Ten years after the Bank of Uganda took control of Crane Bank, Sudhir Ruparelia and other former shareholders are back before a court, this time in London, where a lengthy trial is examining the claims arising from the institution's takeover and subsequent transfer to dfcu Bank.
The hearing marks a significant point in a dispute that has survived regulatory intervention, domestic litigation and several challenges over the jurisdiction of British courts. The claimants are seeking damages of more than £170 million, while the defendants reject the allegations and contest the case.
Crane Bank was taken over by the central bank on October 20, 2016. On January 24, 2017, it was placed into receivership, and the following day most of its assets and liabilities were transferred to dfcu under a transaction whose stated consideration was Shs200 billion.
At the time, the intervention was presented as necessary to deal with the bank's financial difficulties. Ruparelia and the other claimants have disputed that account, arguing that Crane Bank had greater value and that the process through which it was transferred was unlawful.
Follow us on WhatsApp | LinkedIn for the latest headlines
The London proceedings now bring those competing accounts into one substantive forum. The court is expected to hear evidence from the parties and examine documents accumulated during years of preparation.
The case has a wide cast of claimants and defendants. Alongside Ruparelia are members of his family, the estate of his late son Rajiv Ruparelia and another former shareholder. The defendants include dfcu Bank, dfcu Limited, institutional interests and former executives associated with the acquiring side.
One of the most important developments before the trial was the decision by the English Court of Appeal to allow the case to proceed after a High Court ruling had initially found that the English courts lacked jurisdiction. The Supreme Court later refused permission for a further appeal, leaving the way open for the substantive proceedings.
The length of the dispute has also had financial consequences. Public disclosures by dfcu have shown rising expenditure associated with the London litigation, underlining how complex and expensive major commercial disputes can become when they involve several institutions and jurisdictions.
For Uganda, the trial has significance because Crane Bank represented a major part of the country's indigenous banking sector. Its takeover affected shareholders and management, but it also formed part of a wider discussion about depositor protection, banking supervision and the future of locally owned financial institutions.
Ruparelia's business interests have since broadened. His group remains active in property, hospitality, education, insurance and other sectors, and major developments have continued during the years of litigation.
The current proceedings are therefore both a legal reckoning with the past and a test of competing interpretations of a major banking event. The claimants must prove their allegations, while the defendants will have the opportunity to challenge them.
Whatever the final judgment, the London case is likely to remain an important reference point in Uganda's financial history. It gives the courts an opportunity to examine evidence accumulated over years and gives the parties a chance to bring the long running dispute closer to a final legal determination.