the Politics of Memory (University of North Carolina Press, 1995)

Apaulo Kussano

Co- Founder

Nuba Mountain Peace Coalition

Dallas, Texas 75225

www.nubapeace.org

Dr. Elisa von Joeden-Forgey

Visiting Scholar

Department of History

University of Pennsylvania

208 College Hall

Philadelphia, PA 19104

Author of "The Devil in the Details: 'Life Force Atrocities' and the Assault on the Family in Times of Conflict (2010).

Dr. Maureen S. Hiebert

Assistant Professor of Political Science/Law and Society Program and Senior Fellow, Centre for Military and Strategic Program

University of Calgary

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Author of "Do Criminal Trials Prevent Genocide? A Critical Analysis" (Transaction, 2012)

Dr. Deborah Dwork

Professor of History

Founding Director of the Strassler Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies Department

Clark University

Worcester, Massachusetts

Author of Flight from the Reich (W.W. Norton, 2009)

Dr. Yael Stein MD

Hebrew University - Hadassah Medical Center

Co-founder, the Jerusalem Center for Genocide Prevention

Jerusalem, Israel

Dr. Paul Slovic

Professor of Psychology

University of Oregon

Eugene, Oregon

Co-author of "Can International Law Stop Genocide When Our Moral Intuitions Fail Us?" (Oxford University Press, 2012)

Terry Nickelson

Executive Director

Our Humanity in the Balance

Asheville, North Carolina

Dr. Rouben Adalian

Director

Armenian National Institute

Washington, D.C.

Author of Guide to the Armenian Genocide in the U.S. Archives, 1915-1918 (Chadwyck-Healey, Inc., 1994)

Dr. Philip Spencer

Professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies

Kingston University

London, UK

Author of Genocide since 1945 (London: Routledge, 2012)

Dr. Christian P. Scherrer

Professor/Senior Researcher

Hiroshima Peace Institute, HPI-HCU

Hiroshima, Japan

Author of Genocide and Crisis in Central Africa: Conflict Roots, Mass Violence and Regional War (Praeger, 2001)

Dr. Robert Melson

Professor Emeritus

Purdue University

West Lafayette, Indiana

Author of Revolution and Genocide: On the Origins of the Armenian Genocide and the Holocaust (University of Chicago Press, 1996)

Dr. Roger W. Smith

Professor Emeritus of Government

College of William and Mary

Williamsburg, Virginia

Author of "Scarcity and Genocide" (in On the Edge of Scarcity: Environment, Resources, Population, Sustainability, and Conflict (Syracuse University Press, 2002)

Dr. Victoria Sanford

Director

Center for Human Rights & Peace Studies

Professor of Anthropology

Lehman College & the Graduate Center

City University of New York

Author of Buried Secrets: Truth and Human Rights in Guatemala (2003)

Dr. Adam Jones

Associate Professor, Political Science

University of British Columbia

Kelowna, BC, Canada

Author of Gendercide and Genocide (Vanderbilt University Press, 2004)

Dr. Kjell Anderson

Senior Researcher/Project Leader

The Hague Institute for Global Justice

The Hague, The Netherlands

Dr. Gregory H. Stanton

Professor of Genocide Studies and President of Genocide Watch

School for Conflict Analysis and Resolution

George Mason University

Arlington, Virginia

Author of "The Eight Stages of Genocide" (Routledge, 2009)

Dr Herbert Ekwe-Ekwe

Independent Scholar

London, England

Author of Biafra Revisited (Dakar and Reading: African Renaissance, 2006) and Essays on African Politics, Genocide, Literature (Dakar and Reading: African Renaissance, 2011)

Dr. Victor Peskin

Associate Professor

School of Politics and Global Studies

Arizona State University

Tempe, Arizona

International Justice in Rwanda and the Balkans: Virtual Trials and the Struggle for State Cooperation (Cambridge University Press)

George Shirinian

Executive Director

Zoryan Institute & The Institute of Human Rights and Genocide

255 Duncan Mill Rd., Suite 310

Toronto, ON

Dr. Robert K. Hitchcock

Department of Geography

Michigan State University

East Lansing, MI

and

Kalahari Peoples Fund

Austin, TX 78756

Co-editor of Genocide of Indigenous Peoples (Transaction Publishers, 2011)

Dr. Craig Etcheson

Visiting Scholar

Center for Southeast Asian Studies

Northern Illinois University

DeKalb, Illinois

Author of After the Killing Fields: Lessons from the Cambodian Genocide (Texas Tech University Press, 2006)

Felisa Tibbitts

Director, Human Rights in Education Program

Carr Center for Human Rights Policy, Harvard

Kennedy School of Government

Cambridge, MA

Eric Cohen

Co-founder and Chairperson, Investors Against Genocide

Chairperson, Massachusetts Coalition to Save Darfur

Co-founder, Act for Sudan

Boston, MA

Dr. Thomas Kühne

Strassler Professor of Holocaust History

Director of Holocaust and Genocide Graduate Studies

Strassler Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies

Clark University

Worcester, Massachusetts

Author of Belonging and Genocide: Hitler's Community, 1918-1945 (Yale University Press, 2010)

Dr. Alan L. Berger

Raddock Family Eminent Scholar Chair in Holocaust Studies

Director, Center for the Study of Values and Violence after Auschwitz

Florida Atlantic University

Boca Raton, Florida

Dr. Robert Skloot

Professor Emeritus

Department of Drama

University of Wisconsin, Madison

Author of If The Whole Body Dies: Raphael Lemkin and the Treat Against Genocide (Parallel Press, 2006)

Dr. Dennis R. Papazian

Professor Emeritus

The University of Michigan, Dearborn

Tanya Domi

Adjunct Professor of International and Public Affairs

Columbia University

New York, NY

Marc I. Sherman

Chief Librarian

The Roberta and Stanley Bogen

Library and Documentation Center

The Harry S. Truman Research Institute for the

Advancement of Peace

Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Jerusalem, Israel

Dr. Gagik Aroutiunian

Associate Professor.

Department of Art, Media & Design,

DePaul University,

1150 West Fullerton, 3rd Floor,

Chicago, IL, 60614

Dr. George Kent

Professor of Political Science, Emeritus

University of Hawai'i

Honolulu, Hawai'i

Author of Freedom from Want: The Human Right to Adequate Food. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press, 2005

Dr. Rick Halperin

Director, Embrey Human Rights Program

Southern Methodist University

Dallas, Texas

Dr. John K. Roth

Edward J. Sexton Professor Emeritus of Philosophy

Claremont McKenna College,

Claremont, California

Editor of Rape: Weapon of War and Genocide (Paragon House, 2012)

Olivia Warham

Waging Peace

London, England

Amy Fagin

International Association of Genocide Scholars

New Salem, Massachusetts

Dr. Yehuda Bauer

Professor Emeritus of Holocaust Studies

Academic Adviser, Yad Vashem

Jerusalem, Israel

Author of Rethinking the Holocaust (Yale University Press, 2001)

Amanda McGee, MSW

Executive Director

League for the Educational Advancement of Human Rights

Boca Raton, Florida

United States

Dr. Linda M. Woolf

Professor, Psychology and International Human Rights

Fellow

Webster University

St. Louis, Missouri

Dr. Rubina Peroomian, Ph.D.

Research Associate, University of California, Los Angeles,

Author of three volumes on the Armenian Genocide, including The Armenian Genocide in Literature, and Perceptions of Those Who Lived through the Years of Calamity (2012).

David Hicks

Church Planter/Strategy Coordinator e3 Sudan

e3 Partners

UNTIL THE WORLD HEARS!

Plano, Texas

Aram Hamparian

Executive Director

Armenian National Committee of America

Washington, D.C.

Jane Spiers

Amnesty International

Bendigo, Victoria, Australia

Dr. Ernesto Verdeja

Assistant Professor of Political Science and Peace Studies

University of Notre Dame

South Bend, Indiana

Author of "Unchopping A Tree: Reconciliation in the Aftermath of Political Violence" (Temple University Press, 2009)

Dr William Fernekes

Lecturer, Rutgers Graduate School of Education

Social Studies Program

New Brunswick, NJ

Dr. Peg LeVine

Associate Professor (Psychologist/Medical Anthropologist)

School of Political and Social Inquiry

Monash University

Melbourne, Victoria Australia

Dr. Michael A. Riff, Director

Center for Holocaust & Genocide Studies

Ramapo College of New Jersey

Mahwah, New Jersey

Geoff Hill

Journalist and Author

Johannesburg, South Africa

Dr. Yair Auron

Associate Professor of History

Department of Sociology, Political Science and Communication

The Open University

Ra'anana, Israel

Author of The Banality of Indifference: Zionism and the Armenian Genocide (Transaction, 2000), and The Banality of Denial (Transaction, 2003)

Ads by Google

Copyright © 2013 South Sudan News Agency. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica publishes around 2,000 reports a day from more than 130 news organizations and over 200 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.