Ethiopia: Enat Bank Bags Modest Profit, Yet EPs Slides

Enat Bank registered 208.6 million Br in profit over the last fiscal year, a modest 3.5pc increase from the previous year. The Bank's profit growth rate has slowed down compared to the preceding year's performance that saw a 33pc surge.

Despite the moderate profit rise, the earnings per share fell by 13pc to 161 Br mainly due to the 15.7pc growth in paid-up capital, which reached 1.4 billion Br.

Hanna Tilahun, the board chairperson, stated that the past fiscal year was quite different from previous ones in many ways.

"During the budget preparation and approval process," said Hanna, "it was hard to predict that the liquidity crunch would be so significant as to jeopardise banking operations at large."

Last year, the banking industry witnessed a liquidity strain that has not been seen in the economy for over two decades. Aiming to alleviate the problem, the National Bank of Ethiopia (NBE) has availed 14.5 billion Br in loans, in two rounds, to the cash-strapped private commercial banks at a competitive bidding interest rate.

The pandemic, which Hanna characterised as a new overwhelming crisis, came onto the scene while the Bank was struggling to recover and rebalance from the staggering liquidity crunch.

To help customers affected by the pandemic, Enat removed a three-month interest rate for borrowers, especially for businesses in the hotel and tourism industry, and waived commission fees for Letters of Credit (LC) extensions.

These measures cost the Bank about 15 million Br, according to Ermias Andarge, the acting president of Enat, which has 18,874 shareholders. Ermias replaced Wondwossen Teshome, the recently departed president.

Despite these challenges, the Bank has performed well in loan and advance disbursement, which stands at 6.5 billion Br, a 27pc rise. This is accompanied by a 17pc increase in deposits, which reached 8.4 billion Br. The 5.8 percentage point increase in the ratio of loans to deposits pushed the rate up to 77.3pc.

This is an impressive increase, for which the management of the Bank should be appreciated, according to Abdulmenan Mohammed, a financial statement analyst.

"However, the management should take extra caution regarding further increases, as it may undermine the liquidity level of the Bank," he said.

Ermias says the loan to deposit ratio of the Bank has spiked due to the five-year NBE Bill's phaseout and the significant growth of deposit mobilisation.

In October 2019, the central bank repealed the mandatory NBE bill, which required banks to surrender 27pc of their gross loans and advances to the central bank. With a maturity period of five years and five percent interest rate, the bond aims to mobilise funding for the Development Bank of Ethiopia (DBE), which finances selected areas.

The total income of Enat rose by 31.5pc to 1.3 billion Br. Income from interest on loans, investment in NBE bonds and time deposits, reached 1.1 billion Br, amounting to a 41pc surge. Income from service charges and commissions also showed a notable spike of 31.4pc to 222.8 million Br, while earnings from foreign exchange dealings stagnated at zero for the second consecutive year.

This phenomenon was observed across several banks, according to Abdulmenan, who attributed stiff competition and volatile international trade as causes.

Ermias also says that foreign currency earning is the major challenge facing the Bank.

"We're trying to work with the international organisations and exports to improve our earning of foreign currency," said Ermias.

The total expenses of Enat expanded by 46.5pc to 1.1 billion Br. Interest rate expenses rose by 35.8pc to 656 million Br. In comparison, salaries and benefits rose by 17pc to 188 million Br.

Enat's total number of employees had reached 660 by the end of the last fiscal year after the bank hired 120 new staff. It has also opened 12 new branches, pushing the total number of branches to 57 at the end of the fiscal year.

The total assets of Enat reached 11.2 billion Br, exhibiting a 21.7pc expansion. The 1.7 billion Br worth of investments that Enat has made in the NBE bond showed a 12.4pc decline that accounted for 15pc of total assets and 20pc of total deposits.

Its total liability stood at 9.4 billion Br, a 22.2pc increase from the previous year. Its cash and bank balances showed a 26.1pc rise to 2.3 billion Br. Cash and bank balances account for 20.5pc of the total assets and 27.4pc of the total deposits of Enat.

This shows that Enat has a good liquidity level, according to Abdulmenan.

Provisions for the impairment of loans and other assets expanded massively, recording a 456.7pc growth to reach 37.3 million Br.

A shareholder, who joined the Bank a few years back following a recommendation from a professional association he works with, says the Bank's reported figures are good. He sees the Bank as being on the positive side.

"However, the real value of the figure is low when we look at it against the inflation rate," the shareholder, who received a little over a 10pc dividend, told Fortune.

Last fiscal year's average inflation rate stood at 19.9pc.

A very challenging time is awaiting Enat and all other banks, according to the shareholder, who says that the full impact of COVID-19 and the desert locust invasion will be manifested this fiscal year.

"The continuous and recurrent conflicts across the country impacted the country's image," he said, "and this has consequences toward foreign currency earnings and businesses in the service and tourism industry."

He also says that there will be tough competition among banks, mentioning the dozen or so banks currently undergoing the establishment process.

The banking sector might not stay closed to foreigners since the country has joined the continental free trade area and started the World Trade Organisation accession process, according to him.

More From: Addis Fortune

Don't Miss

AllAfrica publishes around 600 reports a day from more than 130 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.