"Safiya overcame so many obstacles, I can't find the words to describe how much we're proud of her. Internet trolls could not stop her, threats could not stop her. She's the perspective the city needs. It's a really big deal, a tremendous transformation for this city." - Mo Khalid, speaking of his sister Safiya Khalid on her election to the Lewiston, Maine City Council on November 6, 2019
If you´re not from Maine, but have heard of Lewiston in the news in recent years, it may be because of the Lewiston High School boys´ soccer team on which Mo Khalid played, which has won 3 state-wide championships in the last five years (2015, 2016, and 2018, but not this year). Or it may be from the many articles over the years that have noted the welcome, despite difficulties, for African refugees in Lewiston in the past two decades.
Two authors who have closely followed Lewiston for most of this period, Amy Bass and Cynthia Anderson, have recently published books which well complement each other and provide engagingly written and well-researched accounts of the encounters between Lewiston and its new residents. Bass, in One Goal, highlights the story of the soccer team in the years leading up to their first state championship in 2015, and how the school, its soccer coach, and both immigrants and long-time residents fostered school and community pride in a team led by African players. Anderson, in Home Now, follows a set of immigrant and other Lewiston residents over the years from 2016 to early 2019, coping with anti-immigrant sentiments mobilized at national and state level as well as local fears, and how sustained personal interactions built the grounds for mutual understandings.
With a population of 36,000 in 2017, Lewiston is the second-largest city in Maine, after Portland with 67,000. And, of all U.S. states, Maine is the one with the highest percentage white population (94%). Lewiston might seem to be an unlikely location to host as many as 6,000 first or second-generation African immigrants, most of them U.S. citizens. But most residents agree that both Lewiston and Portland (with a larger African immigrant community although proportionately less) have benefited from the new residents. Lewiston in particular has experienced a significant demographic and economic recovery. It has set a precedent that is being closely watched at state-level, as Maine also is the state with the highest median age and a recognized need for a younger work force.
Lewiston differs in many respects from the hundreds of other communities where African immigrants live across the country. It is not among the top five or even the top 50 in terms of numbers of African immigrants. According to census data, about 36 percent of the 2 million first-generation African immigrants live in the five metropolitan areas of New York, Washington, DC, Minneapolis, Dallas, and Atlanta. The proportion of refugees in the immigrant community in Lewiston who were eligible for initial assistance is probably larger than in most other communities. And each geographical area has its own distinct mix of national backgrounds, such as the prominence of Somalis in this immigrant generation and French-Canadians in previous generations in Lewiston.
But one conclusion from these two authors is likely to hold nation- wide. When I asked her about the election of Safiya Khalid, Cynthia Anderson told me that again and again she found that "the most vocal anti-Muslim and anti-refugee voices in the state belonged to those who neither live among nor know newcomers." And Amy Bass, reflecting on her experience covering games of the Lewiston soccer team around the state, similarly noted that contact through sports provided an opportunity for changing minds, despite the hostility often initially apparent among the supporters of opposing teams.
This AfricaFocus Bulletin contains, first, a recent article by Amy Bass, on the election of the first Somali-American member of the Lewiston city council, and a short excerpt from the book by Cynthia Anderson. (Longer excerpts from Bass´s and Anderson´s books are available on line in Sports Illustrated and the Christian Science Monitor respectively.)
These are followed by a short email interview with both authors asking their reflections on developments since their books were written. At the end of the Bulletin is a a selection of links to other recent sources with additional relevant background information, both about the particular Maine experience and the wider context of recent African immigration to the United States.
For previous AfricaFocus Bulletins on migration, visit http://www.africafocus.org/migrexp.php
When Lewiston Wins...
by Amy Bass
November 6, 2019
I love Election Day. I always have. To be able to vote, understanding what so many people have done before me to make sure I can and to make sure others can too is something that I am in awe of every single time I do it. Election Day morning is filled with hope. Election Day evening can be exhausting, exhilarating, or bone-crushingly sad and disappointing.
This year, Election Day was something extra special.
I woke up thinking not of voting, but of soccer. The Lewiston Blue Devils Boys Soccer team was to face the Brunswick Dragons for the regional title. The winner would go on to states. The loser would, well, you know -- go home. Game day proved to be kind of miserable, defined by the cold and rainy weather that often permeates playoff soccer in Maine. But when the clock hit zero, Lewiston prevailed, 3-1, with Suab Nur and Bilal Hersi scoring goals backed by the offensive and defensive skills of both the starting lineup and the bench. Hunched over my phone with my daughter watching the postgame celebration via proud sister Halima Hersi's Instagram live feed, wearing the "I VOTED!" stickers we had received hours before at the polls (and thank you to the kind poll workers who gave the 12-year- old a sticker), I felt the familiar sense of awe that I get when Lewiston plays soccer. It is a feeling that has never gone away, no matter how many times I see them play. Lewiston, it seems, can't stop winning. But the day was far from over.
I first met Safiya Khalid on the sideline of - what else? - a soccer game in Connecticut. Her brother, Mohamed, having graduated from Lewiston High School in 2016, a member of the stories championship squad described in ONE GOAL, was on the field for the Kent School, where he and Abdi H. were spending a postgraduate year playing soccer and preparing for college. It was a gorgeous fall day, quintessential New England, and Safiya and younger brother Sharmarke cheered Mo while goofing around with the various cousins who had accompanied them on the trek. Later, over pizza, Safiya told me about her life, about how she balanced work with school, and regaled me with hilarious tales about her brothers.
Now, just 23-years-old, she is the first ever Somali-American elected to Lewiston City Council.
She nailed down almost 70% of the vote, and she worked for it. She campaigned in person, emphasizing door-to-door canvassing over social media, where trolls loomed large and ugly. She introduced herself to hundreds of people, telling them her story, how she got from the refugee camps of Kenya to the United States. How she majored in psychology at the University of Southern Maine while working full time to help support her family. How she unsuccessfully ran for school board when she was just 20-years-old. And why she wanted Lewiston's elected officials to better represent the diversity that now rings throughout the city, with thousands of newcomers from Africa settling down, going to school, raising their families, and trying to create a future. There are more young people in Androscoggin County than anywhere else in Maine, the "oldest" state in the U.S. Safiya wanted to get her voice into the mix.
When I reached out to Mo, who has become a close friend, early in the afternoon on Election Day to wish the family luck, he replied with a photo of himself and his friends -- soccer players, of course -- still canvassing for his sister, getting out every last vote they could. It would be several more hours before he would text again, but when he did, the unofficial results were in.
"She wonnnnnh!!!!" read the text.
Nothing else needed to be said.
Despite a lot of ugliness, including and especially the racist and xenophobic trolls who infiltrated her social media spaces (and some of my own), Safiya Khalid had done it. She won. Endorsed by just about everyone, surrounded by supporters and helpers, Safiya Khalid mobilized a historic door-to-door campaign for City Council that brought with it a huge victory.
I asked Mo this morning how he felt about all this, how he felt about his sister achieving what she did. He replied: Safiya overcame so many obstacles, I can't find the words to describe how much we're proud of her. Internet trolls could not stop her, threats could not stop her. She's the perspective the city needs. It's a really big deal, a tremendous transformation for this city.
Lewiston is a city that has experienced a lot of transformation in a very short period of time. An influx of newcomers over the last decade and a half, downtown's ongoing rebirth, the expansion of the high school's athletic fields, the building of a new elementary school, and now a referendum voted just yesterday by an overwhelming margin that authorizes how the high school itself will be bigger before too long.
And there is soccer, of course, which has become one of the constants in this ever-changing city. On Saturday, the Lewiston Blue Devils Boys Soccer team will head back to the state final looking for a third straight title, and a fourth in five years. I hope the Falmouth Yachtsmen are ready. Because when Lewiston wins, American wins.
by Cynthia Anderson
Excerpt from Chapter 13 in Home Now (2019)
New immigrants work throughout L-A [Lewiston-Auburn]—in both of the hospitals, Argo, Bates College, the cities' banks and hotels, manufacturing plants, Walmart, supermarkets, and as childcare providers, shopkeepers, farmers, caseworkers, home health aides. Anti-Islamists claim that refugees and asylum seekers take jobs that should go to native-born citizens. But Maine needs workers. It still has the highest median age of any state—and labor shortages in several sectors, including agriculture, hospitality, and retail. For years Maine's innkeepers and restaurant owners have imported workers on H-2B visas to fill summer jobs.
According to Phil Nadeau, by late 2002 close to half of Lewiston's adult Somalis had found jobs. As more refugees arrived, that percentage remained steady for years before rising at the end of the decade. Early news stories reported employers reluctant to hire Somalis because of concerns about Muslim culture. But by 2007, when I wrote a magazine piece about Lewiston, things were changing. I profiled Mohamed Maalin, who worked on the manufacturing floor at Dingley Press. If he needed to pray during a shift, a crewmate covered for him. "It's worked out," a manager said. "He's a great employee." Last summer, driving west on Route 196 into Lewiston, I noticed Dingley had a recruiting table set up outdoors. It was there for days. One afternoon I saw a van pull up. Two black men got out, walked toward the table. The company's workforce is now 20 percent Somali and other African newcomers.
The availability of workers in the L-A area has drawn employers. L.L. Bean opened a new boot-making plant in Lewiston in June 2017. "Demographics are definitely part of it," says Bean shift manager Rick Valentine. "We wanted to feel confident we could fill the jobs." In some cases, Bean also receives tax credits for hiring refugees.
When machines at the new plant and in nearby Brunswick are fully running, 450 boot-making employees will beat back a near-constant backlog. Twenty-seven-year-old Abdiweli Said is one of them. He grew up in Dadaab and came to the US with older siblings. At LHS he played varsity soccer. After that he went on to community college and then to USM, where he studied international relations until the costs and the commute got to him.
In the four years he's worked at Bean, Abdiweli has absorbed the lore. How back in 1912, L.L. got tired of wet feet while hunting and designed himself some boots. Founded a company, mailed one hundred pairs of boots to customers—satisfaction guaranteed—and got ninety back. Nearly went out of business, but figured out just in time why the bottoms were tearing from the uppers. Last year the company produced 600,000 pairs of its iconic boot. Abdiweli owns a pair. Actually, he owns two, but a friend appropriated the other pair last winter.
One summer afternoon, Abdiweli works second shift. He and his crewmates surround a device that forms polymer soles and bottoms. Leather uppers get sewn on later. On the manufacturing floor: a mechanical roar but surprisingly little smell. People fit socks onto sized lasts, which disappear via conveyor into a molding machine. Inside, polymer flows around the last. The resulting piece—picture a rubber moccasin with no sole—is heat-fused with its matching bottom into a waterproof half-boot. An aperture opens and, in a maneuver that conjures a sportsman being ejected feetfirst, the boots emerge soles-up on metal legs.
Robotic arms pluck the boots off the feet. Abdiweli trims excess fabric. Someone applies the Bean label. Two others pack. Boom, a dozen pairs of half-boots—done. Next stop, Brunswick.
Valentine calls a break. Workers gather for a photo for an upcoming grand-opening celebration. The mayor has been invited, and the governor. Bean executives will be here, too, to watch the crew run the newest million-dollar molder. After the photo comes stretching: backs, shoulders, arms, even fingers. Abdiweli leads a soccer stretch—crosses legs, reaches hands toward feet, 1-2-3-4.
Two-thirds of Abdiweli's crewmates come from Somalia or other parts of Africa. The rest are white. "It's a premier company," he says. "We work hard, but they take really good care of us"—by which he means the breaks and the stretching, plus state-of-the-art workspace, good pay, high-end health plan, employee fitness room, and a designated space where he goes for salah.
The prayer space, and the fact that Bean gives Muslims paid holi days on Eid-al-Fitr and Eid-al-Adha, means a lot. Abdiweli's co-worker Safiya Khalid remembers a different experience at Kmart where a supervisor admonished her for speaking Somali during a break. "There was no understanding," she says.
"Expect diversity," people are told when they apply to Bean. Valentine says he sees people and personalities, not ethnicity. "When you work with someone day after day—skin color, head coverings, all that sort of disappears." Everyone is known for something particular to their person—Abdiweli's quick hands and droll sense of humor; Safiya's ability to multitask two stations at once.
As immigrants in Lewiston have gained traction and established lives, some have expanded their social networks to include longtime residents who seem in need. Aba Abu, the Trinity Jubilee caseworker, also drives a bus that picks up kids with special needs. One of her passengers is a white boy who lives with his father. The father, overwhelmed, often sends his son to school wearing the same clothes as the day before. "It was sad to see him like that in the morning," Aba said. So she started buying shirts to send home with the boy.
Acculturation has turned out to work both ways. Newcomers adapt but also influence the broader community. At CMCC an instructor reports that Somali eagerness for education is contagious. "When [other students] see refugees taking their educational opportunities seriously, it establishes a certain climate," he says. Last winter, on an afternoon when Nasafari was in class, about a third of the students in the CMCC cafeteria were new immigrants.
At the institutional level, advocates say racial equality is closer than it was a decade ago—but not achieved. "Look, we've made progress in Lewiston, but we're not there yet," says Fowsia Musse, director of Maine Community Integration. Musse and others cite improvements: organizations in which services are provided horizontally rather than vertically—that is, new immigrants helping each other rather than being "helped" by white administrators; newcomers employed in city institutions as other than interpreters and cultural brokers; a school system that while imperfect still graduates most of its new-immigrant kids—and sends many on to college.
Email Interview with Amy Bass and Cynthia Anderson
November 18-20, 2019
AfricaFocus: Both of you stress how Lewiston has welcomed Somali and other African immigrants despite anti-immigrant sentiment by many in the Lewiston community, further fueled by anti-immigrant rhetoric and policy at the national level. How do you see this playing out in Lewiston since you completed writing your books, and what additional difficulties do you see for 2020, with an approaching national election?
Amy Bass: Talking about Lewiston - or any community undergoing rapid transformation - means it is constantly a story of steps forward and steps back. There will be fractures, and there have certainly been fractures since ONE GOAL came out, but there will also be what I would call "coming togethers." And I think that what you have to hope for is that each fracture's lasting damage will be minimized, and the tools that have been assembled over the last decade or so will be put to use quickly, making each coming together moment more meaningful, stronger, and with a longer lasting impact. I think the recent election of Safiya is a truly bright moment in so many ways - to be the first person elected. Everything she encountered in terms of hateful trolls was highly unoriginal and expected, but it doesn't make any of it easier to stand. Yet she persisted and persevered and now will represent Lewiston. But there are always stormy waters ahead - these things are not new, but they are, perhaps, newly emboldened. And figuring out paths forward will still require organization, community, and, quite honestly, bravery.
Cynthia Anderson: I feel hopeful. HOME NOW ends in January 2019, with the inauguration of a new Maine governor, progressive Janet Mills. The prior governor had tried to withdraw the state from the federal refugee resettlement program and held anti-immigrant views. In choosing Mills, a Democrat and new-immigrant advocate, voters spoke.
Refugees and asylees are a visible change not just in Lewiston but in Maine overall. Integrating has been hard work—for the newcomers and for the cities where they settled. It's taken time and money and concerted effort. It still does. One message of the 2018 midterm seemed to be that Mainers as a whole feel the effort is worth it, that they believe they're collectively becoming something greater than they used to be.
AfricaFocus: You note that strong leaders in the school system and city administration were key to crafting constructive policies. Several Lewiston mayors with anti-immigrant views, for their part, seem to have been catalytic in evoking a backlash of support for immigrants. City council members, on the other hand, do not appear prominently in either of your narratives. With this fall´s election of Safiya Khalid to the council as well as a new mayor, do you anticipate greater collaboration in a positive vein, or are there likely to be new points of tension?
Amy Bass: See above - I guess I answered both.
Cynthia Anderson: Safiya Khalid brings new consciousness and a new perspective to the city council, so I anticipate points of tension and greater collaboration, both.
Safiya's election is momentous. Media coverage focused on her victory in spite of the trolls' ugliness, but the real story is that Ward 5—which is not majority new-immigrant— gave her 70 percent of their vote. To me this suggests evolving ease between longtime Lewistonians and newcomers. This is the real news. Again and again in writing HOME NOW I saw that the most vocal anti-Muslim and anti-refugee voices in the state belonged to those who neither live among nor know newcomers. Familiarity has yielded acceptance.
AfricaFocus: An AP story in 2017 stressed the contrast in views on immigrants between Lewiston and the surrounding Androscoggin county, highlighting the 2016 national election results. National research studies also show that anti-immigrant views are found disproportionately in communities with less exposure to immigrants. In your opinion, are efforts to counter these views, such as that by Catholic Charities mentioned in the article, having any effect, either in Androscoggin county or elsewhere in rural and small-town Maine? If not, what do you think could be done differently? For example, are you aware of political leaders or non-profit groups trying to address the issues of rural Mainers both feeling and actually being left behind?
Amy Bass: Not really a question that is in my current wheelhouse -- super specific to local politics, and there are plenty of people on the ground in Lewiston who should it far before I should. I will say this, however: ONE GOAL isn't just about soccer. It's about points of contact - very deliberate points of contact. One of the biggest battles Lewiston soccer confronts, whether it is facing a midcoast team or a rural team, is the world view of the other team, the coaches, and the officials. That is contact. That is saying "Here we are" within the specific rules of a game, a game that emphasizes continuity over fracture, a game that asks both sides to move a ball largely (although not entire) without a whole lot of contact. That's important. So for me, it isn't about the political leaders or groups - it's politics by other means, and in this case, those means are soccer. And it's doing some of the hard work, creating teammates on clubs like Seacoast United, and forging bonds that go beyond that of opponent.
Cynthia Anderson: Safiya Khalid was elected because she's smart and hard-working—voters saw this AND they'd reached a point where they no longer feared her as a Somali Muslim refugee— as "other." Contact and shared experience did that. The point is that the views of people in other Androscoggin County towns already are changing—and will keep changing—as new immigrants move into those communities and/or people continue to get to know each other at work and at school, etc. When I met Safiya Khalid a couple of years ago, she had a job at L.L. Bean on a boot-making crew composed half of longtime Mainers and half of new immigrants. As the crew manager put it: "When you work with someone day after day—skin color, head coverings, all that sort of disappears."
As for rural Mainers feeling (and being) left behind, this is something I know keenly, having grown up in the western part of the state. The closures of mills and factories meant the loss of well- paying jobs, of course, but also a wholesale loss of morale over a generation. And that loss bred longing for the past and resentment of the new (including refugees and the resources they might consume). Western Maine's biggest challenge is the creation of more living-wage jobs—for longtime residents and newcomers alike.
AfricaFocus: Although every community experience is unique, it seems that there might be many similarities as well as contrasts between the experiences with African immigrants of Lewiston and Portland in particular. Do you have any reflections on this? Is there any organized dialogue on this between communities or officials in the the two cities?
Amy Bass: There's tons of dialogue, and has been from day one, when Portland shifted those first families to Lewiston, and created the collaborative. But again, rather than look at organized anything, look at the networks that people forge themselves, whether it is with a group like MEIRS or one like Gateway. Understanding that these things work outside of, and often in spite of, what might be considered traditional frameworks of politics, is critical in understanding what has worked, and what hasn't.
Cynthia Anderson: Amy's right that much of the dialogue/collaboration between Lewiston and Portland is informal rather than structured or official. This is partly because with time refugees increasingly have taken over responsibility for their own adjustment to life in the U.S. Newcomers run nonprofits and other agencies; they prioritize goals and advocate for themselves. In HOME NOW, I talk about the strong web of outreach from new immigrants to newer immigrants. Self-sufficiency means having the ability to handle issues within the community—and to talk and work inter-agency, informally, as well as with city officials.
On African immigrants in the United States
Background and statistics from the Migration Policy Institute, November 6, 2019. Sub-Saharan African Immigrants in the United States.
An interactive view of the map above is available from Migration Policy Institute at https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/data-hub/charts/us-immigrant-population-metropolitan-area
Book forthcoming in December 2019: Voices of African Immigrants in Kentucky: Migration, Identity, and Transnationality (Kentucky Remembered: An Oral History Series) by Francis Musoni, Iddah Otieno, Angene Wilson, Jack Wilson.
On the economic need for immigration
Charles Kenny, "The Real Immigration Crisis: The Problem Is Not Too Many, but Too Few" Foreign Affairs, November 11, 2019 https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2019-11-11/real-immigration-crisis
Background on Maine current economy and politics
Bangor Daily News, November 2016 http://mainefocus.bangordailynews.com/2016/11/down-the-road/#.XdA6xHVKjTc
Maine Center for Economic Policy, July 2017 https://www.mecep.org/a-new-great-depression-in-rural-maine/
The Nation, October 2018 https://www.thenation.com/article/what-a-rural-maine-house-race-can-teach-the-left/
Maine Center for Economic Policy, November 2018 https://www.mecep.org/state-of-working-maine-2018-examines-job-quality-offers-solutions-to-make-good-jobs-the-norm/
More on African refugees and other migrants in Lewiston and Maine
April 2017 https://apnews.com/7f2b534b80674596875980b9b6e701c9/How-a-community-changed-by-refugees-came-to-embrace-Trump
March 2019 https://bangordailynews.com/2019/03/13/news/lewiston-auburn/mayors-racist-texts-cause-pain-in-maine-home-to-refugees/
June 2019 https://www.pri.org/stories/2019-06-17/portland-maine-turns-crisis-opportunity-african-migrants https://www.npr.org/2019/06/19/734165446/the-recent-influx-of-african-asylum-seekers-is-taxing-social-services-in-maine https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/us/portland-maine-african-migrants.html
August 2019 https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Society/2019/0813/Among-those-helping-Maine-s-new-arrivals-Other-immigrants
And a few articles of interest about Somali Americans in Minnesota
(among many recent news articles; see customized Google news search)
Ilhan Omar´s constituents push back against Trump taunts (including 3-minute video), October 2019 https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/trump-ilhan-omar-minneapolis-rally-somalis-racist-2020-election-latest-a9170536.html
Why Minnesota question answered by Star Tribune, June 2019 http://www.startribune.com/how-did-the-twin-cities-become-a-hub-for-somali-immigrants/510139341/
Why Minnesota question answered by local TV, July 2019 https://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2019/07/23/minnesota-somali-american-population-good-question/
American football, too, Willmar, Minnesota, November 2018 https://theundefeated.com/features/football-hero-hamza-mohamed-for-a-new-generation-of-somali-americans/
AfricaFocus Bulletin is an independent electronic publication providing reposted commentary and analysis on African issues, with a particular focus on U.S. and international policies. AfricaFocus Bulletin is edited by William Minter.
AfricaFocus Bulletin can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org. Please write to this address to suggest material for inclusion. For more information about reposted material, please contact directly the original source mentioned. For a full archive and other resources, see http://www.africafocus.org