Congo-Kinshasa: What Do Deaths in Makala Prison Reveal About DR Congo's Justice System?

4 September 2024
analysis

Prison Centrale de Makala in DR Congo's capital Kinshasa, built for 1,500 prisoners but currently holding almost 15,000 inmates, was the scene of an unprecedented tragedy at 2am on Monday, September 2, when 24 prisoners initially died in an escape attempt after they were shot by guards. The death toll had climbed to 129 by Tuesday morning.

Also read: DR Congo: 129 inmates killed in Makala prison break

But one horror in the melee was that some women were sexually assaulted although officials did not give a number nor indicate whether the prisoners had a role in the violation, The EastAfrican reports.

As reported, Jacquemain Shabani, the Deputy Prime Minister for Interior and Security, said the 24 who were shot defied orders to stop and return to the premises while dozens others died from 'suffocation' in a stampede that ensued.

Some 59 others were injured "and are currently being treated by the government for appropriate care," he said.

In DR Congo, however, prisons tend to be overcrowded which makes them a ticking time bomb for stampedes. On this specific incident, the Deputy Prime Minister said a special commission has been set up to continue the investigations into what he called deplorable and "unfortunate incidents."

After the incident on Monday, the government said two people had died. Then videos of the dead started circulating on social media. There were more bodies than the figure given by the government.

Several buildings were burnt down, including the infirmary, the registry building and the administration building.

In DR Congo, however, The EastAfrican reports, a sluggish justice system means more people also spend months, or years, waiting to have their cases concluded.

Magistrates "the main culprits" in the crisis?

The Deputy Minister of Justice, Samuel Mbemba, severely criticised the magistrates, whom he considered to be "the main culprits in the current crisis." In his view, prison overcrowding is exacerbated by the fact that ordinary suspects are sent to prison, whereas detention should be reserved solely for convicted prisoners.

"We want to say that the people primarily responsible for this are the magistrates who send even ordinary suspects to prison, against the principles of Congolese criminal law," said Mbemba.

In June this year, images published by journalist Stanis Bujakera, who was incarcerated in Makala for six months, caused a stir nationally and internationally, because of the poor conditions of the detainees. They were crammed together and sleeping on the floor.

Since then, it is reported, Constant Mutamba, the Minister for Justice, committed himself to reducing overcrowding and improving conditions for prisoners in Kinshasa's main prison.

One former inmate who spoke to The EastAfrican said the overcrowding is not just a problem waiting for the world to see happen. It has a constant toil for inmates who have to endure congestion to serve their years.

"Let me say between two and seven people die every day in Makala prison," the former inmate said.

In July, Mutamba had more than 400 prisoners released to relieve the overcrowding at Makala prison.

A few hours after the tragedy at Makala prison, Mutamba denounced what he called "an act of sabotage, a coup by the enemies of our people."

He promised what he called an implacable response to those responsible. As reported, one such move is a ban on the transfer of detainees to Makala prison by public prosecutors unless authorised by the Minister for Justice, as well as an intensified process of culling prisons, which could suggest more small-time criminals being freed to reduce overcrowding.

The events at Makala prison come at a time of growing tension between the Minister for Justice, who was only appointed in June this year, and the magistrates belonging to the Autonomous Union of Congolese Magistrates, their trade union. The latter are denouncing what they see as the Minister's tendency to hold magistrates responsible for dysfunctions in the administration of justice.

Ever since President Felix Tshisekedi deplored the "ailing justice system" in DR Congo, in February, Mutamba has been committed to remedying what he called an ailing justice system.

To achieve this, the Minister of Justice introduced a bill in the National Assembly to reform the justice sector, at the same time as launching "a fight against corruption, misappropriation of public funds and leakage of public revenue" by instituting a generalised process for the payment by bank transfer of all duties, taxes, fees, fines, sureties and consignment fees... and several other charges.

"I am carrying out the instructions of the Head of State, and things must be clear. We are going to fight the mafia networks to the bitter end", said Mutamba. In his fight to reform the justice sector, he said has no intention of backing down.

In a press release, the Minister said there will be an investigation into the "the work of negative and mafia-like forces that feel threatened in the fight to clean up the justice system in our country."

AllAfrica publishes around 500 reports a day from more than 100 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.