South Africa: Standoff Between Shack Dwellers and Sand Mining Company in Khayelitsha

30 May 2023
GroundUp (Cape Town)
By Vincent Lali

Mining operations halted after families living in shacks near the site complain about sand filling their homes

  • A sand mining company operating in Khayelitsha, Cape Town, has suspended operations after shack dwellers complained their homes are filled with sand and have become inhabitable.
  • The company was granted a permit by the national Department of Mineral Resources and Energy in 2018, before most of the shacks were built on the land.
  • The City of Cape Town gave permission for the company to operate on the land in 2019 and moved some of the families. The others will not be moved until next year.
  • Meanwhile, the City says, the permission it granted has expired.
  • The City is to investigate the matter.

Families in Vosho informal settlement in Khayelitsha say sand being moved by a sand mining project nearby is making their homes uninhabitable.

The area, with shacks perched on a large dune, has been nicknamed Plattekloof after the suburb in the north where homes overlook the city.

According to the City of Cape Town mining company, Maccsand was granted a permit by the national Department of Mineral Resources and Energy in 2018, before most of the shack dwellers occupied the land. The permit expires in 2024. Deputy Mayor and Mayoral Committee Member for Spatial Planning and Environment, Eddie Andrews, said in 2019 the City had granted the company permission to remove the dune. The permission lapsed in October 2021.

After the mushrooming of Vosho informal settlement, the City moved hundreds of families to land near Baden Powell Drive in 2020/21, but a few shacks remain, close to the site. Families living there told GroundUp that their homes, food and other belongings are covered in sand.

"The sand moves into the shacks because the construction vehicles work too close to them. We don't want the project to continue to compromise the safety of the residents," said community leader Baphelele Dokolwana. Dokolwana said residents wanted to be moved.

But the City said environmental restrictions on the land where the Vosho families had been moved meant it could only accommodate 335 families. The remaining families would be moved in 2024, the City said.

Community leader, Nonkululeko Nyathi, said some shacks near the site had been abandoned. "The sand invaded some shacks and made them unliveable. One resident can't even open their door. The affected residents have no money to buy material to rebuild elsewhere," said Nyathi.

Bongani Khawushe, who settled in Vosho in 2018, said he had been forced to abandon his shack. "My brother and I removed the sand from behind my shack with spades, but it kept on piling up," he said. "Everything, including my bed and cupboard, is now covered with sand. I couldn't even open the door on Wednesday when I came to check on my shack." Khawushe has since moved to his brother's home in Makhaza.

Andrews said the City's land use property inspectors would investigate the matter and take appropriate action.

Asked about safety, the City said the residents' complaint "appears to be the result of ineffective implementation of health and safety standards by the mining operator." The City said it was the national department's responsibility to monitor compliance at the site.

The City promised to investigate and ask the mining company to meet the community and ward councillor to address these issues.

In response to GroundUp's questions, John Pretorius, Maccsand's Public Relations Officer, said the dune had overshadowed the shacks "long before Maccsand arrived at the site". He said shack dwellers building shacks there was "tantamount to inflicting safety hazards amongst themselves due to the close proximity of the shacks on the dune".

But, he said Maccsand had abandoned the levelling of the dune to consult with the councillor and the families concerned. "About eight shacks are affected at this point," he said.

"We hope the councillor can arrange meetings so that the levelling can proceed. Maccsand will never put residents' lives in danger as we comply with the Health and Safety Act of 1993," he said.

Pretorius said residents had "started to panic" when the company's excavators began work on top of the hill. "The project manager explained to the residents his intention to make it safer. But they seem not to grasp that Maccsand wants to make it safer."

Read the original article on GroundUp.

Tagged:
Copyright © 2023 GroundUp. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica publishes around 400 reports a day from more than 100 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.