9 November 2016

Uganda: Transform Makerere Into a Private University

Photo: Colleb Mugume/Daily Monitor
Makerere University medical students during a meeting at the College of Health Sciences.
opinion

Nearly all the strikes that have broken out at Makerere University in the past two and half decades have invariably been triggered by issues relating to inadequate funding and administrative ineptitude.

The funding and managerial crisis at the ivory tower manifests itself in a variety of ways including the cumulating incentive arrears for staff, non-payment of pensioners, deteriorating physical infrastructures (especially students' Halls of Residence), wanting quality of the food served in the halls of residence, belated payment of suppliers; acute shortage of even the most basic teaching-learning materials/facilities, and delayed clearance of electricity/water/Internet bills.

It is also reflected in serious internal inefficiencies as evidenced in high retaking rates, missing examination/coursework marks, rampant lecturer and student absenteeism, bloated student to lecture room ratios, too much "organisational fat", ad infinitum.

But, what is the genesis of all these seemingly endemic financial and managerial woes and how can they be mitigated?

Although it would be too simplistic to try to establish cause-effect relationships when discussing Makerere's financial and organisational predicaments, the continued reliance by public universities on the semi-public financing and managerial policy model is, without any doubt, a major contributory factor. Yes, government continues to bear a greater burden of financing even the education of the so-called 'private' university students.

With a weighted annual average unit cost for Makerere university of Shs2,359,043 or about $ 700 for general disciplines and Shs9,073,073 or approximately $ 2,670 for Medicine (as of May 2010), higher education remains a heavily subsidised service in this country.

Equity, efficiency; employment, political stability, economic growth, human rights and "public good" arguments are routinely invoked to justify and legitimise State-funded higher education.

At the same time however, this subsidisation of the costs of higher education by government is proving to be counterproductive in several respects. First, it has to be appreciated that the demand for university education is increasing at a faster rate than the resource-constrained government of Uganda can cope with.

That demand is increasingly becoming more differentiated and 'customised' not only because of the rapidly changing and diversified labour market needs, but also owing to the rapid obsolescence or perishability of the knowledge and skills previously acquired from the educational institutions.

More and more resources are, therefore, continually needed to teach newer courses and to update people's degenerating knowledge, skills and attitudes.

Secondly, rather than reduce inequality, public financing of university education actually reinforces inequality as it obliges students from poorer socio-economic backgrounds (majority of whom are "private" students) to subsidise the cost of educating their colleagues usually drawn from the upper socio-economic quintile (majority of whom are 'government sponsored' students).

Thirdly, public financing of education makes government 'interference' in the management of publicly funded educational institutions warrantable.

Unfortunately, this 'interference' denies such institutions the motivation, flexibility and autonomy they need to attract additional resources from their clientele or the private sector; to ensure optimal utilisation of the available resources; to originate labour market-responsive curricula or to introduce newer and better ways of delivering such innovative academic programmes.

For example, Makerere University has hitherto not been free to revise its tuition/functional fees upwards principally because the political leadership is opportunistically opposed to it.

Nor has the university been able to independently determine and enforce a fees payment schedule to be followed by its students!

More on This

Makerere Closure Paralyses Mulago

The closure of Makerere University has crippled medical services at Mulago hospital and the subordinate hospitals in the… Read more »

Copyright © 2016 The Monitor. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica publishes around 900 reports a day from more than 140 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.