Harry Gwala District Municipality says project to replace 1,451 pit toilets in Horseshoe is complete, but GroundUp found many toilets were not working
- A R137-million sanitation project to replace over 1,400 pit toilets in Horseshoe, a township outside Kokstad, KwaZulu-Natal, is officially complete.
- However, residents complain about water connection issues, broken pipes and shoddy work.
- The Harry Gwala District Municipality blames vandalism for the failing infrastructure and says a pipe from one of three pump stations is broken affecting households on that line.
According to the Harry Gwala District Municipality, a R137-million project to replace pit latrines in Horseshoe, outside Kokstad in KwaZulu-Natal, is complete. But when GroundUp did a random inspection we found few working toilets, many without water, broken pipes and sewage spills, and a clear lack of maintenance.
The project, which began in 2008, to replace 1,451 pit toilets with flushing toilets was funded by a Municipal Infrastructure Grant from the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (COGTA). It included reticulation and building pump stations and the outhouse structures for wash basins and toilets.
Keep up with the latest headlines on WhatsApp | LinkedIn
The project commenced with R29-million in 2008, and received additional funding of R52-million in 2017, R29.8-million in 2019, and R26.5-million in 2021. The total cost is to date has been R137.3-million with 19 tenders awarded to 13 companies, according to municipal spokesperson Ndabezitha Tenza.
Tenza said: "Upon completion of each structure all the plumbing items were installed, and the owners were satisfied."
But, he said, vandalism had been frustrating the project.
In 2023, BM Consulting had identified issues and Yakhalungisa Engineering and Novuba Construction had addressed these.
Tenza said this left only 11 structures incomplete. These would be addressed through the upcoming R14-million Mahhagu Sanitation Project.
The project would also fix one of three pump stations built to service the outhouses, which has a broken pipe. Toilets belonging to houses on this line are blocked. Tenza did not respond to our query about how many toilets were affected by this broken pipe.
In a 2017 post on its official Facebook page, the municipality states the project will be "resuscitated". Tenza said this was after years of vandalism, which had left the outhouses and infrastructure severely damaged.
According to the municipality's 2016/2017 annual report, it had spent only less than 4% of its adjusted budget for the Horseshoe Sanitation Project.
Sign up for free AllAfrica Newsletters
Get the latest in African news delivered straight to your inbox
Victoria Tshebi, a pensioner living in Horseshoe, said her top structure was built in 2008 but her toilet was only connected to water last year. She said it is now working.
But other residents have been less fortunate. Phula Mjwacu, a resident for 35 years, said her cistern was connected last year but the water is only a trickle. The tap doesn't work and has a broken outlet pipe.
Dunoma Sabisa, a pensioner and resident for over 20 years, said her top structure was completed in 2019 but the toilet has never been connected to water. Her six grandchildren still have to use a longdrop pit latrine which is often full. She has to pay someone to empty it.
Residents have been complaining, but nothing has happened, said Sabisa. "[I've] told the councillor that there's no water, but he didn't take any action."
Ward 1 Councillor Phumzile Nocanda (ANC) did not respond to WhatsApp messages or calls.
