Uganda: Court Rejects Defence Bid to Call New Witness in Kayanja Defamation Case

6 October 2026

The Chief Magistrate's Court at Nateete-Rubaga has rejected an attempt by the nine youths accused in the Pastor Robert Kayanja defamation case to introduce a Uganda Broadcasting Corporation (UBC) language transcriber as their final witness, ruling that the move would unfairly take the prosecution by surprise.

Principal Magistrate Adams Byarugaba said the defence had already disclosed translations and transcriptions of audio and video recordings prepared by Makerere University and had indicated that it would call a witness from the institution to explain and tender the documents in court.

He said allowing a different witness from UBC, together with new translations and transcriptions, at such an advanced stage of the trial could prejudice the prosecution, which had prepared its case based on the evidence previously disclosed by the defence.

"The defence never sought leave of court to call this witness from UBC. No reason was given to court why they abandoned the disclosed information already given to the State. They are saying the content is the same; why then run to UBC? Could it be to get a favourable person or establish a relationship with experts who are supposed to be professional and should speak to the work done?" Mr Byarugaba held.

Follow us on WhatsApp | LinkedIn for the latest headlines

He added: "When they encountered difficulty with Makerere University, they should have brought it to the attention of court and sought leave to look for an alternative, as they did when it came to the issue of a forensic expert to analyse an electronic gadget/phone."

The court held that fair disclosure and pre-trial discovery are essential to truth-seeking, preventing fabricated or surprise evidence, and ensuring a fair hearing.

The magistrate noted that the defence had disclosed its evidence, including the Makerere University transcription and translation witness, obtained summons for the witness and indicated that he would be its final witness following the re-examination of the tenth defence witness on October 1, 2026.

"This court finds that though there is no statutory law barring an accused to present any witness at any stage of the trial, case law has guided that ambush and surprise attacks, and the need to fill gaps not disclosed to the other party, require fairness to both sides through openness and fair disclosure beforehand," the magistrate held.

He added that the examination and cross-examination of witnesses must be viewed holistically because evidence from one witness can affect the manner in which another witness is questioned.

Makerere Witness Allowed

The magistrate, however, allowed the defence to proceed with a witness from Makerere University's School of Languages to tender the translations and transcriptions that had already been disclosed to the State, thereby rejecting the request to introduce a new UBC witness.

He observed that both Makerere University and UBC are government institutions, and that the issue of a personal connection with an expert could not justify introducing evidence that had not previously been disclosed.

The ruling followed an application by the defence, after the testimony of its tenth witness, seeking permission to call a UBC language transcriber instead of the Makerere University expert it had earlier disclosed.

Defence lawyer Bernard Mugenyi told court that the defence had opted for the UBC expert after encountering difficulties in establishing the chain through which it had become involved in the translation and transcription of the recordings.

He said the audio and video recordings were already part of the court record after being presented through a forensic expert, but that the defence had not originally requested their translation and transcription.

Mugenyi said the defence subsequently approached UBC to have the recordings translated and transcribed, arguing that the prosecution would not suffer prejudice if the new documents were served on it and sufficient time given to study them.

The prosecution, led by Chief State Attorney Jonathan Muwaganya, opposed the application, saying the defence had already disclosed translations and transcriptions prepared by Makerere University and informed the State that it would call a witness from the institution.

"Our preparation for cross-examination of the 10 defence witnesses had been based on the evidence disclosed by the accused, including the Makerere translations," Muwaganya submitted.

The prosecution further questioned why the defence had abandoned the Makerere witness without demonstrating that the expert could not be found or compelled to attend court.

"For this court to be moved, after 10 defence witnesses have testified, to introduce a new person on a completely new piece of evidence at this advanced stage of the trial would be upsetting that right to a fair hearing which the Constitution seeks to guarantee," Muwaganya submitted.

The case was adjourned up to tomorrow, Wednesday, October, 7, 2026.

AllAfrica publishes around 600 reports a day from more than 100 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.

Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.