Nairobi — The abrupt ouster of Kiharu MP Ndindi Nyoro as Chair of the powerful National Assembly Budget and Appropriations Committee has raised questions about his next political move. His removal, part of a broader leadership reshuffle driven by the political deal between President William Ruto and opposition leader Raila Odinga, saw Alego Usonga MP Samuel Atandi take over the influential position.
The shake-up, which restructured parliamentary committees to accommodate opposition MPs in key oversight roles, has sparked speculation about Nyoro's political future. Once a vocal ally of Ruto and a rising star in Mt. Kenya politics, Nyoro has recently maintained an unusual silence, fueling debate over whether he is retreating strategically or facing political isolation.
A Calculated Political Retreat?
Political analysts argue that Nyoro's silence is not accidental but a tactical move designed to keep his options open in an increasingly fluid political environment. His critics, however, suggest it signals indecision or even diminished influence within the ruling party.
University of Nairobi Political Science Lecturer Richard Bosire believes Nyoro is playing the long game. "Silence is golden in politics, especially when power shifts are taking place. He may have realized that speaking out won't change anything at this moment," Bosire told Capital FM.
Herman Manyora, another political analyst, views Nyoro's silence as a strategic pause rather than a sign of weakness. "By not engaging in political theatrics, he maintains a national image and avoids alienating key players. If he openly takes sides now, he risks burning bridges with either Ruto or his rivals," Manyora said.
Nyoro has notably distanced himself from major national debates, avoiding commentary on contentious issues such as the broad-based government framework, the impeachment push against former Deputy President Rigathi Gachagua, and the recent UDA-ODM pact that reshaped parliamentary leadership. Instead, he has focused on launching development projects in Kiharu, portraying himself as a leader driven by service delivery rather than political showmanship.
The Fallout from Budget Committee Allegations
Nyoro's removal from the Budget and Appropriations Committee came amid scrutiny over allegations that he disproportionately allocated funds to his Kiharu constituency at the expense of others. Majority Leader Kimani Ichung'wah and Minority Leader Junet Mohammed openly criticized him, further complicating his standing within the political establishment.
While Nyoro has not publicly addressed these allegations, analysts suggest that stepping back from the national stage could be a deliberate strategy to weather the storm while recalibrating his political ambitions.
A Man Caught Between Political Factions
Mt. Kenya politics is currently in turmoil, with shifting alliances and emerging rivalries. Gachagua, who was ousted as Deputy President in October 2024, has positioned himself as an opposition figure, actively mobilizing against Ruto's administration with an eye on the 2027 elections.
During Gachagua's impeachment process, Nyoro was widely seen as a potential successor to the Deputy President position. Many within the ruling coalition considered him an ideal candidate--young, influential, and well-rooted in Mt. Kenya politics. However, Ruto ultimately backed Interior Cabinet Secretary Kithure Kindiki for the position, sidelining Nyoro in a move that many saw as a strategic balancing act.
Political analyst Javas Bigambo argues that Nyoro's silence is more about self-preservation than political heroism. "True political leaders take a stand. Nyoro has avoided aligning with either the Ruto camp or the Gachagua faction, which suggests he is hedging his bets rather than demonstrating leadership," Bigambo said.
Sign up for free AllAfrica Newsletters
Get the latest in African news delivered straight to your inbox
Despite this, his approach may prove advantageous in the long run. As Bosire points out, political neutrality can be both a shield and a liability. "While some see his silence as strategic, others interpret it as implicit support for one faction over another. In politics, silence is rarely neutral--it often carries its own weight," he observed.
What's Next for Nyoro?
With the 2027 elections approaching, Nyoro faces a critical decision: Will he re-emerge as a force within the ruling coalition, or will his continued silence erode his political relevance? His recent sidelining raises questions about his long-term positioning--whether he is biding his time for a more opportune moment or struggling to find a clear path forward.
For now, his silence keeps the political class guessing. But as Mt. Kenya's leadership battles intensify, Nyoro may soon have to break his quiet spell--before the moment to shape his own narrative slips away.
