Kenya: Foreign Firms Fight Over Sh2.6 Billion Gold in Nairobi Vaults

22 October 2021

Two foreign firms are locked in a bitter court battle over a 650kg gold haul valued at Sh2.6 billion that was mined in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and stored in Nairobi.

Spanish firm Inner Spirit SL claims that DRC's STE Cooperative Miniere Pour Le Progress De La Nation Congolese Sarl (Coomidepco) is colluding with a local security firm to defraud it of the gold.

It wants the High Court to issue orders barring removal of the haul from the safe deposit boxes in Nairobi. Inner Spirit reportedly penned a deal to purchase the gold from Coomidepco on May 8.

Each kilo was worth $37,000 (Sh4.1 million), meaning that Inner Spirit was to pay $24.05 million (Sh2.66 billion) for the consignment.

Coomidepco mines gold in North Kivu and Kasai provinces. It's one of six giant firms that control a large chunk of the industry in the DRC called the Cooperative of Artisanal Mining Operations of Masisi (Cooperamma).

Others are Societe Agro-Pastorale et Miniere du Kivu (Samikivu Sarl), Societe Miniere de Bisunzu (SMB), Societe Cooperative Miniere de Mutanga (Comimu Coopca) and Virunga Riverine Exploitation Mining Cooperative (Comervi).

Inner Spirit is headquartered in Madrid with interests in the Equatorial Guinea, a former Spanish colony.

On May 12, Inner Spirit and Coomidepco signed a second contract indicating that the gold would be stored in a security firm of the buyer's choice. It would only be exported to Spain upon completion of the Sh2.6 billion payment.

Inner Spirit opted to store the gold in five safe deposit boxes of Kenya's MySafe Vaults Limited. Its owners are Terry Downs (Ireland), William Pike (UK), Moss Ngoasheng (SA) and Ezra Bunyenyezi (Rwanda). Bunyenyezi died in December last year.

As a commitment to the contract, Inner Spirit released a down payment of $47,240 (Sh5.2 million) to cater for transport expenses and debts that the Congolese firm already owed MySafe Vaults Limited.

Inner Spirit now claims that MySave Vaults wants to release the gold to Coomidepco before its representatives arrive in Nairobi to complete the deal. It fears that it may lose out after committing the initial Sh5.2 million.

Purchase deal

The Spanish firm has sued Coomidepco and its principal official, Mr Paul Mohindo Katchuva, alongside MySafe Vaults Limited, seeking orders barring release of the gold.

"MySafe Vaults Limited's officials have since called Inner Spirit's officials threatening to release the said gold to Mr Katchuva without further reference and notice to Inner Spirit. Inner Spirit avers that Mr Katchuva is in Kenya but he is not a Kenyan citizen and is therefore a flight risk.

"Coomidepco and Mr Katchuva have not supplied Inner Spirit with any gold despite the fact that they have received huge sums of money," Inner Spirit manager Kennedy Mua Kamwathi says in court papers.

Neither Coomidepco nor MySafe Vaults has responded to the suit.

Documents filed in court indicate that the purchase deal was to be completed within three months of signing the contract, which means Inner Spirit should have had the gold by August 8, and Coomidepco should have been paid its Sh2.6 billion by the same time.

"Reasons wherefore Inner Spirit prays for judgment jointly and severally against the defendants jointly and severally for a permanent injunction do issue to prevent the defendants, their agents or any other person acting on their behalf from releasing the said gold in custody of MySafe Vaults Limited without the presence of Inner Spirit's representatives as stored at the defendants' premises vide file boxes number referenced as 1601, 1602, 1603, 1604, 1605 and 1606 in Nairobi City County," Mr Kamwathi adds.

Inner Spirit has also asked the High Court to order Coomidepco, Mr Katchuva and MySafe Vaults to compensate it financially for the alleged attempt to "illegally release the gold".

The Spanish firm does not, however, state how much it wants in compensation. It has also asked that the three defendants ordered to foot all legal bills in respect of the case filed in court.

AllAfrica publishes around 700 reports a day from more than 100 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.