Donald Steinberg
13 January 2009
guest column
Zimbabwe’s Parliament, its only legitimately-elected body, should take the lead in resolving the country’s crisis by legislating for a non-partisan transitional government to rule for 18 months and plan new elections, writes Donald Steinberg, a former aide to President Bill Clinton of the United States.
If things could get any worse in Zimbabwe, they have. The country is on the verge of complete collapse: there are no public services, no health sector, no economy. Half the population needs food aid and humanitarian groups say it will take hundreds of millions of dollars of new support over the upcoming weeks to avoid mass starvation.
With the breakdown of water supplies, cholera is spreading. Already 1,700 people have died from the disease, with many more infections expected in the next two weeks. At least four million Zimbabweans have fled to neighboring countries, and the entire region, including South Africa, Botswana, Zambia and Malawi, is at risk.
The international community has been paralyzed over how to help Zimbabwe move back from the precipice. While there are calls for President Robert Mugabe's departure – some from Africans such as Kenyan Prime Minister Raila Odinga and Nobel laureate Desmond Tutu – Mugabe and his hard-line Zanu-PF supporters and security officials have shown themselves immune to international pressure.
There are signs that Mugabe is about to name a cabinet unilaterally and many fear he will declare a state of emergency or martial law to justify further repression. He recently told supporters that “Zimbabwe is mine.”
Implementation of the flawed power-sharing deal negotiated by former South African president Thabo Mbeki following the fraudulent June 2008 presidential election run-off is hopelessly deadlocked. Mugabe and his Zanu-PF party will not accept genuine power-sharing, and Morgan Tsvangirai and his Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) are understandably unwilling to join an administration as, at best, weak junior partners, responsible for ending international isolation but without the authority to implement reforms and distribute emergency humanitarian relief. Creating a government with two centers of power is inherently unworkable in the current non-cooperative environment.
Zimbabwe's long national nightmare must end, and its only legitimately-elected body – Parliament – must take the lead.
Parliamentarians should prepare a constitutional amendment to create a non-partisan transitional administration to govern for 18 months, under the leadership of a chief administrator – a neutral Zimbabwean from the private sector, civil society or an international institution. This person should be chosen by a two-thirds parliamentary majority, and would be ineligible to stand for president in the next election or serve as prime minister after it.
Under this plan, Mugabe must stand down and should never be able to hold public office again. The positions of president and prime minister should remain unfilled through the life of the transitional administration and partisan ministers should be replaced by neutral administrators. Morgan Tsvangirai and the MDC would have to put their leadership aspirations on hold until new elections.
The job of the transitional administration would be to prepare presidential elections in 18 months through a reconstituted and apolitical Electoral Supervisory Commission, and to address the humanitarian and economic crises immediately.
Such a deal would give Mugabe immunity from prosecution, a dignified exit and the assurance that he will not simply be handing power to his bitter rival. His main supporters in the security forces could be offered the same amnesty and honorable retirement. While this would be hard to swallow for those who have suffered at the hands of the regime, it would end the current suffering as well as the prospect of massive suffering in the future.
Right now the MDC has deep concerns over the potential response of the Zimbabwean security forces and Zanu-PF hardliners to an immediate transfer of power. The prospects for a dangerous and violent transition are very real. Such an outcome would serve no one, least of all Mugabe, Zanu-PF stalwarts and the security forces.
For the MDC, the approach I have outlined would secure Mugabe's immediate departure, create a cooling-off period and improve the prospects of a smooth transition.
To facilitate such a process, the Southern African Development Community and the African Union should name a new international mediator to succeed Mbeki. Regional actors such as South Africa and Tanzania should offer forces to help ensure stability during the transition.
United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon should at the same time appoint a special representative to mobilize international help in addressing the humanitarian crisis. The international community could assist the transitional government in the huge task of reconstruction and ensure that all parties cooperate.
If patriotism and a desire to end their country's tragic suffering aren’t enough to drive Zimbabwe's leaders to create a credible, competent government that can inspire confidence at home and abroad, enlightened self-interest should be.
Donald Steinberg is the deputy president at the International Crisis Group and a former special assistant for African affairs to President Bill Clinton of the United States.
Read comments. Write your own.
Copyright © 2009 allAfrica.com. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica aggregates and indexes content from over 125 African news organizations, plus more than 200 other sources, who are responsible for their own reporting and views. Articles and commentaries that identify allAfrica.com as the publisher are produced or commissioned by AllAfrica.
Hhhmmm mm m...Donald Steinberg ... sound like some one whose own ethnic group is responsible for the on-going wanton slaughter of Palastines ...pregnant mothers, children, old grannies and grandpas, the sick and disabled etc etc palastines ... which is very akin to the many times innocent Jews were subjected to massacres and banishments at the hands of various European powers in the past 2000 years. And yet you have the guts to try to apply the same approach to Zimbabwe. How dare you, sir, make a demand that our President, RMG, should never stand for office again ... on what morals or principles do you base your dastard proposition? You are a racist just like your uncle Adolf Hitler. I am told that actually the Furher had Jewish blood! Admittedly, there has been instances of maladministration and mistakes by the current gvt in Great Zimbabwe, but the main culprit for the suffering of Zimbabweans is the economic sanctions targetted against the various organs of gvt ... namely health, education and communication by the English speaking nations led by the UK, USA, Canada and Australia . I am not an anti-semitic person as l have very long term close friends among Jews. On one hand, you rightly condemn the NAZIs slaughter of the innocent but you hold condemnation of the actions of Zionists in Palastine. Explain!?!
Hhhhmm...AKAPFUNDE...sounds like someone whose own ethnic group is responsible for the ongoing slaughter of MDC supporters...pregnant mothers, children, old grannies, grandpas, the sick and disabled. Beating up of two year olds and murdering another group of thousands of Ndebele. Akapfunde you are quick to say that you are not anti- Semitic - liar.
Believe it or not, l have very nice Jews as friends. "thousands of Ndebeles..." you claim!!! How about the thousands of Shonas murdered in the Entumbani slaughter long before the 5th brigade was sent into stop a UNITA scenario developing in the west of Great Zimbabwe. How about the thousands of Shonas slaughted by Tebele raiders for over fifty years ... the flow of Shona blood led the rebel leader (Musirikadzi) of the people, Tswanas nicknamed Tebele-tebele, to call his Kraal "kwaBulawayo" .... a place of killing and slaughter. It is Shonas who were being slaughted by the Tebele-tebele, as the Mangwato would called their maurading raiders. Dont scratch the past, we all have an axe to grind. I did rather stick to the future but l shall not hestate topoint out a few painful facts. But life goes on.
Akapfunde, you have just proved my point. So who are you to point a finger when you too have such a history?
I thought AK47 would turn into a new leaf with the new year! Alas! He is the same crass, outdated, out of touch, full of hypocrisy, hate and revenge!
I say before appointing a neutral government, the bloodstained Mugabe, at the root of all the ills in Zimbabwe, should be put behind iron bars awaiting trial at the ICC for crimes against his innocent people.
There is no future with Mugabe. He wasted 28 precious years to completely destroy the fabrics of the Zimbawean economy and plunge the people into a cholera ridden country.
Yet lunatics like Jallohlaw, AK47 & gand continue to praise the monster that Mugabe has turned into!
Let's just hope that Mr. Mugabe can last 10 more years with the aid of South Africa and SADC, for that is probably the only way that Zimbabweans won't lose their much coveted resources (land, etc.) that Mr. Mugabe has fought so long and hard to return to them (the West's massive lying machine notwithstanding). By then, hopefully, there will be enough people like Takunya_Ndebvu, Rafil and a few others on this board to continue the fight against the massive resources of the West gained from centuries of the enslavement of Africans and the stealing of their natural resources, something which they seem determined to do for as long as they can find African collaborators to do their bidding.
This is a good article, prescribing a way forward from the current stalemate. So what if the writer has a Jewish sounding name? What a rotten a regressive critique. We need to focus on solutions and not empty rhetoric.
See all comments (60).
Active Discussions: Focus Moves to Parliament