Tanzanians Demand Return of Ancestral Skulls

Une vue aérienne du port de Dar es Salaam, le 16 mai 2016.
22 September 2023

Colonial-era skulls had been lying in a Berlin archive for more than 100 years. Once looted as war trophies, they have now been matched by DNA tests with living descendants in Tanzania -- who are demanding their return.

Zablon Kiwelu never knew that his grandfather's skull had been gathering dust in a Berlin cellar for decades.

The news was only confirmed at the beginning of September during a workshop held at the foot of Tanzania's Mount Kilimanjaro, where he was presented with a document from the Berlin-based Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation (SPK).

"Positive" was written on the document -- confirming Kiwelu's relationship to one of the skulls stored at Berlin's Charite hospital.

"I was so happy that after more than a hundred years we finally know where my grandfather remained," said the Tanzanian.

Hanged by German colonial troops

"Akida" is written on the skull -- the name given to the high-ranking warriors and advisors of the then leader of the Chagga people in Tanzania.

Zablon Kiwelu's grandfather, Sindato Kiwelu, was the advisor to Chief Mangi Meli, the leader of the Chagga people of Kilimanjaro, during his lifetime, grandson Kiwelu explained.

He and 18 other Akidas and chiefs were hanged by German troops in the 19th century.

According to the evidence, the German colonial rulers shipped Sindato Kiwelu's severed skull to Berlin after his execution.

"For the German occupiers, the bones, especially the skulls, were war trophies, for one thing," explained Valence Silayo, an archaeologist and genealogist at Tanzania's University of Dar es Salaam.

On the other hand, the skulls were taken away for scientific research -- mostly with racist motives, he said.

Silayo led the search for relatives in Tanzania as well as the workshop and ultimately presented the DNA results to the families.

In a major research project, scientists from Berlin's Museum of Prehistory and Early History, together with colleagues from Rwanda, investigated the origin of around 1,100 human skulls from Germany's former colonies in East Africa.

Hermann Parzinger, president of the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation, told DW that it was "a small miracle" to find living relatives for three skulls by way of DNA analysis, and that it was like finding a needle in a haystack.

In addition to the skull of Sindato Kiwelu, two other skulls stored in Berlin could also be assigned without doubt by means of saliva samples -- namely to the Molelia family whose members live in Kibosho, a district in the Tanzania's Kilimanjaro region.

One of the two skulls is apparently the descendant of Chief Mangi Sina, who ruled a powerful kingdom in Kibosho during colonial times.

After prolonged warfare, Mangi Sina's army defeated the German Schutztruppen in 1891, but the Germans took revenge in another campaign in 1893.

Mangi Sina was defeated, his fortress destroyed and his fighters arrested. The chief died only a few years later, in 1897.

But his son and heir to the throne, Molelia, was a proud warrior who attacked the Germans again, Silayo said. But he was captured.

"On March 2, 1900, he was hanged by the Germans," he noted. They shipped Molelia's severed head to Berlin. There it lies to this day.

Demand for traditional burial ritual

The fact that the Chagga could not bury their leader at the time according to their traditional rituals has had consequences for them to this day, Silayo acknowledged.

"Because the Chagga follow the iron rule that all relatives may only be buried at Kilimanjaro, nowhere else," said Silayo.

If the rites are not followed and the dead are not buried properly, then "their spirit continues to wander to this day," the archaeologist explained.

"Since then, the Chagga explain many epidemics, economic failures, crop failures or other bad things with this spirit that finds no rest."

Relatives are therefore calling for the human remains to be returned to Tanzania as soon as possible.

"For the Germans, it may be a symbolic act," Silayo said. But for the descendants in Tanzania, the whole thing has much greater significance.

Silayo pointed out that Germany is now a close partner country of Tanzania and the German government finances numerous development projects in the country -- but the colonial history should not be forgotten because of that.

"The Germans have to take responsibility and acknowledge that what they did was against human rights. That it was not right and that they apologize for it," said Silayo. "And then these aid projects will have more meaning."

Painstaking choice: Museum or burial?

Zablon Kiwelu said that he does not yet know exactly what will happen to his grandfather's remains.

The idea of displaying the skull in a museum has been considered, however the family will make a final decision once the remains have been transported to Tanzania.

According to tradition, the whole body must be buried as part of a ritual ceremony.

"But because it's just the skull, I don't think we can bury it. We will put it in a museum where people from all over the world can come and see the remains," he suggested.

Tanzania has been increasing pressure on the German government to take responsibility for German colonial-era atrocities in East Africa.

In early 2020, Tanzania's ambassador to Berlin, Abdallah Possi, called on the German government to "negotiate reparations" for these crimes.

Kiwelu said that he has hired a lawyer who will now contact the German government directly.

"I want to fly to Berlin this year and bring the skull home," he added resolutely.

This article was originally published in German and has been adapted for English by Okeri Ngutjinazo

AllAfrica publishes around 500 reports a day from more than 100 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.