South Africa: 'Construction Mafia' Accused of Delaying Building of Joburg School

1 November 2024
GroundUp (Cape Town)
By Kimberly Mutandiro

Parents want the reconstruction of Nancefield Primary School investigated

  • Reconstruction of Nancefield Primary School, Johannesburg, started in 2019 because the school had unsafe asbestos.
  • Six years and R56-million later, the school is still far from being finished.
  • Parents and residents allege that a "construction mafia" is interfering and is in cahoots with some local councillors.
  • The ward councillor says she is unaware of any construction mafia.
  • A local organisation, Coloured Lives Matter Too, says there was no construction mafia, only small businesses demanding a share in the project.
  • The education department says another R87-million has been allocated to finish the project by September 2025.

Parents in Eldorado Park in Johannesburg want an official probe into delays in the rebuilding of Nancefield Primary School. They say a construction "mafia" is delaying the project, which has been stalled for years.

Nancefield Primary School, which used unsafe asbestos material, was one of several schools earmarked to be rebuilt in Eldorado Park. Students were moved to mobile classes in 2018 and the rebuilding project was launched in 2019, with a budget of R96-million, according to Preventine Webster, who has children at the school and is on the school's project steering committee.

Clear Choice Builders was appointed as contractor.

Six years later, the school is still far from being finished, though more than R56-million has already been spent, according to Theo Nkonki, spokesperson for the MEC of the Gauteng's infrastructure development department.

Praylene van Reenen, chairperson of the school governing body (SGB), says that last year parents shut the school for a day, demanding the department explain the delays.

Van Reenen said the department then inspected the contractor's work and found that some buildings were built incorrectly and had to be demolished before work could recommence.

The project resumed in August this year, but parents and residents say a "construction mafia" is interfering and is in cahoots with some local councillors.

Ward committee member Petunia Bailey said she wrote to the Presidency, Parliament's Portfolio Committee on Public Works and Infrastructure, the Special Investigating Unit, and the National Prosecuting Authority, demanding a probe into the construction of the school.

"There have been a number of projects in the community where interference by the construction mafia or community business forums has caused more problems, resulting in delays. We feel that the government should intervene to ensure transparency in our community projects, including the Nancefield Primary School project," she said.

But Charis Pretorius, from the organisation Coloured Lives Matter Too, said there was no construction mafia, only a group of community businesses "compelled to fight" for a share in the project. "Most of the contractors involved in community projects are coming from outside and this is causing frustrations among qualified business people in our community," said Pretorius.

Ward councillor Juwairiya Kaldine (PA) said she was not aware of any interference. She urged those who claimed there was a construction mafia to go to the police.

Kaldine said the provincial infrastructure department had committed to finishing the school in 12 months (September 2025).

"We will ensure we keep everyone accountable so children can return to school as this is about the kids and not politics," she said.

Meanwhile parents and SGB members say they are tired of waiting for the project to be completed while their children are taught in mobile classrooms which were supposed to be temporary when they were installed in 2018.

"Mobile classes expose our children to extreme weather conditions. When it's hot, they are extremely hot and when it's cold, they are extremely cold. Our children have been asking us when the school will be finished but we have not been able to give them answers," said Van Reenen.

Webster said he is disappointed in the delays. "As parents, we expect the project to be completed within the specified time, which is September 2025," he said.

Nkonki said he was not aware of any interference by a construction mafia or small businesses in the project. He said the first contractor had encountered cash flow problems and had not been able to continue, and so the contract had been terminated in January 2022, after R56-million had been paid. He said R87-million had been allocated for the continuation of the project.

A new team had been appointed to prepare procurement documents. "This documentation required approval from the Gauteng Department of Education, contributing to delays. However, the tender process has since been completed and a new contractor has been appointed," said Nkonki.

Read the original article on GroundUp.

Tagged:
Copyright © 2024 GroundUp. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.

AllAfrica publishes around 500 reports a day from more than 100 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.