Africa: Kenya Could Lose Its Mombasa Port to China Over SGR Debt

A container is offloaded from a ship at Mombasa port (file photo).

Kenya risks losing port of Mombasa to China Exim bank should Kenya Railways Corporation default the 227 billion shillings ($2.229 billion) it owes the bank.

The loan was used to construct the standard gauge railway (SGR), using Kenya Ports Authority's (KPA) revenue as collateral for the government's debt.

According to a letter sent to the Kenya Ports Authority by the Auditor General, the payment agreement means that the Authority's revenue would be used to pay the debt if the minimum volumes required for consignment are not met.

From the report, China Exim bank would become a principle in over KPA if KRC defaults its obligations and the bank exercise power over the escrow account security.

This arrangement is biased since any non-performance or dispute with the bank would be referred to arbitration in China, whose fairness in resolving the disagreement may not be guaranteed.

The authority did not disclose this guarantee in the financial statements.

The Auditor general has therefore called on KPA to disclose pertinent issues and risk related to the guarantee in the financial statements. It has also been urged to confirm in the management representation letter the KPA assets are not a floating charge/guarantee to the government of Kenya loan as the borrower.

Kenya Port Authority's Revenue

KPA container operations manual order 7 procedures, requires the senior clerical assistant to confirm that the electronic delivery orders (EDOs) have been mapped into CATOs with the correct information and if any variances found are reported to the shipping agent immediately and a terminal hold placed.

"The statement of profit and loss and other comprehensive income reflected operating revenue of Sh42,736,520,000 being an increase of Sh3,132, 843,000 ($30,775,013) or (7.9 per cent) from 39, 603,677,000 ($389,040,780) in the year ended June 2017." Reads the report authored by F.T Kimani on behalf of the Auditor General Mr Edward Ouko.

"The statement of comprehensive income showed Sh42,738,520,000 ($419,835,440) being the operating revenue for the period ended 30 June 2018. It was noted that the operating revenue recorded a 7.9 per cent increase from the previous year's balance." It adds.

According to the Director of the African Department at the International Monetary Fund Mr Abebe Aemro Selassie, at the end of 2017, average public debt in the region was 57 per cent of its GDP, an increase of 20 percentage points in just five years.

"While this is well below the peaks of the early 2000s, the current spike is concerning." he said.

The IMF official also noted that most countries that have funded development and infrastructure through borrowing have failed to generate sufficient additional tax revenues to repay that debt.

"In many cases, countries have not been effective at capturing the return on their investments through their tax systems." he said.

And this is what has just happened in the Kenyan scenario. According to IMF, in a handful of countries, poor governance can also be blamed for unsustainable debt practices.

"As we have been saying for some time, if governments stick to their medium-term fiscal-consolidation and reform plans, debt levels should stabilize or decrease, alleviating debt-related challenges." Mr Selassie said adding that the required adjustments have been delayed repeatedly, owing to political constraints, social pressure for much-needed development spending, and favorable external financing conditions.

This is a recipe for long-term pain; there is no scope to delay the adjustment any longer. As countries work to meet their development goals, it is essential that they move debt sustainability to the top of the policy agenda.

How to redeem ourselves

According to the IMF official, for this to happen, four key areas will need special attention, depending on country circumstances.

"First, in resource-intensive countries, especially the region's eight oil exporters, fiscal consolidation plans must be enacted without delay. This should be coupled with economic diversification, for which the recent recovery in commodity prices provides wider scope." He said.

In much of the rest of the region, the required fiscal adjustment is more modest and can be achieved through steady increases in tax revenues. In most cases, there is potential to raise revenue by 3-5 percentage points of GDP over the next few years. Reaching this level will require broadening the tax base, streamlining exemptions, and strengthening the administration of value-added tax.

"Third, efforts should be made to account for off-balance-sheet risks, improve debt-management capacity, and enhance data coverage of debt and debt exposure." He said adding that "And, fourth, governments must improve prospects for private investment."

For decades, public expenditures offset low levels of private investment. But, faced with growing public-debt vulnerabilities, it is unclear how long this trend can continue. Sub-Saharan Africa's economies should orchestrate a transition from public to private investment by strengthening regulatory and insolvency frameworks, increasing intra-African trade, and deepening access to credit.

For Kenya, it is a wait and see scenario as Kenyans watch with baited breathe to see how the country will redeem itself from this and not lose its port to the bank, keeping in mind that doing nothing will only constrain it's tremendous potential to achieve sustainable and inclusive growth.

See What Everyone is Watching

More From: The Exchange

Don't Miss

AllAfrica publishes around 600 reports a day from more than 140 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.