Nigeria: Ese Oruru - a Post-Script

Sketch of Ese Oruru (file photo).
opinion

If you want to know the end, look at the beginning - African proverb

A little over four years ago, I wrote the material below in this paper. It was intended to speak against a national hysteria being fired by our poisonous national patents of ethnic and religious stereotypes and prejudices. I have since followed this matter even when it threatened to disappear under our penchant for finding new causes to fight over. Last week, there was a major development around the story. First, though, please read my comments on the matter.

"Any responsible parent of a girl of fourteen that disappears and is then reported to be with an unknown person hundreds of miles away from home will be beside themselves with worry. If they also hear that she has changed her religion and is planning to marry the person responsible for her disappearance, their concerns will deepen. They will do everything to trace the girl and utilise every available source of redress and relief to retrieve her and get justice. If they meet their daughter, and then encounter difficulties in retrieving her from any quarter, they will raise their voices to the high heavens in protest. Everyone who hears the side of the parent's story will line up in their support.

This is what all Nigerians have done in support of the demand of the parents, relations and the community of 14 year old Ese Oruru for her return to her home in Yenagoa, Bayelsa State from a village in Kano State where she has been for the last few months. This universal support behind the return of Ese to her home is the only peg on which you could hang some sort of consensus. Ese's reported ill-advised elopement with a young man from Kano is presented as abduction, forceful detention, and conversion to Islam in many versions. Sloppy handling and laxities in the operations of institutions with responsibilities to protect the weak and vulnerable are interpreted in other quarters as high level collusion to violate the fundamental and other rights of a Nigerian minor. A saga that has been active for months, with many stops and gaps substantially outside public glare suddenly assumed the status of a national scandal with all the trappings and muck of our politics. A child everyone should look at with responsible sympathy suddenly became the source of the rediscovery of all that is wrong with our politics and other values as a nation.

Ese was, a few months ago, one among millions of Nigerian children from whom you will buy pure water or snacks without a second look. Today, she is at the center of an almighty row about faith, cultures and damaging politics. Long after this dust is settled, this child will deal with the effects of our quarrels over her. Whether she is a victim of childish impetuousness or adult abuse and cynical manipulation is not likely to matter. Collectively, we would have further injured a child that ought to have been in school learning to be a responsible adult, with the support of her parents and community.

There are quite possibly many angles to this sad story that would have been permanently drowned by indignation and outrage from just about everyone who has scores to settle, or a cause to advance. A range of persons and interests from the Emir of Kano to all Muslims and many northerners are likely to feel hard done because their status and faith are being portrayed in very bad light. They will attempt to distance their faith from abduction, forceful conversion or marriage without consent of parents, to no avail. Palace officials, police and community leaders will roll out all manner of evidence that they played their parts. No one will care, after the devastating conclusions of social media warriors has reached many ears, galvanising opinions in support of a child who desperately needs to be freed from abduction and forced conversion and impending marriage.

Ese's sojourn has attracted to the poor child an entire army of sympathisers, many of whom she does not need, and they do not deserve mention. Minister of women affairs says Ese is a wake up call to improve the protection of women and child rights. Hashtags in support of Ese's return have been gaining support in social media. Traditional and stereotype insults against people, regions and religions are being unearthed, with reminders of child marriages by prominent northerners, the Chibok girls, sponsored pregnancies, commercial baby factories and entire communities living off remittances from prostituting daughters in Europe filling all social media spaces.

In this bedlam, which says more about how we treat each other as adults than how we relate to our young, there are a few islands of sanity. The governor of Bayelsa State went out of his way to engage governor of Kano State and the Emir of Kano, and publicly commended both for the roles they played in reuniting Ese with her parents. The Kano Emirate Council released a measured statement distancing the Emir and the Emirate Council from accusations that they colluded in keeping Ese in Kano State, away from her parents.

On the other hand, the legion of shrill joiners piling on sensation and crude opportunism reminds us all that we are stuck in some deep gutters as far as inter-community relations go. The Nation newspaper screamed an editorial that should lose it a substantial amount of respect. It said: "The story which was, at press time still developing, has all the evil trappings of molestations, child abuse, sexual deviance, abduction, religious coercion, constitutional violation, a network of shadowy big men manipulating the law... " This comment will force all people with a hint of civilised humanity to grit their teeth and read the trademark drivel rolled out routinely by Femi Fani-Kayode because it appears that he shares the same space with this newspaper on this matter. Forgive me for giving this man who clearly needs help a few minutes of your time, but this is part of Fani-Kayode's contribution on this matter: "The truth is that this is not a love story about two inseparable young people: it is rather a sad and tragic tale about pedophilia, child abduction, kidnapping, human trafficking, slavery, rape, impunity, wickedness, religious bigotry and ritual sex. Worse still, it is an unfolding drama at the end of which Emir Sanusi Lamido (sic) may well have a case to answer. The truth is that the little girl would have been raped over and over again and she may well have Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDs), Vesico vaginal Fistula (VVF) or some other strange sexual disease by now".

There must be people who enjoy this type of delusion in print, because newspapers give it space. But Ese does not need it. What she needs is a quiet and productive reunification with her family, and a lot of time to sort out deeply personal issues. What we need as a nation is to move on and find other grounds for a quarrel. Everyone involved in this sensitive issue should examine their roles, or have them examined by those who police accountability. Where amends or restitutions need to be made, they must be made. Ese will develop into an adult and decide what she wants to do with her life. The best way we can help her reach that stage without further damage is to create appropriate distance between her life and our many preferences and prejudices."

Since this piece was published, Ese was separated from Yinusa Dahiru (alias Yellow) February 2016 and taken home with a five months-old pregnancy. She delivered a girl three months later. Yinusa was arrested and detained in prison custody, and has been on trial until last week when he was sentenced to 26 years in prison. He had pleaded not guilty to all charges. A newspaper that had vigorous championed Ese's case quoted her father as saying that an attempt was made to steal the baby at the Police Officer's Mess in Yenagoa where mother and child were staying. The same paper interviewed the father in 2018 during which he said all the promises for scholarship and support made by the Bayelsa and Delta State governments for Ese's education were not fulfilled. She is now in SS3, living away from, but being supported only by her father.

In all likelihood, Yinusa will appeal. But the court of sectional opinion is already split right down the middle. Champions of Ese's case who paid for her lawyers hail his conviction as rightful vindication. His sympathisers say he has been abandoned and betrayed by his own people who, in addition cannot raise their voices at the reported cases of Hausa children routinely stolen and taken to the East, culturally re-processed and converted.

Yinusa and Ese have played their roles as pawns, and they will continue to remind us that in most of our fights, there are no winners. This, however, does not stop us fighting in filth.

More From: Daily Trust

Don't Miss

AllAfrica publishes around 800 reports a day from more than 140 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.