Africa: China's New Strategy in Africa - Is the Continent Getting a Fair Deal?

The Forum on China-Africa Cooperation (FOCAC) Summit in Beijing, September 4, 2018.

China has unveiled a bold new strategy to deepen its influence in Africa - with mixed reactions over whether the continent will truly benefit. At the close of the latest China-Africa cooperation forum, Beijing presented an elaborate proposal to boost African development while securing its own strategic foothold.

The Beijing Action Plan is China's blueprint for the next three years, committing a staggering €46 billion in aid, investments and credit lines.

Building on the Dakar Action Plan - signed in the Senegalese capital in 2021 to strengthen cooperation in trade, infrastructure and development - the new deal promises African countries €27 billion in credit, €10 billion in assistance and €9 billion in direct investment from Chinese companies.

Its unveiling, made during the ninth Forum on China-Africa Cooperation (Focac) held last week in Beijing, marks a key moment in the strengthening relationship between the two regions.

But while the numbers sound promising, questions linger about the true impact on Africa.

"Monitoring these commitments is difficult, and it is not certain whether or when these targets will be met," says Ibrahima Xalil Niang, an economist at Cheikh Anta Diop University in Dakar.

He warns that a lack of clear oversight and evaluation is one of Focac's biggest weaknesses.

Politics and security

Beyond financial aid, China's strategy this time extends into new territory: political and security cooperation.

The plan also includes promises of training African military forces, participating in peacekeeping efforts and combatting terrorism.

Beijing has also expressed a desire to foster "exchanges between political parties", generating concern that China may be encouraging African governments to adopt elements of its own authoritarian model.

At the same time, China's so-called Global Security Initiative promotes an alternative to the US-backed "rules-based order" by emphasising territorial sovereignty and noninterference.

This initiative, which advocates for less external influence in African countries, resonates particularly in regions frustrated by Western interference.

The Beijing Declaration issued at the end of the forum went even further - tapping into anti-colonial sentiments across the continent.

It referenced a February 2024 African Union statement on reparations, demanding that the US and other Western nations end sanctions on countries like Zimbabwe, Eritrea and Sudan.

These nations, the declaration said, "have the right to decide the future of their own country".

'Historical injustices'

In a keynote address, China's President Xi Jinping spoke of what he described as the shared struggle of China and Africa against colonialism.

"Modernisation is an inalienable right of all countries," Xi said, adding that the Western approach to development had caused "immense suffering" to nations in the Global South.

"Since the end of World War II, developing nations, represented by China and African countries, have achieved independence ... and have been endeavouring to redress historical injustices..."

Although China was not colonised like many African nations, it faced significant foreign influence in the 19th and early 20th centuries.

Following the Opium Wars with Britain, China endured a "century of humiliation" marked by unequal treaties that granted foreign powers like Britain, France, Japan and Russia substantial control over its land and trade.

Shift in strategy

The Focac process is part of a longer trend that began during the Cold War with the non-aligned movement of the 1950s, when Beijing emerged as a leader of a bloc independent from both the US and the USSR.

Today China is seeking to position itself as the leader of the Global South, a catchphrase for the developing world - a group of nations often at odds with the US and its allies.

Its message of rewriting the international, US-dominated, order resonates with African nations that often feel abandoned by their traditional Western partners.

By presenting itself as an alternative, China has gained considerable influence on the continent says the economist Niang - pointing out that this partnership is all about strategy.

"States don't have friends, they only have interests," he said, adding that China's engagement is as much about securing its own strategic goals as it is about helping Africa.

African expectations

For African nations, China offers much-needed access to finance, infrastructure and technology.

"African countries stand to gain from China in terms of easier access to finance and technology, and in terms of narrowing the infrastructure gap," says Niang.

"That's why China is becoming indispensable. China has the money and the technology, and Africans need that money and technology. This is why any other discourse that does not meet the expectations of Africans will not be heard."

But, as living costs and inequality continue to rise across the continent, African governments will need to tread carefully.

"Today, the traumas of colonisation and post-colonial exploitation have developed anti-French sentiment in West Africa," he adds.

"African streets are abuzz with demonstrations hostile to government decisions."

Anti-Western sentiment is growing, particularly toward countries like France, and this dynamic could affect how Africa engages with global powers, including China.

How the Beijing Action Plan plays out will shape the future of Africa-China relations - and reveal whether this evolving partnership will truly benefit both sides.

AllAfrica publishes around 600 reports a day from more than 110 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.